I didn’t plan to specialize in hormones. I trained as a naturopathic doctor with a focus on mental health, drawn to questions of mood, anxiety, resilience, and meaning. And hormonal health found me anyway, as a language that explained everything I was already seeing.
It feels fitting that a naturopathic doctor would focus on hormones because hormones don’t belong to one organ or one diagnosis. They belong to systems that connect everything in us to everything else, like a tree with many branches and extensive root networks. They connect us to nature. They are shaped by food, sleep, stress, safety, relationships, and time. They respond to the world we live in, cycle with the sun, moon, and seasons, and undulate through the decades of our lives, affecting how we feel, think, crave, and cope.
Naturopathic medicine views the body as an interconnected ecosystem, and hormones serve as its communicators, keeping our parts in conversation. They respond to and influence our emotions, habits, cravings, fertility, and energy levels.
Hormones ebb and flow across the day, the month, the year, and the lifespan in predictable rhythmic waves. When those waves shift out of tempo, symptoms emerge: disrupted sleep or nighttime waking; anxiety, low mood, or increased emotional reactivity; fatigue or reduced stress tolerance; changes in body weight or composition, especially around the abdomen; and menstrual changes, such as heavier, more painful, or irregular cycles. This is when most of us seek help from the medical system.
The medical model is built on a reductionistic framework that assumes one symptom means one problem, and that the solution is to remove, replace, or suppress the malfunctioning part. Diabetics need insulin, depressed individuals need serotonin, and pain needs to be suppressed through analgesics or anti-inflammatories: one problem, one malfunction, and a neat one-drug solution.
Sometimes these interventions are coherent, necessary, or life-saving. And sometimes they oversimplify, making a more dynamic, rhythmic, and circular conversation linear. In the worst case, they override physiology and obfuscate the body’s attempts to find balance, sometimes worsening the underlying condition and causing unwanted side effects.
Hormonal conditions spill out of the clean lanes of the reductionist medical model. I often have patients come in or write to me with various concerns: anxiety, fatigue, weight gain, sleep issues, heavy periods, changes to skin, hair and nails. “I have so many things wrong with me,” many will exclaim, or “I know this sounds crazy, but I sometimes notice—” They often have a long history of being dismissed or medically gaslit by a system that can’t hold or make sense of their experiences. But these rather mysterious and chaotic symptoms often fit into a coherent, predictable pattern of imbalance once we understand how hormones work.
Hormones don’t behave like broken parts in a machine that can be tightened, tweaked, plucked, and patched up. Hormones are nodes in a network. The word hormone comes from the Greek hormao, meaning “to excite” or “to set in motion.” They are signalling molecules released from endocrine glands such as the ovaries, thyroid, adrenals, and pancreas that travel through the bloodstream to convey information to every body cell about metabolism, ovulation, energy, mood, cravings, and sleep.
These messages respond to and adjust to the body’s internal and external environments. They respond to physiology, stress, safety, meaning, nutrient levels, sunlight, time of day, and food. Oftentimes, they are trying to find balance in a system where communication is interrupted or distorted.
When one thread in this communication web is yanked, such as chronic stress, disrupted sleep, under-fueling, or inflammation, other parts shift to compensate in an effort to find balance. Symptoms often indicate that the system is not broken, but adapting.
Throughout my years of clinical practice, I have spent a lot of time teaching my patients about their hormones. I believe when we know better, we can help ourselves feel better. After all, the word doctor comes from the Latin word docere, which means “to teach.” One of the naturopathic principles is the tenet “doctor as teacher.” I firmly believe that healthcare providers have a duty to care for our patients through education, support, and empowerment. Informed consent is essential in medicine, and you cannot give it without the right information.
I wish we knew more about our hormones.
I’ve had several patients on oral contraceptives (“The Pill”) claim that their periods are regular, coming every twenty-eight days like clockwork. They were offered the pill to “regulate” their cycles, and none of them were taught that the pill doesn’t produce a menstrual period, regular or not, but a well-timed withdrawal bleed.
Regular cycles, more than being convenient, are important medically because they more often than not indicate regular ovulation. Ovulation is necessary for producing progesterone, a hormone that gets little attention compared to estrogen but that is essential for sleep, bone health, metabolism, skin health, and mood. Women with PCOS, or endometriosis, or perimenopause, or hypothalamic amenorrhea are not menstruating regularly because they are not ovulating regularly. Sometimes they are put on the pill to “regulate their cycles,” but the pill does not support ovulation; it suppresses it in order to prevent conception.
Oral contraceptives aren’t wrong; they are a miraculous technology that has revolutionized society, women’s rights, and women’s health. Many of my patients, upon learning that the pill isn’t actually regulating their cycles, choose it anyway. And that’s absolutely fine. However, we have a right to understand what interventions are doing in our bodies: what they suppress, what they add, and what effects to expect. We have the right to informed choice, not to be told that a medicine is doing one thing, like regulating cycles, when it is actually doing something entirely different: suppressing ovulation and creating a bleed at regular intervals once the hormonal pills in the pill pack are paused.
Many of my patients in their 40s are unaware that perimenopause can start in their late 30s, and that early symptoms include changes to mood, menstrual cycles, and sleep well before the first hot flash. In our youth, we were given books about our periods and taught how to use condoms. I wish, in our late 30s, someone would interrupt our work and caregiving responsibilities to hand us a manual on perimenopause and what to expect in our upcoming decade of hormonal change.
If we understood our hormones, we might be able to anticipate, recognize, and respond to these changes, rather than seeing them as concerning personality change, meeting them with fear, or consulting endless practitioners who might also be clueless about perimenopause. There are only 7,000 PubMed studies on perimenopause. In contrast, there are over 1.2 million studies related to pregnancy. Half of humanity is women, and every woman who lives long enough will go through perimenopause, yet this remains a niche area of research.
I wish my patients in their 40s could discern what information is useful and what is not when it comes to Google searches, long lists of supplements, or advice from influencers.
Not everyone may or should choose hormone replacement therapy, but I wish more of my patients were informed of its risks and benefits, how it works, and what each hormone does in the body, choosing based on values, symptoms, and health goals rather than fear.
Much of the hormone replacement conversation around perimenopause and menopause focused on estrogen replacement. Progesterone, however, is anti-inflammatory, acts on nearly every cell in the body, and declines once ovulation becomes irregular or absent, sometimes as early as age forty. Perimenopause has recognizable phases, and many of them begin with low or unstable progesterone.
I was once on a bus reading a book about hormones, and the woman beside me, glancing at the title, remarked, “Hormones, I’ve heard about those. They say they’re important.”
Hormones aren’t just important; they’re the web that keeps everything together, creating the very experience we were sharing, being on the bus, thinking about hormones, conversing with one another. This woman was somewhere in her 50s, and I supposed that she had no idea that vasomotor symptoms like hot flashes, and future bone, cardiovascular, and metabolic health are all deeply tied to hormonal levels and can all be affected by the hormonal change of menopause.
I’m not sure what her perimenopausal journey looked like, but an in-depth conversation about hormone therapy with her doctor might have improved her quality of life and health trajectory as she ages.
I’ve seen a myriad of patients told that their thyroid labs are normal, without context. Patients have come into my practice on dozens of supplements, spending hundreds on specialized hormone testing without understanding what they offer (or don’t) or how to interpret the results.
Many symptoms are dismissed by the medical establishment as “stress” or “aging.” Stress is an important hormonal input, as the stress response itself is hormonally driven, but stress is not one thing. It has phases, shapes, durations, and distinct manifestations. Stress hormones interact with and are impacted by nervous system capacity and resilience. These hormones shift ovarian, thyroid, and metabolic hormones in various ways.
Many of us (an estimated 88%) sit somewhere on the insulin-resistance spectrum, often without our awareness. This can result in abdominal weight gain despite no meaningful change in diet or exercise. It can also contribute to symptoms like anxiety, low mood, pain, fatigue, and low energy. Insulin resistance, or even diabetes, is not simply “a bad diet,” but a distinct hormonal pattern that is influenced by menstrual hormones like estrogen and progesterone, stress hormones, and circadian rhythms.
Many people with insulin resistance aren’t even aware they have it, instead reassured that their glucose levels are normal because we aren’t taught how insulin works or how to advocate for insulin testing.
This gap in hormonal research and healthcare leaves us open to influencers and social media marketers swooping in. We are inundated with conflicting health advice from online professionals and various health “experts” who all swear they have special knowledge and a unique solution. We’re sold complicated plans and protocols, and oversold supplements, in the hope that they will relieve our suffering. But these solutions are imposed without an understanding of what is causing symptoms. Understanding is everything because it helps you discern and choose wisely.
The most expensive, fancy supplements are often not the most indicated or effective for your particular pattern or condition. The most effective plans are often those chosen with context, and the right ingredients, forms, doses, and timing in mind, where the intervention is matched to the specific presenting pattern.
To understand hormones, our bodies, health, and nature, we must become systems thinkers of the Biopsychosocial Model. Systems thinking asks not what is broken, but how our parts interact. Instead of isolating a single symptom or lab value and treating it as a standalone problem, it examines how different systems in the body influence one another.
In hormones, this means understanding the ongoing conversation between the adrenal, ovarian, thyroid, and metabolic systems. These systems are connected and constantly communicating with our biochemistry, organ health, and external environment. A change in place, such as constipation or a lack of light exposure, ripples throughout the human body.
Systems thinking also requires a sense of time. Hormones don’t just fluctuate day to day; they shift across weeks, months, years, and lifetimes. Puberty, contraceptive use and disuse, peak fertile years, perimenopause, and menopause are transitions that reorganize the system, alter physiology and how we experience energy, mood, motivation, appetite, and even self-trust.
When hormones are viewed through a systems lens, symptoms stop feeling random and become information. We can start tracing the threads back to identify where the system might be under strain, what it is adapting to, and what support it is asking for.
This way of understanding hormones also requires interoception: the ability to sense and interpret what is happening inside the body. Interoception is how we perceive internal signals, such as hunger, fatigue, tension, warmth, restlessness, and calm, before they become symptoms or diagnoses.
Interoception is more than a “gut sense.” It is embodied awareness paired with understanding. Without context, bodily signals can feel confusing or alarming, but with context, they become useful data that we can learn to decipher and respond to. We can observe a gradual shift in menstruation or mood, including pain, sensations, energy levels, and swelling. We can learn to interpret shifts in stress exposure, blood sugar, inflammatory load, recovery, and felt sense of safety.
For most of human history, this kind of awareness was reflected in how we lived. Bodies were understood in relation to light and dark, hunger and satiety, and the seasons of activity and rest. Menstrual cycles were observed alongside lunar cycles. Energy rose and fell with daylight. Fertility, recovery, grief, and productivity were shaped by seasons, weather, and community demands. This wasn’t mystical knowledge so much as practical attunement, an understanding that bodies change in response to time, environment, and meaning.
Much of that literacy has been lost as modern life flattened time and disconnected us from natural cues. Regaining it requires paying closer attention. Through tracking, reflection, and education, we can rebuild a relationship with our bodies that was once cultural and natural knowledge.
Tracking can help build this awareness. When we track sleep, energy, mood, appetite, and cycles, and learn the signs of ovulation, we can shift our relationship with our bodies, riding the waves of hormonal rhythms with ease rather than being thrashed around by them. This is how we build agency.
Health is not the absence of disease or even the feeling of being well all the time. I believe health is an empowered state of connection with our bodies, where we become fully engaged in their care, as we are with a child or a pet. What am I feeling right now? What does my body need?
I also believe that naturopathic medicine is not just about the interventions: whether it be supplements, nutrition, acupuncture, or even medication like hormone therapy. There are many responses that might be appropriate for an individual depending on their context, values and health goals. The difference is collaboration and choice. No matter how gentle or effective the intervention, the best one is that chosen with information and consent.
Too often, we are handed a prescription without being told what it does, what it changes, what information it obscures, or what alternatives exist. That lack of context erodes trust not only in the medical system but also in one’s own body. The implied message is that the body is something to fear, manage, control, and override.
In other instances, we are actively taught to ignore our bodies, told the message is “all in our heads,” that labs are normal, and we are fine. This attitude can delay a diagnosis of endometriosis by as much as 10 years. During that time, people are often told their pain is normal, their symptoms are stress-related, or that they should simply manage. Interventions may be offered, but without curiosity about the underlying pattern that can be associated with infertility, anxiety, and bowel changes, along with painful periods.
Hormone therapy is another important topic of nuance. Women in midlife are prescribed antidepressants more often than hormone therapy, when the “root cause” is a shift in hormones, not brain chemistry. We need to have more conversations about hormone replacement grounded in evidence rather than fear.
Much of the public conversation about hormone therapy is shaped by outdated interpretations of research, incomplete explanations of risk, or oversimplified narratives that swing between panic and promises of anti-aging.
Bioidentical hormones, for example, are often discussed as if they are either a miracle or a marketing gimmick. In reality, the term simply refers to hormones that are structurally identical to those produced by the human body, such as estradiol or micronized progesterone. These hormones have been studied extensively. Their effects, benefits, and risks depend on dose, timing, route of administration, and the individual context of the person taking them. None of this can be reduced to a single headline or blanket recommendation.
Dose matters. Timing matters. Whether hormones are taken orally, transdermally, or vaginally matters. Age, symptom profile, metabolic health, inflammatory status, and cardiovascular risk all matter. Research reflects this complexity, but that nuance is rarely translated into patient-facing conversations. As a result, many people are either frightened away from therapies that could help them or pushed toward them without sufficient understanding.
Agency in hormonal healthcare does not require rejecting medical care, but we should be informed enough to participate in decisions. We should understand what therapies are intended to do, what trade-offs they involve, how success will be evaluated over time, and what testing can show. It means knowing when a symptom is expected, when it signals the need for adjustment, and when further investigation is warranted.
The patients who tend to have the best outcomes with hormonal health interventions are supported in understanding their bodies as dynamic systems. They are given time, information, and follow-up. They are allowed to ask questions. They are not rushed into decisions, nor are they left to navigate complex choices alone.
Understanding our hormones is not about memorizing biochemical pathways, hunting for a single root cause, taking on extensive lifestyle changes or expensive, heavily marketed supplement regimes, nor is it about approaching the body as something that needs to be fixed.
Instead, learning about hormones is about orientation and learning where you are in a larger pattern and how the system is shifting over time. You learn how to participate in decisions rather than feel subjected to them. You know what questions to ask, what information matters, and what changes are expected versus concerning.
Most importantly, it allows you to interpret change without panic. Hormonal systems adapt and fluctuate. When those fluctuations are understood within context, they can be met with curiosity, adjustment, and care rather than fear, urgency or self-blame.
I wanted to respond to this information gap by creating a course on hormone health. I didn’t want to offer a quick fix, another set of rules, protocols, or promises, but to share the framework I use clinically when people come in confused by their symptoms and unsure how to make sense of what their bodies are doing. I wanted to create a resource that walks you through your hormonal systems so you can feel empowered in your health.
This course replaces late-night Googling. In 10 modules, I teach you how to recognize patterns as they shift; understand hormonal changes across cycles, seasons, and life stages; ask better questions; interpret information without panic; and participate more fully in decisions about care.
I gathered everything I’ve learned from the hundreds of books, research papers, and courses I’ve taken, as well as the thousands of patients I’ve worked with to create a course for women who want to understand hormones without reducing themselves to a diagnosis, a lab value, or a label, and who want a way of relating to their bodies that is informed, grounded, and humane.
Because I wish women knew more about their hormones.
References:
Bluming, A., & Tavris, C. (2026). Estrogen matters. Penguin Random House.
Briden, L. (2018). Period repair manual. Pan Macmillan Australia Pty, Limited.
Brinton, R. D., Yao, J., Yin, F., Mack, W. J., & Cadenas, E. (2015). Perimenopause as a neurological transition state. Nature Reviews Endocrinology, 11(7), 393–405. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrendo.2015.82
Hitchcock, C. L., & Prior, J. C. (2012). Oral micronized progesterone for vasomotor symptoms—a placebo-controlled randomized trial in healthy postmenopausal women. Menopause, 19(8), 886–893. https://doi.org/10.1097/gme.0b013e318247f07a
Huberman Lab Podcast. (2024, June 3). Dr. Mary Claire Haver: How to navigate menopause & perimenopause for maximum health & vitality [Video]. YouTube.
Hussain, A. (2024). The period literacy handbook: Everything you need to know about your menstrual cycles, period. Period Literacy School.
Mattern, S. (2019). The slow moon climbs: The science, history, and meaning of menopause (1st ed.). Princeton University Press.
Mosconi, L. (2024). The menopause brain: The new science for women to navigate midlife, and optimize brain health for later years. Allen & Unwin.
Romm, A. (2021). Hormone intelligence: The complete guide to calming hormone chaos and restoring your body’s natural blueprint for well-being (Unabridged ed.) [Audiobook]. HarperCollins B and Blackstone Publishing.
Rossouw, J. E., Anderson, G. L., & Prentice, R. L. (2002). Risks and benefits of estrogen plus progestin in healthy postmenopausal women: Principal results from the Women’s Health Initiative randomized controlled trial. JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association, 288(3), 321–333. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.288.3.321
Weschler, T. (2003). Taking charge of your fertility: The definitive guide to natural birth control, pregnancy achievement, and reproductive health (Revised ed.). Vermilion.
“If you try this and hate it, we’ll learn something.”
Sometimes a great plan brings no relief. Many patients come into my practice having read, researched, consulted, and asked thoughtful questions for years. They have tried different diets, bought various supplements, gone to therapy, and seen multiple practitioners. Some things may have helped briefly, then outcomes faded. Other protocols or so-called solutions felt overwhelming and expensive, preventing them from even starting.
We are surrounded by conflicting advice, and each new option carries the burden of dashed hopes, “What if this doesn’t work either?” Over time, choosing starts to feel more challenging than staying uncertain. We want to feel better, but the act of committing to a plan, a practitioner, or a direction feels utterly exhausting.
This is a common experience for patients entering the holistic and natural health space, where treatment plans often involve lifestyle changes. Sometimes, even well-meaning practitioners dismiss it as “noncompliance” or “lack of readiness.” But the issue is rarely a lack of will, motivation or intelligence. Patients in this state are often highly active and engaged in healing. Over time, enough disappointment, overwhelm, or contradictory guidance leads their bodies to expect that effort won’t lead to results. Their system isn’t refusing to heal; it’s protecting them from the emotional cost of choosing and the heavy shame of bearing the responsibility.
When people are actively seeking solutions but repeatedly struggle to initiate or sustain action, the system responsible for authorship is already overburdened. Low agency arises when we feel that authorship of our lives is unsafe, exhausting or futile. Many who struggle with follow-through have lived for years, often since childhood, in environments where choice wasn’t safe.
If you struggle with decision-making and commitment, you may have grown up learning that trying often came at a cost, such as overwhelm, criticism, or collapse.
Over time, your body may have learned to conserve energy by waiting rather than acting. This was never a conscious decision you made, but an intelligent adaptation. In nervous system terms, chronic stress, trauma, illness, or prolonged uncertainty can pull the system into shutdown or freeze states, where initiating action feels heavy, confusing, or risky. You want to change, but struggle to implement change over time.
I’ve seen this pattern many times, often in people with complex histories. A patient might come in carrying a heavy file of childhood trauma. Perhaps they come to me with a history of disordered eating, chronic pain and fatigue, emotional volatility, panic, and depression. They’ve been waiting, sometimes for months, for the “right” referral, the specialist who will finally have the answer. When that appointment arrives, the encounter is brief and decisive. The recommendation may be a strict diet, testing and supplement protocol, or medication. Collaboration is non-existent, follow-ups are sporadic, and the style of care is directive: do this to feel better.
And sometimes, remarkably, it works, at least at first. Symptoms ease within days. Pain lessens and mood lifts; the relief is real. Through my years of practice, sometimes watching this from the outside, I’ve found it disorienting. After many sessions of careful pacing with clients facing many struggles, they seemed miraculously cured by authoritative, sometimes heavy-handed interventions, and I’ve often wondered whether my slower, gentler, collaborative approach was wrong.
But, over time, I came to understand what often unfolds next. Without ongoing support, context, or integration, these intensive plans become unsustainable. For patients with a history of restriction, control, or collapse, the intervention slots perfectly into an old binge-shame-control-restrict-rebel-shame cycle. After a period of deprivation, without nervous system scaffolding and the structure in place to hold these significant changes, patients inevitably slip through the cracks, falling off the plan and spiralling into shame and self-defeat.
Not only does relief disappear, but so does the sense of being held by an authority that had the answer. Disappointment deepens, leading to further collapse, and what remains is paralysis: no clear way to continue, no internal compass for deciding what changes mattered, what helped, or how to adapt.
Healing doesn’t fail because the intervention was wrong, misguided, or useless, but because something essential, something required for healing, was never named or built.
In these moments, agency, or rather the lack of it, becomes visible. Intense, immersive fixes can feel irresistible precisely because they temporarily relieve the burden of authorship. We don’t trust our capacity to steer, decide, or stay with change because our system has never been taught to do so. And so an external structure feels like salvation. We are exhausted, miserable, and in pain and in these states, containers like retreats, protocols, charismatic practitioners, and tightly defined rules offer certainty. And certainty temporarily regulates a system that feels uncertain and chaotic.
When these structures disappear or fail to fit our realities of daily life, we’re left holding the responsibility for our health and lives, and without support, it becomes too heavy to carry. The resulting collapse under this weight is a predictable nervous-system response, not failure.
Early in my practice, I felt this tension acutely. I understood, intuitively and philosophically, that patients heal themselves, and that my role was to guide, explain, and support. This is explicit in psychodynamic psychotherapy, where healing comes not from answers, but from understanding oneself in the presence of a steady, attuned other.
I noticed, however, that in medical settings, many patients are understandably impatient with nuance. Patients are dealing with troubling symptoms that demand an answer. In our healthcare system, we are trained to defer our bodies, agency and choice to an authoritarian expert. In this context, I could feel the pull to become that leader: more directive, more convincing, even more “magical.” But, I knew that while this stance might improve short-term compliance, it would undermine the very thing required to heal: agency.
Patients struggling with low agency want to heal but don’t yet trust themselves to carry the process. When patients appear indecisive, demand authority, or continue gathering information, they’re often asking not for more answers but for help tolerating the vulnerability of change. As clinicians, we can misread this (I often have) and respond by adding more plans, complex explanations, and intense structure, thereby unintentionally increasing the load on a system already at capacity.
Many so-called miracle cures follow this arc. They rely on pressure, urgency, restriction, or intensity to push a nervous system into action. For a time, this can feel like a transformation. But without integration, these highs often collapse into more profound shame, fatigue, pain, or shutdown. The lesson isn’t that these experiences are meaningless; in fact, they can teach us a great deal if they’re reflected on and metabolized. The problem is that without support, the learning often never consolidates. We usually view these experiences as something out there that works, but that we failed somehow.
The problem was never the plan, or practitioner; it was the mismatch between the agency the intervention required and the agency the patient had access to at that moment.
In psychology and medicine, several concepts overlap with what I’m describing here, including self-efficacy, locus of control, autonomy, and learned helplessness.
Self-efficacy refers to a person’s belief that they can carry out a specific action. Self-efficacy predicts why confidence is needed for follow-through and why low confidence can trigger avoidance and early abandonment of plans, but agency is not just about beliefs. Low agency is not about a lack of doubt in one’s ability to act, but a system that can not tolerate the act of authorship itself. The problem isn’t confidence or belief, it’s capacity.
Locus of control describes whether someone experiences outcomes as internally or externally determined. In other words, do we believe our actions matter or that outside forces dictate them? An oscillating locus of control can overlap with the pattern of deference to authority, followed by rebellion and collapse when one struggles with agency. Still, it doesn’t account for the emotional or physiological costs of choosing.
In Self-Determination Theory, autonomy is a felt sense that one’s actions are self-endorsed. Research consistently shows that behaviour change is more durable when autonomy is supported rather than coerced. However, Self-Determination Theory assumes a baseline capacity for autonomy. This article points to something that lives upstream of that assumption: with patients whose systems are not yet able to tolerate autonomy without threat.
Learned helplessness comes closer to describing how repeated, uncontrollable stress can reduce action, even in the face of options. Learned helplessness maps well onto chronic illness, long diagnostic odysseys, healthcare trauma, and repeated disappointments over attempts to heal. However, it is often framed as passivity rather than high-effort, high-seeking, low-integration patterns that many chronically ill patients are trapped in.
In the late 1960s, psychologist Martin Seligman and his colleagues ran a series of experiments that came to be known as the Learned Helplessness Studies. In one version, dogs were placed in a situation where they received mild, unavoidable electric shocks. No matter what the dogs did, move, whine, or try to escape, the shocks continued. Later, those same dogs were placed in a new environment where escape was easy: a low barrier they could step over to stop the shock. But the dogs learned that their actions didn’t matter, and so many of them didn’t try. Their agency was extinguished.
In contrast, dogs who had never experienced uncontrollable shocks quickly learned to escape. This experiment has since been ethically criticized and is no longer conducted, but its implications have echoed through psychology, medicine, and trauma theory.
When we repeatedly encounter situations in which effort doesn’t change outcomes, we stop initiating action altogether. Seen through this lens, what we often call “lack of motivation,” “self-sabotage,” or “giving up,” can instead be understood as a learned nervous-system adaptation: why try, if trying hasn’t helped before?
Similar to learned helplessness, low agency is a state of the nervous system, not a personality trait. It often shows up alongside chronic fatigue, metabolic dysfunction that doesn’t respond to lifestyle change, health anxiety, autoimmune illness, and depression. Patients arrive depleted and foggy, frustrated by their inability to initiate or sustain change. They desperately want to feel better, so they ask for testing, supplements, diagnoses, and explanations. On the surface, they’re asking for energy. Underneath, they’re often asking for amelioration from the burden of choosing and carrying their lives. Their systems have been in collapse long enough that surrender feels like the only imaginable intervention.
Suggestions that require sustained action, like regular meals, movement, and supplement consistency, can feel intolerable because they demand a level of authorship the system doesn’t yet have access to.
As a clinician, I felt this as pressure to find the one thing: the right supplement, the proper test, the correct explanation that would finally ease all symptoms. Sometimes that treatment exists. More often, cases are complex and rooted in long-standing patterns that shift only with steady, consistent inputs: changes that require feeling the body change and tolerating what that change brings.
For years, I focused on insulin resistance and metabolic dysfunction as key root causes of hormonal, cognitive, and mood symptoms. Often, this framing was correct. When the labs finally provided a coherent explanation, it felt like a solace for both of us: now we know what to do. I’d suggest a small set of actions, such as movement, nutritional guidance, a supplement, and sending patients off with hope.
Sometimes they improved, then abandoned the plan for something more extreme or restrictive that actually worsened the problem. Frequently, the issue wasn’t the plan. It was that the body was changing faster than the nervous system could metabolize the responsibility of maintaining that change.
Anxiety often reflects this same struggle with authorship. Many patients are highly vigilant: researching, anticipating side effects, seeking reassurance, listening to podcasts, tracking opinions. On the surface, they look engaged. But the engagement is often in the service of control rather than action. The moment a concrete choice is made, like starting a supplement, stopping a food, or setting a boundary, anxiety spikes, and the system retreats into analysis.
Depression, particularly with states of shutdown, involves a profound loss of agency, a loss of the felt sense that actions matter.
In chronic illness, where one feels betrayed by their body, low agency can appear as endless consultation without integration. Patients might move from practitioner to practitioner, accumulating opinions, tests, and plans that never consolidate. Each new expert destabilizes the last, but choosing one path means letting others go, and that loss can feel threatening. Authoritarian care can worsen this by overriding agency through pressure or shame.
Low agency can also show up as over-identification with external authority. Some defer completely to doctors, diets, and ideologies, only to rebel or collapse when asked to sustain the change. Rather than defiance, this reflects confusion about where the self ends and the other begins, often rooted in early experiences in which separation and autonomy were shamed, forbidden, or unsafe.
In practice, this can look like repeated requests for plans that are never used. Meal plans sit untouched. Supplement lists are partially followed, altered, and questioned. The plan becomes a symbolic container for hope rather than a tool for change.
Trauma is often at the center of this pattern. Trauma isn’t only about what happened to us, but what happened to our agency. When initiative was punished, ignored, or exploited, the body learned to stay still. In adulthood, this can look like indecision or endless seeking without consistent action. Beneath it is an intelligent truth: staying small once kept me safe.
Agency can be grown, however, in small, meaningful and survivable steps. It doesn’t come from overhauling your life, but from choosing one thing and staying with it long enough to feel the consequences and survive them emotionally. Agency isn’t a trait that you have or don’t have; it’s a capacity that can be rebuilt.
Consider the smallest action you could take that could be repeated without resentment or collapse. Maybe it’s laughably simple. Eating protein at breakfast, taking your iron supplement consistently, walking for 10 minutes after dinner, or not responding immediately to a triggering email. These are not trivial actions; they are repetitions of agency. Like each rep of a bicep curl, each one is an opportunity for the nervous system to learn: I chose this; something happened, and I survived it. That learning is what builds capacity.
Agency is the nervous system’s bandwidth to make a choice, feel what happens next, and remain intact, emotionally and relationally, through the consequences. Often this means doing less, not more. Complexity can destabilize collapsed systems.
If a plan immediately triggers anxiety, obsession, or the urge to rebel or abandon it, that’s not a moral failure; it’s information. The system is saying, This is too much right now. Plans that are too detailed, too perfect, or too ambitious can actually erode agency by reinforcing the sense that healing is too big to hold.
Time-limited experiments can help. Rather than framing changes as permanent commitments, saying things like, “This is my new diet,” or “This is who I am now,” frame them as experiments with a clear beginning, middle and end. This reduces the existential weight of choice. The nervous system relaxes when it knows there’s an exit: at two, four, or eight weeks. And this makes follow-through more likely.
When agency is fragile, the real task is not optimization. It is learning how to stay with one small choice long enough to experience yourself as the author of it.
A helpful practitioner for rebuilding agency is not the most impressive, directive, or confident one. It’s someone who can tolerate uncertainty without rushing to fill it, who doesn’t escalate complexity when things stall, who respects pacing. Someone who can say, “Let’s try this and see what happens. If you hate it, we can try something else,” and mean it. Someone who doesn’t confuse care with control.
If a practitioner feels all-knowing, rescuing, or possessing secret knowledge, this can feel comforting at first, but often undermines agency over time. It invites outsourcing rather than authorship. On the other hand, you might feel abandoned by a practitioner who offers too many choices and no structure at all.
The sweet spot is containment without domination, and guidance that leaves room for choice. The work of the clinician is not to find the perfect solution but to scaffold agency gently, through simplicity, repetition, containment, and tolerable choice.
Tolerating authorship is often the most challenging part of building agency. Authorship means accepting that outcomes are not fully controllable and that success or failure will belong, at least in part (but never in whole), to you. For many people, this is where shame, grief or fear surface. We might think, if I choose this and it doesn’t work, what does that say about me? About my body? About my capacity to heal? If I feel better, can I sustain it? If I take responsibility, will I be blamed?
Learning to tolerate authorship means staying present with those feelings rather than fleeing into analysis, seeking reassurance, or endlessly choosing. It means practicing saying, internally, I don’t know, but I’m willing to find out by trying something. That is a profound nervous-system shift.
The most challenging part of healing is often not doing something new. It’s staying with it. It’s tolerating the uncertainty, the effort, and the sense that now the outcome depends partly on us. In this realization, there is often grief. On the other side of the grieving process, however, is healing.
Reflection is also part of agency, but it needs to be simple and embodied, asking questions like, Did this feel stabilizing or destabilizing? Did this give me more energy, or did it drain me? Do I feel more resentful or vigilant? Is what I’m feeling a high of healing, a sense of relief, or actual change? These are questions that build interoception, the ability to read internal signals, which is foundational to agency.
Agency is relational; most of us don’t lose it alone, and we don’t rebuild it alone. Safe relationships with a practitioner, therapist, friend, or group provide external regulation that supports internal and self-regulation. The goal is not dependence, but supported autonomy from someone steady enough nearby that you don’t have to outsource your decisions, but don’t feel alone with them either.
It helps to let go of the idea that agency means doing everything yourself. Agency does not mean isolation. It means choosing consciously where you accept support and where you take responsibility. It’s the difference between saying, “Just tell me what I should do,” and asking, “Can you help me think through my options?
When we develop agency, choices become easier, less dramatic, and less charged. Healing stops feeling like a series of make-or-break decisions and becomes a rhythm of choosing, feeling, adjusting, repeating, and creating sustainable change over time.
Healing is not about finding the perfect plan. It’s about building the capacity to stay with yourself while living one.
References:
Apigian, A. (2025). The biology of trauma. Simon & Schuster.
Dana, D. (2020). Polyvagal exercises for safety and connection: 50 client-centred practices (Norton series on interpersonal neurobiology) (1st ed.). W. W. Norton & Company.
Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). The “what” and “why” of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327965pli1104_01
Maier, S. F., & Seligman, M. E. (1976). Learned helplessness: Theory and evidence. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 105(1), 3–46. https://doi.org/10.1037//0096-3445.105.1.3
Maier, S. F., & Watkins, L. R. (2005). Stressor controllability and learned helplessness: The roles of the dorsal raphe nucleus, serotonin, and corticotropin-releasing factor. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 29(4-5), 829–841. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2005.03.021
van der Kolk, B. (2014). The body keeps the score: Brain, mind, and body in the healing of trauma (1st ed.). Penguin Books.
In 2012, Facebook collaborated with university researchers to manipulate the news feeds of almost 700,000 users for a week (Frizell, 2014). Unbeknownst to them, one group of users was shown less positive content from their friends, filling their daily feeds with negativity, while the other group was shown more positive content. The study revealed that when their exposure to positive content was reduced, users wrote fewer positive words in their own comments and status updates (Kramer et al., 2014). In other words, the more we’re exposed to negativity in our online spaces, the more we amplify it to the rest of the world.
The users in the experiment never expressly consented to participate and were not informed that their algorithms were being manipulated. Their consent was implied in the general terms and policies that all users agree to when signing up for the platform. Facebook was clear: we’ll let you play on our platform if you agree to our rules.
While no data was collected on whether this exposure to more negativity impacted the user’s mental health, many who suffered from episodes of depression or anxiety around that time wonder if they were part of the study.
If you’re like me, reading this, you might be thinking the same. Was there a strange week in 2012 when I felt unhappy?
What might have been the effect of so much negativity on my mental health? How might I have affected others by amplifying that negativity?
How else is my social media exposure manipulating my mind, body and emotions?
The impact of social media on our thoughts and emotions has been well-documented, with data showing that social feeds can shift and amplify our political beliefs, and increase polarization, by separating users into information and opinion siloes that grow distrust and hostility (Brady et al., 2021). Likes and “retweets” can escalate moral outrage through reinforcement learning: the more you are rewarded for expressing anger, the angrier you feel.
Our anger then fuels the addictive nature of the algorithms, making us more likely to share and spend time on the apps, further amplifying our negative feelings (Han et al., 2023).
During the COVID-19 pandemic, when many of us retreated to our screens, social media disseminated emotional content related to fear, anxiety, and distrust, while isolating people based on their beliefs and group identities (Lu & Hong, 2022). In a time of significant uncertainty and collective trauma, we lost connection with one another, focusing on our differences rather than our shared humanity. And, the more we engaged, the more this shaped our psychosocial and emotional worlds.
Social media platforms manipulate our thoughts, emotions and behaviours through our brain’s reward system.
Dopamine, the neurotransmitter that drives seeking behaviour, is involved in the experience of positive reward, rather than the pursuit of lasting pleasure. Still, its presence in our brains motivates and energizes us. Dopamine is the molecule of wanting, not having.
Unexpected “variable” rewards, like the random payoffs you get from playing a slot machine, trigger dopamine pathways that encourage repeated behaviour (Lieberman & Long, 2018). Every swipe, like, or notification delivers a burst of novelty and potential reward, triggering the release of dopamine. We feel energized, focused, and alert, and most of all, we crave more. Over time, these micro-hits of anticipation keep us hooked.
As we play (or scroll) on, the repeated stimulation desensitizes our dopamine receptors, which can decrease our overall satsifaction from natural, wholesome rewards and increase our craving for more cheap digital hits.
Emotionally charged content can elicit stronger responses, prompting us to engage by checking, scrolling, posting, commenting, and reacting, which keeps us hooked (Brady et al., 2021; Kramer et al., 2014). The result is a nervous system caught between stimulation and depletion, heightened reactivity, reduced presence, and a lingering sense of restlessness. We feel simultaneously wired and exhausted.
Since starting private practice, I’ve often noticed that particular types of clinical cases tend to come in waves, and, for the last two weeks, the theme among my psychotherapy and naturopathic patients has been burnout.
This week alone, ten clients described feeling trapped on a treadmill of constant doing that feels both meaningless and incredibly demanding. Even vacations and downtime no longer feel restorative. Virtually all of them confessed to fantasizing about escaping it all: moving to a sleepy beach town or buying land to garden and raise chickens on. Does this sound good to you, too?
Then, you’re not alone.
The central question is an existential one: why don’t I feel satisfied with my life?
It may be due to global and economic uncertainty, the side effects of late-stage capitalism, or the psychological and emotional aftermath of the pandemic. But the fact of the matter is, we’re running without an end, with a lost sense of purpose, and we’re exhausted.
This pattern in my practice feels bigger than individual moral exhaustion: it’s a kind of collective depletion of dopamine.
Dopamine is the molecule of more: do more, think more, consume more, produce more (Lieberman & Long, 2018). It is the molecule of desire: future thinking and forward momentum. While on our endless treadmills, dopamine urges us on, with cortisol close behind, nipping at our heels.
Having is a phenomenon regulated by other neurochemicals, such as serotonin, GABA, acetylcholine, or oxytocin. They are here-and-now chemicals present while we’re resting, enjoying, basking in the fruits of our labour.
There’s a curious paradox in this stressed-out state: we struggle to relax fully. We know we should do some yoga, go for a walk, meditate, or even sleep, but instead we scroll on the couch, shovel sugar into our mouths, and overconsume alcohol.
When dopamine and cortisol stimulate our stress and reward systems for too long, rest can feel impossible, leading to overwhelming feelings of guilt and restlessness. There’s still so much to do. Stillness can feel like a threat to stressed systems. And so our minds continue to seek stimulation, even when exhausted.
Why is rest so hard in a dopamine-depleted state? When the brain has been used to constant novelty, the nervous system can interpret stillness as deprivation. In that depleted state, rest can feel uncomfortable. Our minds search for something to do, to replenish our dopamine levels: scrolling, snacking, or even working more. Yet, as you might have guessed, these bursts only perpetuate depletion, which can keep our bodies in a low-grade state of constant stress arousal.
In dopamine-depleted states, the activation and motivation required to shift gears can feel impossible. Instead, we reach for easy hits of pleasure and connection through our phones, substances, or sugar, which fail to provide the deep replenishment or sustained pleasure that our often tired and overstimulated nervous systems need (Lieberman & Long, 2018).
After an initial boost, these activities drop our dopamine levels below baseline, leaving us feeling emptier and more exhausted than we were before—a state of unrestful rest—and a craving for more to right the balance (Lambke, 2022).
This drop in baseline pleasure leaves us feeling even more depleted, depressed, and unmotivated. We can’t seem to will ourselves off the couch—we can’t pull away. And, like any chemical drug, social media can mess with our mental health: increasing emotional volatility, impairing self-regulation, and producing stress, anxiety and attentional deficits (Tereschenko, 2023).
The passing of my dog, Coco, this spring left me emotionally and morally exhausted. After that, the summer tornado swept through, unleashing a surge of dopamine-boosting activities: trips to the East Coast, extended family visits, and concerts. I was social and busy, but overstimulated.
My depletion was apparent in how I spent my downtime. Rather than resting, I found myself scrolling through my phone in the evenings, unable to will myself to get up and do something meaningful, restorative, or productive. I felt ashamed and frustrated with myself, but at the same time, thanks to my training, I recognized that screen fatigue is not a result of weak willpower, moral failure, or misaligned values. It’s a neurochemical imbalance that necessitates mindful restoration.
I didn’t like how I felt while scrolling either. I could feel the images through my screen provoking feelings of comparison and inadequacy, desire, lack, depression, fear, or anger. Sometimes I’d find a cute dog video, connect with a friend, or learn something new, but these benefits didn’t seem to outweigh the downsides of spending time on the apps.
I decided to take action to break the cycle. In mid-August, I committed to a social media “dopamine fast” (Lambke, 2022). A dopamine fast involves abstaining from a high-dopamine-stimulating (and ultimately dopamine-depleting) behaviour for a prolonged period of time: usually a minimum of 30 days.
The fast isn’t about eliminating dopamine stimulation, which is impossible, but reducing overstimulation so that our reward pathways can recover and natural, lower-intensity rewards can start to feel satisfying again. In my case, the more restorative practices I wanted to incorporate were reading, writing, art, nature hikes, and meditation.
The brain strives to maintain a pain-pleasure balance: when we’re flooded with high-dopamine stimuli like the constant novelty of social media, our baseline shifts so that pleasure becomes harder to reach (Lambke, 2022). This can result in feelings of boredom, distraction, and general ennui, as well as a lower overall mood. We’re caught in a cycle of depletion-stimulation-depletion, leaving us feeling emotionally malnourished.
I didn’t want to lose the memories, content, and connections I’d created across various social media platforms, so I didn’t want to delete them completely. Instead, I decided to remove the apps from my phone. This is what Anna Lambke, in her book Dopamine Nation, calls “self-binding,” or placing physical, chronological, or categorical limits around behaviour to slow and interrupt the reward cycle. For me, it was removing the icons; for others, it might be setting tech-free hours or shutting off their phones.
At first, it sucked.
Sometimes I would reflexively check my phone before I remembered. A wave of disappointment would sometimes overcome me. I would open a book and stare at the page.
Lambke, a psychiatrist, notes that during the first two weeks of a dopamine fast, her patients often report feeling worse. Without the constant hits of pleasure, they remain stuck in a state of low motivation, boredom, and craving. Life is just pain. I felt that.
But, if we stay with our feelings of discomfort rather than trying to escape them through numbing or stimulating, we can restore our brain’s emotional reward balance. I tried to lean into the withdrawal symptoms as best I could. I sometimes felt restless, bored, and even irritable. I took these as signs that my brain’s pleasure-pain scales were recalibrating.
In the fashion of mindfulness, I tried to avoid suppressing or turning away from the urges and cravings, but to observe them: noticing them, naming them, and riding the wave with self-compassion until they passed.
To help shift the balance, Lambke also recommends “pressing on the pain side,” or introducing minor stressors, such as cold water therapy, exercise, or quiet solitude. These sometimes unpleasant, yet beneficial practices can help strengthen our brains’ capacities for delayed gratification and patience, thereby retraining our reward sensitivity. When we push through these discomforts, we are often left with a wonderful sense of well-being afterwards.
Over time, I started to notice a shift. I felt a sense of space and patience.As my reward system shifted, I began to enjoy more subtle things: walking without headphones, when I would typically need a podcast or music; and reading for hours, whereas before I would reach for my phone after a few pages.
Most of all, I felt more willing to rest fully.
After a few weeks, I forgot about scrolling. I also forgot about other dopamine-stimulating vices like snacking, sugar, and caffeine.
My appetite shifted. I experienced more explicit cues for food, hunger, and movement. It was as if my body’s subtle signals stopped being drowned out by the din of numbing cravings and distractions. I felt less urgency—it was okay to pause and wait before putting down my book or stepping away from my desk to go to the kitchen.
Dopamine fasting can help heal burnout, as the drop in constant stimulation helps the nervous system shift out of low-grade sympathetic (fight-or-flight) activation. We have permission to power off, which reduces cortisol levels, and this, in turn, can support sleep and blood sugar control.
Once the sympathetic nervous system and adrenals gear down, our parasymphathetic nervous systems can turn on, supporting rest, digestion, and feelings of calm. In this state, we can pay more attention to internal body cues, like signals of hunger, thirst, and fatigue.
One of the most potent effects of a dopamine fast is its impact on delayed gratification: the ability to wait for a more meaningful reward rather than reach for immediate pleasure. The prefrontal cortex, which governs impulse control and long-term planning, begins to reassert itself over the faster, dopamine-driven limbic system that tells us to grab that second donut despite the adult brain pleading that we’re trying to reduce sugar.
More prefrontal cortex activity is the neurobiological foundation of discipline and patience: the longer we can pause before acting on an urge, the more time the brain has to engage higher-order reasoning. Over time, this recalibration enables us to find genuine pleasure in slower, more intentional choices, rather than being pulled along by the next quick hit of stimulation that may be at odds with our longer-term goals and values.
We experience better executive functioning, including planning, decision-making, and sustained focus. Bandwidth increases.
At the end of September, I went on a family trip to Italy. It was my first time there in 23 years. I explored the towns of Pietralunga and Gubbio in the province of Umbria, where my late grandparents, Nonno and Nonna, grew up. We connected with my large extended family, and dove into our shared history. For days on end, I had no internet access.
When I got back, I paused before redownloading the apps. But I knew I needed to connect again and use them as the tools they were designed to be: to help me, not hijack me.
At first, I admittedly checked my phone instead of writing this. Eventually, I shifted back to my old, practical tools: Pomodoro timers, Google Calendar, waking early, and scheduling exercise—I “pressed on the pain.”
And it worked, because… well, here we are.
I’m not sure what my relationship with social media will look like moving forward.
For now, I’m pausing before posting, stopping my scroll, and being intentional about which accounts, messages, and conversations I amplify. I want to preserve the connection, sharing, sense of community, and learning I get from the technologies without getting pulled into the cycle of anger, comparison, craving, and anxiety that underlie their darker sides.
I want to utilize social media as an extension of my values, supporting what I care about: my practice, my patients, my passion for mental health and teaching, and my creativity.
I know I’ll always need to set and maintain boundaries with these apps. I’ll need to practice stepping away. But, thankfully, presence is a muscle—it gets stronger with use.
And for those of you reading who are feeling burnt out, apathetic, or unmotivated, you might also be in a state of dopamine depletion that keeps true joy, meaning, and focus just out of reach. It’s just not you: it’s the state so many of us are in.
You might engage with this state by reducing sources of excess stimulation for a few weeks: stepping away from your devices, simplifying your schedule, considering what loads you might put down, and leaning into stillness, even when it feels uncomfortable or impossible.
You might begin by reclaiming agency in small ways: one task, one boundary, or one decision at a time. Even seemingly insignificant choices can signal safety to the nervous system and restore a sense of self-efficacy.
Finally, remember that rest is an act of repair that allows creativity, compassion, appreciation, and peace to return. Grounding practices can help foster connection and presence, allowing the nervous system to calm down through activities such as breathwork, sunlight, unhurried movement, and sensory awareness. Stillness doesn’t have to be a threat. It’ll all get done.
When struggling with meaning and satisfaction, I often have clients re-anchor to their values: what truly matters, and what would remain if all the noise and obligation fell away? I provide them with a master list of common human values (they are easily searchable on the internet), and I encourage them to select their top five. You might try this exercise yourself and be surprised and validated by what you find.
In what ways does your daily life reflect and serve those values? In what ways does it not?
Nature and creativity can reconnect us to a world of meaning and slow the release of dopamine, whether it’s through journaling, cooking, or making art. Creativity reactivates intrinsic motivation, helping us feel alive again.
These are not quick fixes but pathways back to meaning, patience, and vitality.
Ultimately, a dopamine fast is about reclaiming agency over our stimulation: to choose it consciously.
I want to be the one deciding when to log on, to scroll, and most importantly, to stop. I want to use these tools, not fear them, escape them, or be ruled by them. Freedom is the power to choose: connection and presence over compulsion and impulse. It’s learning to participate while protecting our productivity and peace.
somewhere,
there is a version of me
who dared to take the leap
she knows the constellations
by name
her eyes are soft
from looking
outwards
i wonder what she wears
i wonder what her hobbies are,
and how she finds her way
i wonder
if she’s ever bored
or late
or lonely
without the glow
to hold her
References:
Brady, W. J., McLoughlin, K., Doan, T. N., & Crockett, M. J. (2021). How social learning amplifies moral outrage expression in online social networks. Science Advances, 7(33). https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abe5641
Dr. Talia Marcheggiani, ND. (2022, May 7). Dancing with Dopamine: Mood, Motivation & Movement on the Good Mood Podcast [Video]. YouTube.
Han, J., Lee, S., & Cha, M. (2023). The secret to successful evocative messages: Anger takes the lead in information sharing over anxiety. Communication Monographs, 90(4), 545–565. https://doi.org/10.1080/03637751.2023.2236183
Kramer, A. I., Guillory, J. E., & Hancock, J. T. (2014). Experimental evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(24), 8788–8790. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1320040111
Lambke, A. (2022). Dopamine nation finding balance in the age of indulgence. Penguin LLC US.
Lieberman, D. Z., & Long, M. E. (2018). Molecule of more, the. BenBella Books.
Lu, D., & Hong, D. (2022). Emotional contagion: Research on the influencing factors of social media users’ negative emotional communication during the COVID-19 pandemic. Frontiers in Psychology, 13. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.931835
Tereshchenko, S. (2023). Neurobiological risk factors for problematic social media use as a specific form of internet addiction: A narrative review. World Journal of Psychiatry, 13(5), 160–173. https://doi.org/10.5498/wjp.v13.i5.160
The sweltering heat wave has died down for a moment in Toronto, and it’s cool enough to keep windows open. The air is light and misty. I love the lushness of plant life all around, the freshness it brings to the air. It feels like after one long Winter and a split-second Spring, the fullness of Summer buzz is finally upon us.
Recently, I had several encounters with a patient who feels broken. The patient stories I share in this piece are composite sketches to protect confidentiality and anonymity. None reflects a single individual, but rather several who embody similar patient themes.
This patient was flooded by the shame of what we call in Internal Family Systems (IFS), an exiled part, a deeply wounded and abandoned young piece of the self. The part feared it was damaged beyond repair, and perhaps deserved the abuse it suffered. Protective measures of self-blame, desperation, anxiety, control, self-hate, and rage were tangled with this part, and also flooding her system.
In IFS, we understand that all parts carry good intentions, but hers were fierce in their protection. Some lashed out in shame and blame, keeping her tethered to smallness, invading her with anxious demands, and smothering her creative spark under the impossible weight of perfectionism. Others stood like sentries at the gates of her deepest wounds, trembling with terror, others fearsome monsters hissing menacing warnings: Don’t go there. Don’t look.
In the chaos of this inner storm, she crumbled into tears. “I’m broken,” she wept.
For a long time, I resisted Internal Family Systems in my personal therapy. “I just want to talk about the problem,” I’d say, frustrated, when trying to make sense of a toxic breakup or the sludge of stuckness in my work and life, and pulled into metaphors of my “critic” or “inner child.”
As a therapist, I often rolled my eyes at what felt like an IFS obsession in the field. I leaned more on approaches rooted in metaphor and meaning, such as Narrative Therapy, the depth and dreamwork of Jung, Freud, and Klein, or the clarity and structure of CBT, DBT, and Solution-Focused work.
But slowly, with the help of a few wise supervisors and a growing sense of curiosity, I found myself drawn to therapies that reach into the deeper architecture of the psyche.
In IFS, we begin to see the self not as a single voice, but a chorus of parts, some exiled, holding the weight of pain we couldn’t bear at the time; others protective, managing our lives with vigilance, discipline, or distraction to keep that pain from surfacing. It’s a tender and intricate system, built in love and fear, all in the name of survival.
Parts work is a straightforward and intuitive metaphor. We use the language without thinking: “A part of me wants this…” and “A part of me feels that…” we say. We instinctively recognize that we’re made up of different facets of ourselves: voices, perspectives, desires, very often in contrast and conflict with one another.
Richard Schwartz developed Internal Family Systems (IFS) in the 1980s, building upon Bowenian Family Systems, in which families are viewed as an interconnected network of experiences that interact with one another in their unique logic, tensions, and attempts at harmony.
IFS draws on psychodynamic ideas like protective defences or coping mechanisms that shield tender places in the psyche, what Jung might have called complexes. Like in Narrative Therapy, parts are gently externalized, named, and spoken to, which leaves room for compassion and understanding. Each part, no matter how extreme, is trying to help. Rather than fighting or fixing them (the desires to fight and repair may be parts in and of themselves), IFS invites us to listen and develop a relationship with these inner characters.
The work involves cultivating and identifying with Self Energy, the compassionate, clear, calm and curious observer who can allow parts a seat at the table where they can be witnessed and heard. Through this gentle understanding, exiled parts are invited back into the system and relieved of their burdens.
The concept of the Self has resonated throughout both spiritual and psychological traditions for centuries. In Buddhism, the self is considered fluid, ever-changing, and empty of a fixed identity. Mindfulness teaches us to embody the stance of self by noticing our thoughts and feelings without getting swept up in them. The self is that which observes. Jung characterized the self as an inner wholeness. Often, we refer to our “Higher Self” or our adult self when speaking of wisdom, inner clarity, and compassion, as well as the ability to hold complexity without fear and respond to life not by fixing, but by deeply understanding.
In IFS, the Self becomes not just a wise inner witness but a secure base that heals attachment wounds. When Self-energy is present, even the loudest, most chaotic parts can soften.
It was very early in the morning in the Fall of 2018, and I hadn’t slept. I was lying in a fetal position on a mat with daylight streaming through the large windows of the retreat centre. My body shook with sobs. I’d taken three servings of Ayahuasca throughout the night, and I was still deep in the effects of the medicine.
My heart felt full of a black liquid that had diluted to tears that were softly moving from me without tension, fear, or blame. I felt held by a looming, warm presence; it wrapped around me in a safe, all-encompassing embrace as I purged decades of congealed and cogulated but now free-flowing loss from my spirit.
As I look back on that moment, I realize it was Self that held me and gave me the space and capacity for that healing release.
As I lean more into IFS, I appreciate my self-energy and how I’ve become my own best friend. It didn’t happen overnight, but through a few late-night initiations like the one described above, more tears, journaling, and years spent single, processing broken relationships in which I felt less-than, unworthy, and unloved, I soften into Viola Davis’ wise words and remember, “You are the love of your life. Have a radical love affair with yourself.” The truth is, our best witness and most loyal source of understanding is ourselves.
Last night I was down an IFS rabbit hole, watching a lecture series by psychotherapist Derek Scott. In one video (Derek IFSCA, 2016), he reads aloud from a piece, “The Good Fairy,” adapted by Jan Mullen, about a client of Tara Brach (2011), called “Rosalie.”
Rosalie was a woman in her 30s dealing with addiction, self-harm and a series of destructive and abusive relationships. In her childhood, she was abused by her father. Like my patient, Rosalie suffered from an extreme form of self-hate and felt cut off and broken.
The story tells of Rosalie, just eight years old, sitting cross-legged on her bedroom floor, pleading for freedom from her suffering. She is met by a Good Fairy, a gentle protector, who offers her a kind of magic: the gift of forgetting. The fairy gathers the truth of her pain, wraps it tightly, and tucks it away for a future self, one strong enough to bear it.
As Derek reads, tears rise in his eyes, and I think instantly of my patient, the young part of her who, in her moment of desperation, may have made a similar pact. Perhaps a fairy visited her too, offering the kind shield of amnesia, trading memory for survival. That conversation may be long forgotten, but its residues of tension, bracing, anxiety, and rumination remain.
Now, held in the container of therapy, with the steady presence of her adult self, she begins to courageously turn to the parts of her that have been hidden, not all at once, but piece by piece.
She lifts each fragment, holds it in her hands, and witnesses it with care. It is akin to the poem Francis Weller shares in his book, The Wild Edge of Sorrow, titled “The Healing Time.”
Finally, on my way to yes
I bump into
All the places
Where I said no
To my life
All the untended wounds
And red and purple scars
Those hieroglyphs of pain
Carved into my skin and bones,
Those coded messages
That send me down
The wrong street
Again and again
Where I find them,
The old wounds
The old misdirections
And I lift them
One by one
Close to my heart
And I say holy
Holy
Imagine being your own best friend, picking up your wounded parts with curiosity, and holding them with compassion, reverence, and love. What are you here to show me? How are you protecting me? I’m sorry that happened. I love you.
Trauma and unprocessed pain live in our bodies. In The Myth of Normal, Gabor Mate describes how these trapped emotions can lead to physical ailments, sometimes even in the form of autoimmune diseases. Shame, guilt, and resentment can fester, turning inward and cutting us off from our experience of self, thereby dulling our access to life, love, and purpose.
And yet, this dulling is not a failure, but rather a protective shield, cushioning us from what was once too overwhelming and destructive to be fully felt in too-young minds and bodies. And so the fairy tucked the pain away so we could survive and go on.
In my experience, when patients find steadiness in their nervous system, a sense of safety and trust, and have sufficient support around them, or a stable rhythm in their work and self-care, old pain feels safe enough to surface. Sometimes parts make themselves known as physical discomfort, waves of anxiety, dissatisfaction, loss of purpose, stormy relationships, or crushing overwhelm. Very often, there’s a sense that life could be so much more.
Grief, too, often stirs these voices. Usually, patients don’t feel quite ready to meet them yet. But, as the story goes, the pieces start to emerge anyway, through “vague discontents, questions, or flashes of images,” the clues left behind that lead the way through the wilderness to a place of integration.
And, the fairy promises that even if you don’t feel it, you will be “strong enough and old enough to bear the truth” in the comforting special friendship of your grown-up self, who holds you as you find and uncover the lost pieces.
To my patients, wounded readers, or anyone in pain who may be carrying the heavy feeling of broken hopelessness, I want you to know: it will get better. You are far stronger than you realize.
We’re fighting battles against injustice, loss, poverty, and grief: real, raw wounds of our time. But take heart in this: your wise, adult Self, your faithful friend, is with you now, holding space and welcoming whatever arises. Curious, compassionate, clear, calm, connected, courageous, confident, and creative: this Self is your birthright.
From its safe and loving presence, you can examine those broken, hopeless fragments of despair, lift them to your heart, if you’re willing and say, Holy.
Holy.
THE GOOD FAIRY
This story is adapted by Jan Mullen from a report by Tara Brach (2011) of a client, “Rosalie,” encountering a guide in session. Jan Mullen, while sharing the story, warns, “Stories are powerful medicine, administer with care.”
From the corners where the silence remains, there came the urgency to go to a mountain top and scream out the whole truth. I sent out a prayer to God, to the universe—“It’s too painful, I can’t take it!”—and she came to me, the power of my mind, the energy of the universe, an angel of God in blue, like the Good Fairy in the Wizard of Oz, waving a wand.
I sat cross-legged on the floor of my bedroom, looking up, about 8 years old.
She said, “Sweetheart, here’s the deal. There’s too much going on here, and I don’t have the power to make it go away, to make it be okay, or even to help you cope with it in a way that’s not going to cause you some pain. What I can do, Sweetheart, is help you get through this time now, help you get through it as it unfolds. It will come back, but it will come back to you only at a later time, when you’re able to handle it, and there will be someone to help you.”
So I said, “Okay, because I can’t take it anymore.”
She waved her wand and said, “I am going to send things that are happening into different parts of your body, and your body will hold them for you like a treasure chest, like a time capsule.
“Your heart, your heart is broken, and I’m going to have to let your rib cage close in around your heart and let your heart constrict so that you don’t feel the pain of your heart breaking.
“And I’m going to tighten up your neck and let it be a fortress with very thick, round walls, so that what you are feeling doesn’t get up to your mouth, and you can’t speak the words. You can’t cry out for help and can’t scream out in rage. And you can’t breathe too deeply to feel what’s going on in your body.
“And that fortress will keep the knowledge of what’s happening in your body from connecting with your head, so that you will not be fully conscious of what’s going on. And I will tie up your ears, so that you hear but don’t take in too much.
“And this is what I will do with your mind. It will store the truth in a deep place, sealed away behind steel doors of fear. But it will, for now, help you to live with, accept, and believe the lies you are told —that you deserve this and that this is the way your life has to be.
“I want you to be fairly still as a child and rather shy, so we don’t interrupt what we’re going to put very carefully in place. And it will stay this way. You may struggle to feel close to people, but it will be a way for you to survive. And you, my darling, will be a very functional human being despite all this pain, because you have a strong spirit and can hold all this in. And I will be helping you.
“You will not forget everything. You will be visited by vague discontents, questions, or flashes of images that will lead you, like markers on a path, to explore what happened. And I will leave a voice inside of you, like a spark of light, that will urge you to reconnect with your whole self, to find this person you are now, who is calling out for help and whose heart is utterly breaking. It may not be clear, this voice! It will manifest as an urge inside of you, but it will be your lost self speaking through your aching body, urging you to come back and find yourself.
“When the time is right, you will begin to open up. It will be a very long process. It may take as long to heal as you’ve been in pain and the frozen place. Finally, your body will no longer be able to contain all this. Your muscles will begin to give way, and you will feel an urgency to engage in physical healing.
“This will initiate the process of truly unwinding your body and releasing what it has been holding for all these years. There will be physical as well as emotional pain in the process. But by then you will be strong enough, safe enough and old enough to bear the truth, and you will have a special friend, who will be the grownup you, who will hold you as no one else can, as you find yourself again.
“As all this begins to unwind, you will struggle to release your mind from the falsehoods it had learned so you could survive, and the doors of fear barring it from the truth. The mind may at first believe that only the person who gave you this pain has the power to take it away, and there will need to be a period of building trust that this is not true.
“You will struggle to release the flow between the mind and body and reconnect fully. But you will do it, because you are a capable person with a heart yearning to love. I don’t know exactly how it will unfold, but the universe will move you through it. You will have to be very patient, very brave, very courageous, but it will be your training, your fire walk, your healing. And when you are through it, you will be a whole person: new but still the same.
“Now I want you to go to bed. I will wave my wand, and you will fall asleep. When you wake up, you will forget I was here. You will forget you asked for help, and you will not feel your daily pain.
“This is the only way I know to get you through this. You are a beautiful child. I don’t know the reasons this terrible burden came to you, but I love you, and God loves you. You will have to love yourself enough to heal, so that the rest of your life will be lived to its fullest, full of light. The memory of pain will still be there, but it will be in perspective. One day, you will be whole again.
“Until then and for always, I love you.”
References:
Brach, T. (2011, July 1). The power of radical acceptance: Healing trauma through the integration of Buddhist meditation and psychotherapy. Tara Brach. https://www.tarabrach.com/trauma/
Derek IFSCA. (2016, October 13). IFS for Therapists #4 Common Dynamics [Video]. YouTube.
Maté, G. (2022). The myth of normal. Ebury Publishing.
Schwartz, R. C. (2017). Internal family systems therapy (1st ed.). Guilford Publications, Inc.
Weller, F. (2015). The wild edge of sorrow: Rituals of renewal and the sacred work of grief (3rd ed.).
“The patient is not a problem to be solved, but a mystery to be met.” — Rachel Naomi Remen
M was a mother of two, in her mid-50s. She booked an appointment because profound exhaustion had descended on her like a fog. She ate intentionally: fibre, fruits, and vegetables. She usually slept well. Recently, she started experiencing abdominal distension and a feeling of fullness. She read about intermittent fasting and decided to try it: skipping breakfast.
Her family doctor had ordered blood tests and called to tell her everything looked fine. I requested a copy and found that she had high triglycerides and liver enzymes. She said her doctor had mentioned something like that, but said nothing could be done. They advised her to keep eating well and exercising, and to repeat the tests in three months.
Within three months, the liver enzymes returned to the normal range. Her doctor offered her a statin drug for her elevated “cholesterol.” M declined, still feeling tired and bloated, but preferring to focus on lifestyle factors before trying medication.
L was in her 30s. She lived alone and worked from home—a repetitive and unfulfilling admin job. As a teenager, she was diagnosed with major depressive disorder and prescribed medication to correct the “chemical imbalance” in her brain. The medication might have helped a little; she wasn’t sure. Her depressive episodes would often last for weeks, during which she was unable to get out of bed.
When she booked her first appointment, she had tried more medications than she could remember and was currently taking three, her psychiatrist trying to get the cocktail right. She was still experiencing a chronically low mood, cloudy thinking, and troubling memory loss. Her doctor had recommended electroconvulsive therapy for her “treatment-resistant depression,” and suggested that her symptoms were worsening because of peri-menopause.
She wished she could pursue a more meaningful career, but with her depression, she didn’t think she could handle something challenging. She also needed the job security and health benefits to cover the medications for her chronic autoimmune disorder.
H was in his 40s and suffered from gastrointestinal bloating and erratic bowel movements most of his life. As a child, he was diagnosed with ADHD and generalized anxiety disorder. He remembers horrible stomach pain that would keep him home from elementary school. In many ways, this was a saving grace because he remembers the chronic bullying and devastating boredom he dealt with there.
His doctor ordered colonoscopies and gastroenterologist referrals, but when nothing showed up on testing, he was diagnosed with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), linked to stress.
To find relief, H researched alternative therapies like meditation, red light therapy, cold plunges, and ketogenic diets. Could his mental health issues be connected to his gut health? His doctor said that diet was unlikely to shift his symptoms and that his anxiety, ADHD and IBS were separate and unrelated.
These examples are from various patients I’ve seen over the years—their names and identifying details have been changed and combined with other patients to represent overarching patterns in everyday healthcare experiences. There are differences in the details, but they, I, and hundreds of other patients, have all found ourselves in a similar space: leaving an unproductive and invalidating healthcare encounter in tears, feeling utterly alone, unseen and unheard.
M, L, and H all presented with a constellation of symptoms affecting various body systems, including their digestive organs, brain and nervous system, hormones, immune system, muscles, and metabolism. Their doctors were supportive and well-meaning, ordering blood tests and imaging, making referrals, and providing solutions within their scope of knowledge.
However, when their tests were normal, medications failed to provide relief, or symptoms escaped defined diagnostic categories, they and their practitioners hit a wall.
Like many others, these patients are victims of a medical model that overlooks the broader context in which people seeking healthcare solutions often find themselves. Symptoms may be dismissed, data is prioritized over experience, mental health is either minimized or overmedicalized, and care is separated into systems: brain, body, digestive system, hormones, or heart.
What was the significance of M’s elevated liver enzymes on her bloating and fatigue? Did her history of caloric restriction and people-pleasing predispose her to the burnout and exhaustion she was experiencing? How might intermittent fasting and overfunctioning have perpetuated her condition? How did the absence of a clear and defined disease negate her experience of being unwell and prevent her from finding the tools and strategies that might have helped?
What is the connection between L’s longstanding untreatable depression, autoimmune disease, and inflammation? How did carrying her diagnostic labels since adolescence impact her identity, hope for the future, and career aspirations?
Is it true that H’s anxiety, ADHD, and IBS were unrelated? How might bullying have impacted his physical and mental health? How might biohacking give him a sense of agency, or even creativity (May, 1983)? When does striving to understand slip too far into micromanagement, health anxiety, orthorexia, and self-punishment?
One of the reasons I became a naturopathic doctor is to work within the space and framework to ask these questions: Who is the person in front of me? What is their story? How can I serve?
For all three case examples, their family doctor’s office was the first place they sought help. Patients in the current healthcare system are fragmented into signs, symptoms, diagnoses, and labels. They are offered reductionistic linear solutions: one drug, test, or treatment per problem. When solutions are exhausted, practitioners throw up their arms: “It’s peri-menopause/aging/stress.” The system leaves little room for curiosity, meaning-making, transformation, growth, or uncertainty.
The result is a breakdown in the doctor-patient relationship and a lack of faith in the healthcare system. For patients, this can lead to a sense of powerlessness and mistrust of their bodies. Practitioners can feel frustrated, compassion-fatigued, and burned out.
In 1977, the journal Science published a seminal paper by George Engel entitled “The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine.” In it, Engel outlines the limitations of the biomedical model and introduces a new approach to healing: the Biopsychosocial model, a holistic framework that acknowledges the interplay of biology, psychological, and social factors on health and illness.
Even nearly 50 years after Engel’s paper, modern medicine still largely adheres to the biomedical model. The model is based on the tenets of reductionism and dualism, which offer relative simplicity and a sense of certainty. These dogmas are difficult to release in favour of a more complex, flexible, multifaceted, and interconnected holistic framework.
Reductionism is a philosophical approach that seeks to understand the whole by breaking it down into its constituent parts. Health and illness can, therefore, be understood at the molecular and chemical levels: type I diabetes is a disease characterized by insulin deficiency, and coronary artery disease results from high cholesterol levels. However, a Lego sculpture cannot be recreated by turning over and examining the little coloured plastic pieces; the human organism is more than the sum of its parts. Our bodies are layered, interwoven, and interdependent dynamic systems that depend on and interact with the social world and environment.
We are wild, magical, and endlessly puzzling, with pieces and parts that weave, knot, and untangle in molecular dances that connect, disappear, and remanifest from the unseen depths of the mysterious beyond. The truth is as horrifying as it is accurate: despite the degrees, papers and expert-level bravado, we understand very little about ourselves.
Emerson M. Pugh puts it famously and beautifully: “If the human brain were so simple that we could understand it, we would be so simple that we couldn’t.”
The Human Genome Project is a prime example of the limitations of reductionism. Launched in the late 1990s and early 2000s, it aimed to decipher the body’s genetic code to understand the language of disease. While the project helped advance science in many ways, it failed to provide significant breakthroughs in disease research. It turns out that there is more to understanding Shakespeare’s works than reciting the alphabet.
Some diseases are caused by specific mutations in individual genes. Still, the reality is far more complex, with the relationship between genes and health involving combinations of mutations and epigenetics —interactions with the environment, life experiences, and behaviours that impact our DNA.
The second feature of the biomedical model is mind-body dualism, developed and promoted by Descartes in the 17th century. He postulated that the body is a material entity that could be dissected, examined, and altered without impacting the mind, which was considered ethereal and non-physical. The body might have been considered a temporary vessel for the mind, but the two were governed by different principles and troubles of the mind were not thought to impact the body, and vice versa.
The healthcare system still presumes mind-body dualism. We have psychiatrists for the mind and neurologists for the brain. Dead-end symptoms that evade disease categories are hand-waved as “stress” or “psychosomatic” (which paradoxically assumes a connection between mind and body).
Centuries of adopting this ill-fitting assumption have led to the obvious and pervasive mind-body problem: if the mind and body are distinct, then how can anxious thoughts quicken our heartbeat, trauma impact our immune system, stress lead to indigestion, and a placebo produce a healing effect?
The biomedical model views the body as a machine, with diseases representing deviations from normal functioning, and healing involving the restoration or replacement of broken parts. But, despite the comforts of certainty and control, biomedicine is no more scientific than leeches, bloodletting, and celery juice. It provides us with rituals in the form of tests, diagnoses, and prescriptions. The amulets we hold onto to ward off the demons of disease are chemical fixes for depression and ADHD, antibiotics for viral infections, and medications to lower lab values.
The biomedical model is the folk medicine of our time. It promises answers to the more complex questions of what is wrong and what can be done about it, while failing to address the why, how, what for, and, importantly, what this means (for me, my life, my family, my future).
On the other hand, the biopsychosocial model invites us to see the person as a constellation of living systems: interwoven body, mind, relationship, and spirit. It considers the rhythms of our biology, such as blood sugar, hormones, nerves, and neurotransmitters, inseparable from our inner world of thoughts, emotions, defences, and longings. It honours how we move through the world: in families, communities, and systems that shape our choices and burdens. It also asks how we make meaning through purpose, ancestry, connection, and the implicit possibility that links others to our suffering: we belong to something larger than ourselves.
The biopsychosocial model rests on a web of interconnected pillars, each supporting and shaping the others in a living system of feedback loops and resonance. No part can be isolated and touched without creating ripples that contact the whole.
Even a single intervention, such as a medication, sends ripples through the entire system because a pill, even a placebo, is not inert. It holds our beliefs about healing and medicine, our relationship with the prescriber, the meanings we attach to illness, and the social stories we carry about being unwell.
In “Why Make People Patients,” Marshall Marinker (1975) distinguishes between illness, sickness, and disease. The medical establishment diagnoses and treats diseases based on symptoms, signs, and lab tests that fit into neat categories, with defined biological treatments.
Illness is the experience of dysphoria and dysfunction that brings people to the doctor. It is the interpersonal and subjective experience of how unwellness is experienced or lived. Therefore, it is possible to feel ill (or unwell) without meeting the criteria for having a disease.
Sickness is a social role that an individual adopts when they are seen or see themselves as unwell. Those with chronic illness may experience being sick (and ill) without having a disease.
Within the biomedical model, disease receives the most attention. Its cause and course are known, and its treatments are rational and specific (Engel, 1977). Biomedicine can offer patients disease labels and treatments. The biological, psychological, and social dimensions of suffering are medicalized and collapsed into the narrow definition of disease. Care is often dehumanized, and people are treated as problems to be fixed (Marinker, 1975). People with chronic, invisible, or unexplainable symptoms or conditions that have yet to be classified and recognized as diseases are often dismissed, a phenomenon identified as “medical gaslighting.”
The Latin root of the word “patient” means “one who suffers” or “one who endures.” Life is suffering, and in this way, we are all patients. However, patient is a half-word, like confidant or lover (Marinker, 1975). A patient exists as one half of a dyadic whole, the doctor, physician, or healer forming the other half. This therapeutic relationship is the unit from which healing occurs.
The patient enters the therapeutic relationship because either they are unaware of what is wrong or, if they are, they don’t know how to help themselves (Engel, 1977). In this therapeutic dyad, the physician is not just a mechanic, identifying and fixing the broken parts, but also a teacher, mentor, and psychotherapist, requiring knowledge of body systems and medicine, as well as psychological and interpersonal skills. Their task is not only to diagnose, but to soothe uncertainty, offer meaning, and strengthen the patient’s trust in their body.
The physician is an agent of hope.
Research has shown that the biopsychosocial model can be used to treat pain and improve mood and life satisfaction in patients; it enhances clinician skills and improves disability outcomes ( Dossett et al., 2020; Fricchione, 2023; Kusnanto et al., 2018; Mankelow et al., 2022; Nakao et al., 2020).
Though decades of research and clinical evidence support the biopsychosocial model, conventional medicine, shaped by hierarchy and tradition, has been slow to integrate it, preferring power and old dominance structures over change.
Furthermore, the limitations of time and attention in holding space for the biopsychosocial model, the nuance of taking a thorough history, and systems thinking make it difficult to standardize into a rigid and overly complex system.
We need practice to bring the biopsychosocial model to healthcare. Below are real-world, grounded examples of how practitioners and patients can embody the model.
For practitioners:
Listen to Serve. Rachel Naomi Remen says that the doctor’s role should not be to fix or even help, but to serve.
She says, “If helping is an experience of strength, fixing is an experience of mastery and expertise. Service, on the other hand, is an experience of mystery, surrender and awe.”
In her book Narrative Medicine, Rita Charon (2006) recommends that doctors invite patients to speak without interrupting, asking them, “What do you think I should know about your case?” She listens for symptom onset, location, duration, and so on, but she also listens for nuance. How do the patients describe their symptoms? How are their lives impacted? What is important to them? Sometimes, she asks a patient, “Tell me about your scars.” Then, she listens.
In the biomedical model, where the doctor is on a hunt to uncover the broken or missing piece, patients are interrupted an average of 18 seconds after they begin speaking.
In many naturopathic consultations I’ve conducted, patients speak for thirty minutes or more, while I quietly listen, reflect nonverbally, and take notes before asking a single question.
In medical school, we were taught how to take a case, including mnemonics to help remember the key questions to ask. Now, 10 years in, I find that simply listening to patients provides me with the information I need to know, and more.
Perhaps this is why naturopathic doctors are often referred to as “Physicians Who Listen.”
According to Engel, doctors must learn to be high-level interviewers, versed in the cultural determinants of how patients communicate disease symptoms. How we talk about our bodies reveals our relationships with them, our experiences with symptoms, and the early life experiences that shape our bodies.
In the doctor-patient interview, the doctor must listen to understand and validate the unfolding story that led someone to feel unwell and seek help. This means identifying biological symptoms and holding space for the psychological and social elements shaping how the person suffers, and healing might begin.
Charon posits that a medical interview must allow for a layered, nonlinear, and metaphor-rich narrative. How does the patient tell their story, and what are their experiences with symptoms? What details do they choose to include? Or omit? Narrative thinkers like Rita Charon and Gabor Mate argue that our stories, or biography, shape our biology. They are just as important, if not more so, than the classic signs and symptoms that typically characterize a particular diagnostic category.
The doctor’s task is to help patients name their feelings and bear witness to the patient’s experience of dysphoria or dysfunction. They must listen for and begin to untangle the threads that shape the suffering and the individuals’ desire to wear the mantle of “patient” and entrust their body to care.
Begin with humility. The patient is the expert on their own body. While you may have spent hours studying this particular organ or condition, the patient has spent years, even a lifetime, living with it.
Science, while the best methodology we have for encountering the truth, is still just an approximation that we use until something better comes along. Knowledge is always incomplete. According to Babette Rothschild (2021), even the most evidence-based treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder will not help more than 50% of clients.
Even the most thoroughly researched cure will not benefit everyone. Nothing in medicine, psychology, or sociology is a hard fact. Science is a big, unanswered question.
In the words of Rachel Naomi Remen, “The patient is not a problem to be solved, but a mystery to be met.”
Remember why you wanted to be a doctor. If you’re like me, you were captivated by the awe and mystery of not knowing. You’ve studied and practiced medicine for years, and the not-knowing still hangs before you, lighting the way on.
My question to practitioners is this: Can you meet your patient, head down in reverence and awe, with curiosity and compassion, without the need to fix? Can you sit in the discomfort of uncertainty?
Practice systems thinking. From a systems perspective, rather than a reductionist one, each part is integrated and interacts with its layers and within the whole. What layer must be addressed first?
Consider how social forces like poverty, racism, and social categories may affect patients’ symptoms and their ability to heal. Ask how organs, cells, molecules, diagnoses, lab results, and the social and psychological interact. What threads are present, and how might they weave and knot together?
See the person, not the problem. Michael White (2016), the developer of Narrative Therapy, is famous for saying, “The person is not the problem, the problem is the problem.” When we separate people from their problems, we leave room for stories of suffering and strength. We can hold and better listen to their stories, while tackling the problem without erasing the person.
Centre patients as the experts on their own lives and their bodies. Flatten hierarchies and de-centre practitioner power. Educate with curiosity, not to fix or dictate. Leave room for questions and doubt. Learn to roll with resistance rather than fighting against it.
Instead, get curious. Why might these recommendations not be landing for the patient? Ask if the diagnoses and treatment plans make sense to them. And then ask: What matters most? What do you notice? What are you ready for?
Ask patients what threads they would like to tug first. Addressing patient issues and developing plans involves a patient-centred, collaborative approach in which courses of action are suggested, tried, and evaluated for feedback. This way, an intricate dance happens between the patient and the practitioner (Graham et al., 2023).
Self-care. Finally, practitioner burnout is real. Ensure you regulate your nervous system, make space for reflection, and seek support as needed.
For patients:
Trust yourself. Health is not just the absence of symptoms or the relief of pain; it is the sense of wholeness, coherence, and aliveness in your body and your being. Normal lab results don’t cancel out your suffering; a diagnosis cannot fully contain your story. Your instincts and insights are also essential data.
You are not a broken part needing repair, but a whole person, complex, relational, and worthy of care. If something feels wrong, trust that. If you feel unseen, trust it. Your frustration is valid. Your symptoms are messengers.
You deserve understanding, presence, comfort, care, and a path forward.
Empower yourself within the system. Our healthcare system is stretched thin, and sometimes, your suffering may be overlooked. This is not because you don’t matter; it isn’t always because your doctor doesn’t care. Sometimes, even the most well-meaning practitioners work within an overwhelmed structure.
Before your appointment, take a moment to ground yourself. Breathe into your belly. Feel your feet beneath you. Gather your thoughts and write them down. Bring someone who can hold space, ask thoughtful questions, and accurately remember what is said.
Write down your questions before you go. Appointments move quickly, and it’s easy to forget. Describe your top two or three concerns and how they shape your days, energy, and life. Be honest about what you’ve tried, what’s helped, and what hasn’t.
If something feels off, you can gently point it out. “Could we look at this another way?” “This doesn’t quite fit.” “Would you be open to checking this?” If it’s difficult to speak, consider having someone speak on your behalf. You deserve to be witnessed.
Afterward, write down what was said, how it landed, and what you wish you’d asked. Over time, this will build a personal health narrative you can revisit and share with future providers.
Participate in your healing. Responsibility is not about blame. You are not expected to carry everything alone, but you are invited to become a curious, compassionate student of your own body. We can reclaim our agency.
Start by paying attention. Track your symptoms, not obsessively, but as an act of self-witnessing. Look for patterns: what soothes, what aggravates, what precedes the flare or the crash. Learn the basics of your biology and mind: how stress ripples through your system, blood sugar, trauma, hormones, sleep, and your nervous system speak. What are their symptoms, signs, and sensations? You don’t need to diagnose yourself, but knowing your inner landscape helps you recognize when something feels true and when it doesn’t.
Your voice matters, too. Healing is a dialogue. Informed consent is about being an active participant in the conversation. This means learning to describe what you feel, notice, and need.
Pain, for instance, can be more than just “it hurts.” What kind of pain is it? Where does it live? Is it burning, tight, dull, or pulsing? Does it move or stay in place? Is it eased by warmth, made worse by movement, or does it come on with memories or moods? The more we can narrate what we carry, the more we can be seen.
When it comes to tools, focus on what’s within reach. You don’t need a life overhaul or expensive therapies. Sometimes, healing begins with the most minor shift: more rest, a nourishing meal, honouring a boundary, a walk in the sun, or a moment of joy.
The human body requires fresh air, water, sunlight, physical activity, restful sleep, nutritious food, and social connection. While finding a balance of these isn’t always easy, sometimes, the solutions are simpler than we think.
Build yourself a circle of care. No single practitioner can hold everything we carry. If it’s within reach, widen your support: consider consulting a naturopathic doctor to explore root causes, a therapist to help map your inner world, a nutritionist, an acupuncturist, or a massage therapist. Each practitioner can offer a different lens and a different kind of listening. Ask about referrals, covered services, sliding scales, or community programs.
You are allowed to ask for more, to want a second opinion, and to assemble a community of support that sees you more fully. If you have coverage, use it. If you need a referral, ask. If a door closes, it’s ok to knock on another.
Seek information from people you trust. Let wisdom be relational and guided intuitively. Be cautious of algorithms, especially those that induce fear or urgency.
Above all, refuse to give up on yourself. I always believe there is a path toward feeling better. Even when we can’t fully restore the body, healing can still occur through meaning, connection, presence, and peace. Your body is not betraying you. I believe symptoms are cries from the body that deserve to be heard.
Healing begins when we stop reducing people to their symptoms and begin seeing them as whole beings, complex, feeling, and worthy. You deserve care that honours not just your biology, but your personhood, spirit, and life.
You deserve to tell your story and have someone receive it with attention and care.
You deserve a physician who listens.
References:
Charon, R. (2006). Narrative medicine. Oxford University Press.
Dossett, M. L., Fricchione, G. L., & Benson, H. (2020). A new era for mind–body medicine. New England Journal of Medicine, 382(15), 1390–1391. https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmp1917461
Fricchione, G. (2023). Mind body medicine: A modern bio-psycho-social model forty-five years after Engel. BioPsychoSocial Medicine, 17(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13030-023-00268-3
Graham, K. D., Steel, A., & Wardle, J. (2023). The converging paradigms of holism and complexity: An exploration of naturopathic clinical case management using complexity science principles. Journal of evaluation in clinical practice, 29(4), 662–681. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.13721
Kusnanto, H., Agustian, D., & Hilmanto, D. (2018). Biopsychosocial model of illnesses in primary care: A hermeneutic literature review. Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care, 7(3), 497. https://doi.org/10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_145_17
Mankelow, J., Ryan, C., Taylor, P. C., Atkinson, G., & Martin, D. (2022). A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of biopsychosocial pain education upon health care professional pain attitudes, knowledge, behavior and patient outcomes. Journal of Pain, 23(1). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2021.06.010
Nakao, M., Komaki, G., Yoshiuchi, K., Deter, H.-C., & Fukudo, S. (2020). Biopsychosocial medicine research trends: Connecting clinical medicine, psychology, and public health. BioPsychoSocial Medicine, 14(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13030-020-00204-9
Dr. Jessica Eastman, a naturopathic doctor and psychedelic-assisted therapist, shares her integrative approach to trauma recovery and mental health. She emphasizes the significance of preparation and integration in psychedelic therapy, highlighting that healing occurs during the integration of insights gained.
Dr. Eastman discusses the need for emotional readiness and a curious mindset, addressing the risks of poorly guided experiences. Advocating for a holistic, patient-centered approach, she stresses the importance of foundational health and patient autonomy. She also announces her upcoming online trauma recovery program and offers resources for ongoing support and education.
[0:01] All right welcome dr jessica eastman a fellow ccnm colleague and so we recently connected over um yeah well i guess like topics around psychedelics and mental health and uh some cult psychology and spiritual bypassing and um but i think what we want to talk about today is like mental health and maybe some psychedelics and trauma and because that’s a big part of what you do and what your practice is in BC.
[0:34] And yeah, maybe you could introduce yourself and tell me a little and tell the audience a little bit about your practice. Yeah, for sure. Yeah. So I am a naturopathic doctor licensed in British Columbia. I’ve been practicing there for almost 10 years.
[0:49] And I also am a psychedelic assisted therapist and as I call it, a trauma recovery coach. Um, so I kind of mashed together, uh, integrative psychiatry and, um, integrative mental health work with trauma-informed primary care and, uh, some psychedelic, um, assisted therapy, like prep and integration work. I don’t do the actual medicine sessions because it’s not in my scope of practice, um, but. I could do that if I was like working
[1:19] under another like field trip or a numinous or something like that. But I get a ton of value in doing like harm reduction discussion and prep and integration. And I have a little niche of people who come to see me when they’ve gone to do psychedelic assisted therapy, usually with an underground therapist who wasn’t super well trained and they had a bad experience.
[1:38] And then they are looking for somebody to like help them sort that out. Also because a lot of psychiatrists and psychotherapists and psychologists and medical doctors don’t have a whole lot of training or understanding about psychedelics and so these people sometimes come to me they’re like in inpatient psych and their psychiatrist is saying like you’ve broken your brain and there’s nothing we can do to help you and then they call me kind of like as a last-ditch effort to be like hey is my brain really broken and I get to say like no it isn’t actually we can heal this and we can work through this so that’s a really fun little niche that um is is developing there’s like more and more need for that um and then i do some trauma recovery coaching specifically both in my practice and separately um so i get to kind of weave a whole lot of mental stuff together that’s really cool that’s really really really interesting i know bc has a more expanded scope than ontario when it comes to um like i think i Dr.
[2:37] Ray St. Arnall about ketamine therapy and like that’s in scope or like legal for therapeutic use. But yeah, how did you get into the and what maybe you can describe some really interested kind of like what the prep would be like in a in a responsibly administered sort of psychedelic session, like what kind of prep is usually involved and what’s the integration like afterwards if someone’s really going about it in like a.
[3:04] Yeah, totally. Yeah, safe way. Yeah, so the prep work is actually done from, you know, anywhere from one to multiple, like three or four, you know, up to like six months worth of sessions before you do the actual medicine sessions.
[3:25] And what’s involved in prep work is really variable from person to person. The kind of universal things that are involved in prep work is having a discussion with the client or the patient about what they are expecting. And a big part of the prep work is helping them to get clear on what their goals are and helping to work away from a bunch of expectations and toward like intentions and an opening to the possibility of whatever the medicine is going to take you into. Um as a lot of people go into these sessions understandably like hoping that they’re gonna you know be a cure-all because they’ve been struggling with you know depression or PTSD or OCD or whatever it is for a long time and um, psychedelic medicine is a unpredictable in certain ways and so it doesn’t it’s not linear in the way that like when you give this dose of a of an ssri we generally have this response and when we increase the dose we have an increased response and so psychedelics are a more unpredictable, world they kind of um work often by teaching you how to surrender and and exposing you to, feelings and or stuff that you want to work through or that you maybe need to work through.
[4:47] But going in the most likely things that are going to create a bad time or a bad trip is if you go in with a whole bunch of expectations or you go in with the expectation that you’re going to be able to control the experience. And so like a classic example is like people who come And they say, OK, I want to go into this session to heal my relationship with my father. And that sets you up for a challenging session, potentially, because there’s a whole bunch of expectations built into that concept. And so what we often work that into is something more open ended is like I my intention for this session is to be curious and to understand more about my relationship with my father because we don’t put expectations on like healing or outcome necessarily because a the medicine doesn’t do that for you. It illuminates things and helps you to do that work on your own and be surrendering or being able to like relinquish control to the experience is a big part of how the medicine works and how it helps you to allow for neuroplastic change and perspective updating.
[6:01] So, yeah, that’s a big part of kind of like universal prep work with anybody who’s doing it well. And then there are some other things that some people need more support in than others. Like some of the things that I personally would, you know, like more or less require would say like this is a prerequisite to being able to do this work is… Decent amount of experience and tools in being able to manage uncomfortable emotion and knowing that you understand like how to know where your edge is in terms of like I can handle this and this is where my overwhelmed edge is and when I need to ask for help and then also having the skill set of being able to ask for help when you need it because like I said sometimes these sessions are unpredictable and sometimes they’re very chill and gentle and like lovely and warm and you you know feel love for the whole time and other times they like you know open doors to old emotions
[6:51] or memories or stuff that like can be a flood of discomfort. And it’s important that people are not going to be super dysregulated after and not then know how to handle that or get the support that they need.
[7:06] So that’s a component of it. And so, you know, if people come with years of psychotherapy experience, then they’re probably full up on all of those tools. And if they’ve never done any of that work before, then we do some of that work first. Yeah, that’s really useful. It’s like, what are your intentions that are kind of reasonable? And then, yeah, maybe looking at, because one of the things it does, it kind of drops defenses. And sometimes those defenses are there for very important reasons that once they’re gone, you know, what do you, you know, how might you respond or, you know, how might you find stability?
[7:50] Yeah. Like, you know, if there’s some things that have been compartmentalized for good reason and now they’re blasting open or you’re in touch with them or, you know. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And I think that’s probably the most misunderstood part of psychedelic-assisted therapy and all that kind of work is that people think that the medicine is the thing that heals them or is that the thing that fixes their brain, so to speak. And it’s actually like it reveals a bunch of stuff to you and it puts your brain into a particularly like flexible and malleable state where you have the potential to have neuroplastic change and build new neural
[8:34] connections in the like, you know, a few days and weeks right after your session. So you are more changeable in that period, but the change comes from you and the work that you do a little bit during the session, but in large part after in the integration work where you’re being exposed to or choosing to expose yourself to the feelings that it illuminated and the memories and the awarenesses and the connections and then how you process and integrate all of that into the rest of your life. That’s where the change and the growth and the healing really happens. Yeah, in that integration period of like, kind of, yeah, it’s like this, like this kind of like ego dissolution. It’s like your ego dissolves and you’re this raw kind of.
[9:20] Bare soul but that’s not how we operate through the world like we we need to kind of reconstruct the ego the persona to like be able to work your job and be in relationship and parent your kids and like all that stuff right like you can’t just be connected to the trees um or like in a dissociated state so it’s like how do we kind of repair and and like carve new pathways around well traumas or metabolize and reintegrate the traumas that may have been yeah yeah exposed yeah yeah exactly what do you find like when people are so i know you’re not administering the medicine but like what is because a few patients have asked me like especially with treatment resistant depression that’s often like a category where these medicines are really like looked at and studied um a lot of people who have had kind of lifelong depression lots of treatment not really a lot of resolution uh maybe some trauma they’re like maybe i should do an ayahuasca retreat or what do you know about you know psilocybin assisted psychotherapy and like what do you find when someone’s been in years and years of psychotherapy and maybe they’ve got some they’ve built some skills they’ve learned some things about themselves but what what are you seeing with people when they do psychedelic assisted therapy like is it like what kind of changes or what, you know.
[10:42] What’s that like? Because it is framed like a miracle a lot of the time. Yeah, totally. And sometimes it is. Like, sometimes people’s experiences of that are like, this is actually a miracle. And so it does, like, that rhetoric exists for a reason.
[10:55] It’s just, it doesn’t happen every single time. It doesn’t happen in every patient. It’s also really about where you are at in your journey and, like, if the medicine was chosen correctly in alignment with where you’re at. And so, yeah, there’s a lot of parts. But excuse me, I think that.
[11:13] So, a big thing that often people take away from psychedelic experiences is new perspectives, looking at the same things they’ve been talking about or working through or feeling for, you know, months, years, decades, but they get to look at them from a new lens.
[11:34] So it allows you to see things from different angles that also often allows you to develop or unlock compassion for yourself in the past or for the other people in the story in a way that allows you to, as you said, like metabolize the trauma a little bit.
[11:50] Feel, process, and release is the language that I use a lot of the time. Um and as you said earlier it it really also as some medicines more than others but there’s a lot of like dialing down of the amygdala activity during while you’re under the influence of the medicine this is especially true for mdma um but true in you know ketamine psilocybin etc and the amygdala is responsible for our fear response and therefore our protection responses and that is the thing that is often preventing us from being able to really look at and feel the emotions or feel the memory or whatever um and that is there for a reason as you said but also when we dial down how intense the amygdala is active uh is activated in that moment sometimes we can often we can have the memory or feel the feelings without the associated fear and intensity of like a need to protect and so you’re able to just feel.
[12:50] It as opposed to it being buffered by your nervous system saying like it’s too dangerous for you to feel this and so there’s often container too of safety so it’s like yeah it’s appropriate to have that like reduced defense like yeah yeah yeah for sure if if the psychedelic assisted therapy is done well and you’ve got a safe container with a therapist that you trust and it’s yeah so uh it often so it gives people often new perspectives it also gives them an opportunity to have a big release of feelings like i’ve heard many people talk about how this is my experience also like it helped you it helped me and and many others to feel the feelings separate from the story that your brain is telling it for the first time ever just like a thing we work so hard at in psychotherapy to try and like allow for and validate and make space for the feeling without your brain pulling you into like but that shouldn’t have happened or I shouldn’t have done that or if it was different and so to be able to just feel the raw feeling and feel the sad or the anger or the fear, maybe not even connected to a story, but that has been kind of stored in your body. And to be able to release that…
[13:58] And being able to experience that and then know that your brain is capable of
[14:02] that often translates into you being able to retain that ability in your sober life. And then kind of on that same track, another common experience is like being able to feel love or feel cared for or feel cared for others or feel connected to others in a way that people haven’t been. And because that protection that keeps you, you know, from not being drowned by your feelings also prevents you from being able to connect with other people fully, connects you from being or prevents you from being able to feel the love and the vulnerability and all that stuff. And so letting down those defenses also lets that in. And that can be a really powerful experience for people to be like, oh, I am capable of feeling love. This is what it feels like. Now I want to look for that in my regular life. Now I want to strive for that or create a safer container in my regular life so that I can feel that more regularly. Yeah, that’s cool. Yeah, that’s a great way of saying it. Like this, like you feel you release the emotion separate from the story. It’s just the raw experience of the emotion without the like fear of experiencing it, you know. Like, yeah, it’s kind of like this grief dumping that you get.
[15:11] Yes. you clean out your house and you put it all in in donation bins and you’re just yeah you know.
[15:17] Yes yeah yeah exactly yeah that’s beautiful yeah I know too like research has shown it increases like the personality metric of openness to experience like permanently yeah kind of this yeah which is kind of connected to like intelligence creativity but also connection like there’s less inhibition and and store you’re less trapped in the story and those like well-worn paths yep you know yeah which then very linearly um connects to an increase in empathy which then allows you to have more compassion for yourself for others to be able to connect more to people that like understand other people’s struggles you’re like less, intolerant this is that’s the um the facet of psychedelics that people reference when they say like if you know if like all the world leaders took psychedelics the world would be a way happier place because it like helps you to see things from other people’s perspectives and helps you to remember or realize maybe for the first time that we’re all just humans out here like struggling and doing our best and having feelings and loved and being hurt and all of that and like we’re all if we if you can.
[16:29] Remember or remain connected into the fact that like there’s more similarities than there are differences then suddenly a lot of the like world problems feel silly oh we’re all just out here hurting and loving and trying to take care of ourselves and each other yeah like that raw human emotion like when you feel it you recognize it in others and maybe our stories like there’s an infinite amount of stories so maybe that keeps us separate yeah it’s like well i’m different from you because of this particular detail even though maybe it’s kind of the same, which kind of keeps us siloed but if we when you really understand sadness or happiness or joy in your body and you.
[17:10] Can recognize it in others like oh this is just yeah that’s one of the elements of self-compassion is the common humanity idea of like this is just this is something that all humans feel no matter how rich or privileged you know we have these emotions that run through us yeah yeah and that’s like that’s a big part of what is not talked about in our regular society because it’s not productive or it’s not encouraged or it’s like weak or whatever but it’s it’s a big part of it and i think that that contributes to us all feeling like we are alone in these experiences if we all felt more capable more comfortable more confident more safe to be able to say like oh i’m a person and i’m having these feelings then we would all probably feel less alone in that experience yeah and if you say that to somebody who is comfortable or can provide a container for their own feelings they can provide a container for yours like a lot of the time empathy like moments of empathy can be missed when somebody like doesn’t really want to feel it because empathy is ultimately kind of feeling or letting in another’s experience so if I don’t really want to feel that because I’m uncomfortable with it I may invalidate you or dismiss you or you know yes and yeah create like a chasm between us which isn’t helpful yeah yeah totally yeah what happens when okay so now like the negative like what when you when you see people who are worried that their brain is broken or maybe.
[18:39] They had kind of an irresponsible journey or somebody that wasn’t trained like.
[18:43] What kind of things like what are the risks that you’ve seen.
[18:47] Yeah, so there’s a few different facets there. The biggest risk, I think, is the emotional-mental dysregulation piece, and that’s often what the, like, my brain is broken piece is, right?
[19:02] And that, I think, comes from a combination of things that in the patients that I’ve worked with that have been through that experience, it’s often that they were not in a safe or regulated or grounded or nourished state to begin the treatment. And so like the patients that I’m thinking of were like, they had been burnt out for decades and they were like, you know, had recently gotten over like really significant illness and were feeling fairly dysregulated in their day to day. And then a poorly trained or untrained therapist, in quotations, says like, oh, yeah, well, this will solve all your problems. And so they encourage the patient to come in before they’re ready, before they’re like physiologically ready, before they’re mentally ready, and then also sets them up with a whole bunch of unrealistic expectations. Sessions and that then puts their nervous systems and their physical bodies in a position to be very depleted, to be very dysregulated.
[20:07] Like these experiences are taxing. I think that’s a thing to recall. And especially the longer sessions, like ketamine is a shorter session. It usually is like two hours in entirety, but it’s a draining experience for your body.
[20:21] Psilocybin is like six hours ayahuasca is like eight or ten or twelve depending on where you’re doing it and how long you’re doing it for and so these are not it’s like you’re like, running a marathon that whole time. And so if you think about, is this patient fit and ready and has the capacity to like go and do a really hard, laborious task for 12 straight hours, that kind of gives you some idea of like, is the foundation laid for this to go well or not? And then I think the other big mental emotional risk is that, like we’ve talked about already, often psychedelics can open doors to big feelings or big memories or like realizations about traumatic pasts that you’ve had like traumatic experiences that you’ve had in your past and I think that there’s a handful of well-intentioned underground therapists who haven’t been properly trained in trauma or in what happens when people get really dysregulated or their sense of identity gets really disconnected or threatened.
[21:31] And then those people have the really scary experience of being hit with all of this awareness that they didn’t know about, like memories of stuff that happened or connections about like, oh, I’ve been avoiding thinking about this because it was too scary and now I’m being faced with thinking about it.
[21:51] Paired with a therapist who doesn’t know how to meet them there and hold space for them or how to carry that back into their regular life.
[21:58] So then they feel this compounding like, I’m really overwhelmed. I don’t know how to handle this. And I’m alone in that experience. And then the nervous system understandably responds with like big fear responses in those moments. So then you are flooded with all of the hormones that try to keep you safe. And you’re just like on a crazy high alert and you end up in a like perpetual state of hypervigilance. Um so that that’s like a common outcome you know you’re not sleeping and then that’s all compounded that you’re not sleeping you’re not eating your hormones are dysregulated and then everything just kind of snowballs um and i think so that’s like um yeah i’ve worked with a handful of people who’ve been in that position it just takes time for us to help them return to and like rebuild safety in their body and then also understand the patterns that they were living in before they did the session that maybe perpetuate or contributed to this that they didn’t even realize. And so it’s like a process of healing from the experience itself, but then also like rebuilding new patterns because we don’t necessarily even want to go back to what they were like before we want a healthier version of that.
[23:08] And I think I would be remiss to not mention also like some of these, some people have more risks than others for these things to trigger like other things. Psychological disorders. And so certainly a properly trained psychedelic assisted therapy program is going to really assess like your medical history, your psychological history, your family medical history. Not all of these things are safe to take depending on the medications you’re taking. And so there’s definitely some risks there.
[23:38] And then there are some physical capacity risks like you have to have controlled blood pressure. You could be on medication or you have regular blood pressure, but if you have uncontrolled hypertension, all of these medications temporarily increase your blood pressure like they would if you were doing strenuous exercise and so that needs to be a thing that we are cautious of so there’s some like purely medical side um precautions that need to be taken as well to make sure we’re not hurting you in any way or interacting with medications you’re on or putting you at risk for you know bipolar mania or anything like that yeah that makes sense yeah it’s like an underlying predisposition or like you know risk factors or family histories even um and then yeah this kind of like physical stability and how you know what are the structures that are in place in your life like yes it’s like you know all of a sudden you’re you discover like my job is intolerable my life is intolerable my relationship but I have nowhere now to go no safe place to land like how do I cope with my daily life as I figure out how to transition or like all of these things you know yes exactly yeah yeah and then you mentioned too yeah I know we talked about kind of like, maybe traumatic experiences that people don’t really remember and sometimes people have the experience of like.
[25:04] I know with some ayahuasca stories, I’ve heard people have talked about, like, I was kind of in my childhood watching it like a movie.
[25:12] That could be amazingly therapeutic, but, and we’ll probably talk about this when we talk about trauma, but not, it’s not always that. There’s a time and a place to kind of revisit memories, you know, and maybe don’t want to revisit memories at all. And so there’s a lot. Yeah, there’s a lot there for.
[25:33] Yeah and that’s a good example like I would say like if a person came to me and they said okay I want to do psychedelic assisted therapy but I want to make sure I don’t revisit any memories from this one time in my childhood I would say like okay you’re not ready yet like this is maybe not the right tool for you at least right now because we can’t control what happens in that experience just like we can’t control what happens in life and so a lot of the the work is like making sure like you said you’ve got support systems and mechanisms in place to help you manage whatever comes up yeah it’s like okay like yeah we don’t know what will happen but we can’t necessarily yeah like you said have an expectation of what will happen but also have kind of a boundary of what i don’t want to experience it doesn’t exactly work like that yeah and and And there’s like, there’s a lot of variability with dosing and with medicine. And so it’s, I know people talk about ego dissolution and psychedelics a lot. And that, you have to like work hard to get to the ego dissolution place. And so I would say most psychedelic experiences don’t involve like true ego dissolution. And so you do retain some, you like, you know who you are, you know where you are, You have some connection to like, you know.
[26:54] And everybody’s got a different experience and the medicines are all different, but there are definitely a lot of opportunities in there for you to be like, I’m not sure I want to go there. And so you do have some influence, but we can’t guarantee it.
[27:05] And also there is some…
[27:08] It’s worth discussing, like, the things that you explicitly don’t want to look at are, you know, it’s like, don’t think about white elephants. Like, that’s where your brain is going to take you a lot of the time, probably for good reason, because there’s stuff there that’s worth looking at and then metabolizing and moving through.
[27:25] Yeah, if you’re consciously, like, suppressing. Yes. Like, a closet overflowing, but, like, I know it’s there. I know I got to deal with that. Yeah. That’s exactly the analogy that I use. Yeah. It’s almost like, though, I think the gravitation towards psychedelics is kind of like the person’s like, okay, I kind of do want to open that closet. Like, I’m ready. I’m scared, but I’m ready. You know, otherwise I, you know, probably don’t want to take ayahuasca, you know? Yes. Agreed. Yeah. And most people, very rarely does somebody come to me and say like, I want to do this, but I don’t want to look at any of this stuff. Yeah, it’s very much like, okay, I don’t know how to look at that stuff, but I know that there’s probably something in there for me. And so I’m ready to explore whatever that is. Hire like a closet organizer.
[28:17] Yeah, exactly. You still watch. No, no, don’t throw that away. Okay, actually, fine. you can yeah and that’s that’s the that’s the analogy for trauma recovery that i use all the time is like hey you’ve got a closet in your basement that you’ve been shoving stuff into, no judgment but like that’s your that’s been your coping mechanism you’re like i can’t deal with this right now it’s going in the closet you know and that’s been happening for you know five ten twenty thirty years and now you the closet is so full that you have to spend all day leaning on the closet to keep the door closed and so you’re living your life with like one hand and maybe one leg so because you’re just like using a lot of your energy to keep the door closed and so the the process is like okay we open the door we let six things tumble out we close it again and then you and I together work through and learn how to deal with the six things that tumbled out you know and for each one you’re like Marie Kondo-ing your brain sort of you’re like picking each thing up and holding it to the light and saying like, okay, is this mine? Do I want to keep it?
[29:21] If not, do I want to get rid of it? Do I want to give it back to the person that it came from? Do I want to burn it? And then also you have the question of, well, is there a hole that is left behind by that belief or that paradigm? And what do I want to replace it with? And just like go through that process slowly over time until one day you can open that closet and look in and walk in and like it’s all organized and there’s a bin and every now and then you’re like, okay, I’m going to take down this childhood relationship with my father bin and like figure out what’s in there, you know, but it’s it’s, more organized, you have more say over when it happens and how it happens.
[29:57] And that’s where people start to gain the experience of being in control of
[30:03] their emotions and of their life. It’s like it doesn’t make the past go away, but it teaches us how to work with it in a way that feels like we get to be in charge. Yeah, that’s an amazing analogy, actually, because, you know, like I can picture the person kind of like one arm and a leg leaning on the closet, And then the other arm is your job and your kids and your daily life. Why am I so exhausted? Why am I sober? Why am I so overwhelmed? Exactly. And then when you sit down with someone like you, like a therapist, a naturopath, and you’re like, okay, now with my free hand, though, I’m going to sort the six pieces that we let out. So now, so this kind of describes the type of context to enter into trauma work with, where it’s like, can you use that hand or are you using it to like keep things afloat in your life, right? Like, can you take, is there a container that you can, yeah, you have, you know, therapists and support to help, but your free limbs are kind of engaged now in like doing this work. But eventually, you don’t have to be pressing on the closet because stuff kind of stays in there so you can walk away and now you have your full capacity to, you know, enjoy and engage with your life. But in the meantime, yeah, there is kind of this.
[31:21] Like not checking out from life but like you’re you’re there’s time and energy that needs to be kind of uh allotted to tend to it yep yeah you’re not able to be fully present in your life because you’re spending a decent chunk of your energy either keeping that door closed or dealing with the mess that happens every time you step away from the door oh yeah it is a thing that i say often in the early days of trauma recovery work is like this is unfortunately and through no fault of your own your next full-time job you know and now you have to figure out how to balance your actual full-time job and your responsibilities as a parent or a partner or of whatever and also doing this work and that determines the pace of recovery a lot of the time because we can’t always do all of that and so that’s where a support person or multiple support people therapist coach naturopathic doctor come in that’s also where medication and supplements and optimal diet and nutrition come in to help like give you the most capacity that you have potential
[32:27] for in that moment so that you can put more effort into that.
[32:30] If you want to but this is also why i don’t have any judgment or anything but like respect and compassion for people that don’t want to do this work because it’s really hard sometimes and it takes energy and capacity and not everybody like it’s a privilege to be able to do this work if you are drowning in like you know food insecurity or paying your bills or keeping a roof over your head or being a single parent that might not be the right chapter in your life for you to be able to do this because more important stuff is taking your attention and your effort and your capacity. Yeah. Like if that free hand is like keeping you alive, essentially. Yes. Yeah. Then yeah, you need it. It’s not the appropriate time right now. And it’s interesting because as we’re talking, like I think of many psychotherapy clients often don’t.
[33:24] With who are kind of neurodivergent and they’re like they come in they’re like I’m burnt out and I’m just.
[33:30] Kind of in this um treadmill with work like.
[33:33] I’m I’m behind I’m overwhelmed you know and so when we do kind of just like almost like solution focused stuff and we help like build skills and manage the day-to-day overwhelm you know systems stuff like that that’s often when now we go down and it’s like okay actually no it’s my father it’s my mother it’s my you know traumatic past or it’s uh my core beliefs there’s like it goes deeper it’s like once we’ve kind of addressed that initial layer that was sucking all the energy now there’s room to address.
[34:10] The contents of the closet um yeah but yeah when you’re managing things with one hand again like it’s a great analogy because it there’s a lot of compassion it’s like well no wonder you’re overwhelmed and it’s so hard for you to like have your inbox like at zero and not be kind of flooded all the time and like not have not be behind in all these deadlines because you only have one hand to manage everything yeah yeah exactly and then what’s the integration like so after someone’s doing psychedelic therapy like you know how many sessions is it usually i know that can obviously vary but super variable yeah so in the literature like in the research that we have currently usually it’s and you have an integration session that day or the next day right after the medicine session and then one or two weeks later and then kind of ongoing with your own therapist.
[35:04] Um and so there’s a there’s a various various things that happen in an integration session like and it also it depends a lot on how new you were to the experience like in early days for people have never done psychedelics before often a lot of the integration is just talking with somebody and sharing your experience to be like well that was a crazy experience like I’ve never had an experience like that before um the the to be able to like be validated and seen with somebody that also has been there and understands what it feels like to be in that um The terminology that we use in the literature and in the academic world is a non-ordinary state of consciousness, NOSC, which can be also accessed via breathwork and some forms of meditation and that kind of stuff. But it is an altered state and it is a wild experience. And so it’s difficult to talk about if you haven’t experienced it before.
[36:00] So that’s often a little bit of what happens. And then there is sharing about the revelations or the awareness that you have, you know, come to realize or come to experience. Or sometimes you take the medicine and like nothing really happens. And then you are like, at least in your perception.
[36:19] And so then you are processing and metabolizing the feelings of like frustration and disappointment and curiosity and like did something in my brain change but even though I didn’t feel the medicine and all of those things people that have been doing this work for a while talk about how like the integration session is like six to twelve months long so it’s it’s kind of like laughable to say like oh yeah it’s one to three sessions because what actually happens in the integration happens over time as you you know you’ve adopted a new perspective about yourself or the world or belief or whatever and now you have to go through slowly the experience of living your life through this new lens and be like oh wait well how does this change the way I handle conflict with my partner how does this change the way I handle uh feeling underappreciated in my job how does this handle you know like and and it’s it’s that same kind of like Marie Kondo effect of like well I I have to pick up every piece of my life and figure out, well, how does this change that? And that takes time.
[37:22] And the cool thing about all of the work that I do is like it doesn’t require you don’t have to sit down and do that consciously. Like you don’t have to journal about every single part of your life in this new belief system. A lot of it happens in the background, like in the default mode network controlled stuff that just is like happening as you’re living your life. Yeah. As long as you’re committed to curiosity and like paying attention to what is changing and noticing what’s happening in your body and in your mind, you’ll be able to see the changes that happen over time.
[37:53] That’s really cool. Yeah. Yeah. Like it’s, it takes a while to like kind of encounter the moments that you’re maybe watching for or like, you know, okay, the next conflict with my partner, what changed and to kind of be aware of how these changes happen. Yeah, like it’s and like making meaning of the experience can take time to write like what does it mean? How does that weave into my narrative? Yeah yeah exactly yeah yeah and like maybe you have a you know a perspective of like oh i um i am worthy of love you know or i am deserving of being cared for and so then you have this new belief but now you have to go through each part of your life to be like well how would that change all of the ways in which i interact with this life and how can i ask for more and so then you have like okay well you have a sit-down conversation with your partner and be like Actually, these are the things that I would like to be receiving from you in order to feel more cared for. And then you go through that many-step process with your partner to update the systems and the ways you’re caring for each other. It’s a big ripple effect, and it takes time. I think I’ve told this story before, but I remember my own experience where after an experience with a medicine, I was walking in the forest, actually, and I passed somebody. And I saw this kind of like.
[39:18] Judgmental or kind of contemptuous expression on the person’s face. And I remember distinctly feeling like, oh, they made an expression on their face. And it was this first time, like really embodying this feeling of, oh, people’s crap doesn’t always have to do with me, you know, or my, but how does that then, how do I act that out in my life now? Like, how do I bring that awareness to, you know, I mean, that’s a clear interaction. I don’t know that person they’re just walking by what did I do like there’s you know so cognitively I know that it doesn’t have anything to do with me even if that little schema is running yeah but when somebody is unhappy with me or I am in a conflict with someone how can I bring that into the you know how do I how do I work with that or what replaces that schema or you know how does it become modified because sometimes it is about me sometimes I did screw up you know so yeah yeah so What’s the more balanced thought, I guess, in CBT language? And so that can take a lot of time. Yeah, for sure.
[40:23] It is a process. And I think that it is a gift to be able to give yourself time to process all of that.
[40:31] And it’s a recognition of that the medicine isn’t doing the work, you are doing the work. The medicine just kind of like showed you a door that you didn’t know existed. You get to choose if you want to continue to keep that door open or walk through that door in your your waking regular life it’s so cool yeah it’s a really fascinating, area like I’ve always been kind of interested in it because of the.
[40:58] The kind of pivotal way that it can really like accelerate like it’s, It’s very hard to, like, build those different neural pathways when you’re stuck in this same groove and you just, you know, like, you know, often there’s a lot of intellectualizing and a lot of like the cognitive changes that can be really, really sticky. But there’s something about embodying the feelings and just seeing that as a truth that kind of hits you that can be really powerful. Yeah. Yeah. For sure. Like you said, seeing another possibility or another perspective and really seeing it, not just like, oh, yeah, I can use my imagination and kind of see how, yeah, like I know it on a level that’s deeper than just, like, I wish I knew this. I wish I believed this, but I don’t know. It’s hard for me, you know? Totally. And for that reason, the primary modalities that are used in psychedelic therapy and psychedelic integration are generally somatic work and like internal family systems parts work and like mindfulness and where those three all overlap, which is like polyvagal theory and all of that stuff.
[42:09] Because it’s not really about the cognitive understanding. It’s about the somatic felt sense of like, oh, I know that I’m deserving of being respected or cared for, but I feel it now. And being able to feel that is the thing that’s going to enable you to like enact a boundary, you know, or ask for more or decide that you want to make a different choice. It’s not the cognitive knowing that drives behavior a lot of the time.
[42:35] Much as we want it to. Yeah. And I think that’s a good approach to trauma work, too, for most people. I know that CBT-informed trauma therapy is the gold standard because it’s easy to study it. Yeah, exactly. but mostly when you talk to people they’re like uh you know the real movement that i experienced was ifs internal system somatic therapy where i really like you know emdr like where i really was able to kind of locate these parts in my body and metabolize them because a lot of it’s not verbal and not cognitive and not a conscious decision you know yeah exactly and also the like analytical conscious brain often gets in the way and so there’s that’s like a thing i’ve seen in cbt many times both as a patient and um like when i was the patient i mean and in in my patients now who’ve come to me from cbt is like the talking about the trauma or about the patterns or about the belief systems like reinforce them or keep you stuck in those patterns and.
[43:42] There’s like no way to talk your way into something you’ve never felt before. You have to experience your way into something you’ve never felt before. And that’s just not a framework that CBT holds. So it’s a useful set of tools. And I don’t think it is an all-encompassing trauma treatment because it doesn’t really get anything like below the head, so to speak.
[44:06] Yeah, that’s a good way of describing it. Like you know write out your beliefs why do you believe this is there another way of thinking about this that’s a good skill sometimes it’s the first layer like to introduce therapy like oh wow my thoughts like awareness of self-talk is really useful challenging self-talk but yeah it’s a lot of um people who’ve experienced trauma are caught up in ruminate ruminative cycles you know so it’s like all in the head um yeah i guess that brings us to like how can an nd support someone who’s experienced trauma because yeah yeah so there’s a few layers to that the place where i always start is an assessment and a shoring up or a stabilization of the foundations of health so like what what nds are you know functionally good at across the board because Like, are you sleeping? Are you eating enough of the right nutrients at the right times? Is your blood sugar regulated? Are your stress levels even remotely manageable, sustainable?
[45:14] Do you have the ability to move your body? Do you have a support system? Those are the like five foundations of health from my perspective and also they are like the you know the bottom of your maslow’s hierarchy in terms of health like we can’t do higher order healing whether it’s like regulating your reproductive hormones or healing your trauma if you’re not sleeping or eating enough or if your blood sugar is super dysregulated or if you can’t leave your house or can’t move your body in any way um.
[45:45] And it’s a common thing that also comes up with medication because psych meds are notorious for being mediocre in their efficacy. And I think a decent amount of that is because they’re not going to do very
[46:00] much if you’re not sleeping and eating. And that’s such a brutal catch-22 because mental health stuff, especially when you are in the throes of PTSD or complex PTSD, make it really hard for you to sleep and eat. And then people are like, take these drugs, and the drugs aren’t working, or you’re doing your CBT, and you just feel worse and worse because you’re taking the meds and you’re going to therapy, but you still don’t feel good. Yeah. Or you feel like your functioning is even decreasing even further. And so I always start with sleep and nutrition, and that’s different for every person. Sometimes it’s like we run labs and we make sure you’ve got adequate vitamin D and iron and B12s, common deficiencies that are going to contribute to mental health and your ability to be regulated in any regard. Sometimes it looks like, you know, sleep hygiene and sometimes it looks like medication to help you sleep better. Because if you are so, so sleep deprived and your sleep is so interrupted, we’re not going to be able to do any of the trauma work. You’re not going to be able, you have no chance at regulating if you’re getting three hours of interrupted sleep at night. So we start at the bottom, and we work there.
[47:10] Sometimes that’s, there’s like a lot of education involved there because often people come to me and then they are like, okay, I’m drowning in trauma or I’m stuck in complex PTSD. Like, how do I get out of this? And I’m like talking about sleeping and what you’re eating for breakfast. And it’s important for me as the practitioner to make sure that they understand why that stuff is important and how it’s going to help them to feel better.
[47:33] And I love starting there for, in addition to that, like it is the prerequisite to everything else we want to do. I love starting there for two reasons. One is that so often when we start there, a lot of the symptoms that people are struggling with correct themselves on their own because the body has the innate capacity to heal when we give it the building blocks that it needs and we remove the obstacles in the way. And so I think it’s a very useful way for us to get out of the trap of like a supplement for every symptom or a drug for every symptom. It’s like, well, when you sleep and eat and give the body its basic building blocks, you know, half your symptoms are going to get better. And then the other half, okay, those are what we build a treatment plan for. And the other thing that I think is really important about that step of the trauma recovery work is that most people who have been drowning in trauma and struggling for long enough to come and see me have lost a lot of faith in their body and a lot of trust. And a lot of trust is broken between their body and their ability to interpret what their body needs. And I think rebuilding that trust or maybe building it for the first time that like your body is sending you messages and you can learn to interpret them in a way that allows you to take care of yourself and get to a place of happy, healthy well-being.
[48:53] That’s a really important part of, important part of healing and of trauma recovery. And so if we help people to see, like, I don’t give supplements or medications in a lot of cases on visit one, because people are so quick to attribute improvement to those things. But if all we did was we helped you to eat breakfast and go to sleep a little bit earlier, and then you feel, you know, a 50% reduction in your anxiety, which I hear all the time. Yeah people are like oh damn like okay this is real and when I take care of my body it actually does feel better and you start to like build your we get to start to build a blueprint for people of like what are their baseline needs this is the thing that you want to do every day for the rest of your life to take care of yourself so we’re empowering them it’s the you know teach a person to fish thing like I want them to not need me anymore and this is part of how we do that to be able to help them to understand, okay, what does my sleep and my diet and my supplements and my social support and my movement need to look like in order to set me up to be able to do that stuff? And how do we make that sustainable for people? I love that. That’s where we start. Yeah. Yeah. It’s like, yeah. I know we said before we recorded, I’m like, let’s talk about mental health and what NDs do because it is my focus. But you lose yourself in the weeds as you’re talking about the specifics and the extra things and the cool new therapies or the angles.
[50:21] And what is really beautiful about natural health medicine this is like the topic of a new sub stack i’m working on but like the but we’re really the biopsychosocial yeah you know um that model like you know because, And a lot of people will kind of get that biopsychosocial from various practitioners, but an ND is really true. Like, that’s what holistic means, ultimately.
[50:48] And, yeah, like, so many, like, in my psychotherapy practice, a lot of people who, like, there’s probably a blood sugar dysregulation here. And all the talk therapy in the world or somatic work is not going to fix that, you know? It might help you understand you need to eat. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. But a lot of the time with that, like being tired and needing to regulate your blood sugar, like you were saying, there’s sometimes a disconnect in that biofeedback of really even understanding what those signals mean or what those cues mean. Especially if that hasn’t been built in when you were a baby like the inner child kind of needs that safety and that reconnection with like talking about like ifs like the different parts and how do we take care of ourselves recognize what it feels like to be tired it’s time to go to bed even if you might also be kind of wired or um procrastinating when it comes to sleep like revenge bedtime procrastination or yeah you know you’re so um hungry that you don’t really feel hungry anymore. You just feel anxious and almost nauseous. You don’t really think that food would help, but then you develop this relationship with yourself where it’s like, oh, actually, that’s when I should eat, you know? So there’s a lot of these pieces of like, how do we learn how to take care of ourselves?
[52:08] Yeah, so it’s all of that. And it’s all of that through a trauma-informed lens, which means that we’re approaching all of this without judgment. And we’re building a plan to help those pieces get accessible for the patient at whatever pace works for them. The understanding that a lot of people will come to this point like they know that they’re not eating well and they know that they’re not sleeping well and if this you know like if all they needed to do was to have somebody tell them to do it better they would have done it already right so there are there are things that are blocking them from being able to make those changes and so that’s why i really like having to getting to wear multiple hats under one license because I you know my my coaching clients are also my patients and so we can like jump back and forth for me to say like okay like let’s maybe do a coaching session here where we talk about the parts of you that are resistant to taking care of yourself or to explore why it doesn’t feel safe or even accessible to listen to the signals that your body is giving you.
[53:19] And then we can jump back in to the naturopathic work and be like okay now that it feels a little bit safer for us to even talk about what you’re eating or to be able to even give any attention into how you’re making food for yourself because it no longer is like going to trigger a full disordered eating flare or whatever okay now we can talk about yes you need 30 grams of protein at breakfast and you need to have that before caffeine and you know all of those things so it’s like a back and forth of that um and then also compounded by an awareness of how many people come here for this work with a history of being really mistreated or dismissed by other medical professionals like the medical trauma layer it’s really common in women especially and in mental health um patients and in like you know people in bigger bodies or people that aren’t straight or that aren’t monogamous or that aren’t you know like that don’t fit the standard you know, white straight norm basically skinny you know all of those things yeah and so it’s like building a therapeutic relationship and a relationship with themselves to be able to make those changes.
[54:28] To make them accessible and to make them sustainable and like yes you and I could talk forever about like the herbs and the supplements and I’ll give you my 10 cents on on psych meds because I think that’s a really cool layer but so much of it is the foundational piece, but just really like taking our time in the foundations to be able to make it feel possible for people. Yeah, that’s a great point, right? Because there’s sort of the…
[54:56] I’m very resistant to the idea of protocols, even though it’s, but sometimes these courses or packages, they can be accessible to people, right? When you do your own research and go to Chachi PT and here’s, but there’s a lot to the art of like, okay, yeah, sleep, breakfast, but how does that look like? Like what does that look like for the particular person right and how much time do we need to just spend on psychoeducation and like letting them like kind of helping match the symptoms to that or letting someone talk and you know express what they already know about their sleep or what their obstacles are what their difficulty is or um yeah like looking at yeah like the ifs like there’s a lot of um stuff that comes out around lifestyle changes around like the the inner rebel and then the inner critic and their dance. And sometimes people will describe, like, I know I need to exercise. I really want to exercise. I have so many values that are connected to getting stronger, longevity, but I just can’t do it. And then we often discover that there’s a rebel that’s trying to stand up to the critic who is like.
[56:12] Yes, you have these values, but the critic is also kind of shaming you. Why aren’t you living up to your values? What’s wrong with you? And then there’s a rebel that’s like, no, I don’t want to live this way. I don’t want to live under your rule. And so looking at that, you might not see any change on the surface. You might not be lifting a weight for many months as we kind of tease that apart and understand it. You know yeah another one I see often there in that realm is people that have all those values but are really resistant to doing the work because they didn’t get cared for in the way that they deserve to as a kid and so there’s a lot of resistance to being like I’ve been caring for myself my whole life I it’s like not fair that I have to do even more to get myself out of this hole that got dug for me by trauma that I experienced as a kid. So there’s like a lot of grief work often to be able to sit with like how shitty and unfair it is. Like, yeah, that sucks. And it’s okay that you really don’t want to do this work right now, you know, and how can we make space for that and allow you to feel and metabolize and process those feelings of like, Like, yeah, this, it’s not fair that you have to do all of this work on top of all the work you’ve been doing already
[57:27] to, you know, to get yourself here. That you’re still, yeah, you’re still having to do this. Like, you’ve been adulting since you were five.
[57:36] And, yeah, I can see, like, there’s a, you know, without kind of really understanding or unpacking that layer, sitting in front of someone who even compassionately or, you know.
[57:51] Benevolently is like, okay, like, let’s eat protein at breakfast. It’s like, here’s another thing I’m doing wrong. Here’s another thing I have to do. Like, feeling that.
[58:00] Burden of like okay so I’m already I’ve already been feeding myself cooking for myself planning my own meals my whole life but now you’re telling me that I have to fix it even more there’s something that I wasn’t like yeah totally yeah exactly yeah and so like my stance on that is like there are no such things there’s no such thing as a non-compliant patient only a practitioner who is missing a piece that’s education or compassion or the trauma layer or the resistance or whatever But yeah, it’s all of that. Yeah. For patients listening, you can come back if you haven’t done anything. Yeah. A lot of the time people will say like, I’ve been wanting to come back. I haven’t been feeling better, but I’m just worried because I didn’t do the thing you said. But that’s an amazing opportunity because especially when we’re getting to know somebody, you can say like, okay, like sleep, let’s work on getting to bed 30 minutes earlier. Let’s come back. And then we often don’t know what the obstacles are until we try. Yep. So that’s a good opportunity to come back and be like, hey, look, I didn’t do it. And we can work together to understand why, you know. Yeah. Yeah. And that’s the thing that I now like build into my patient communication, especially after our first visit. I’m saying, okay, here’s what we’re going to do in the second visit. We’re going to check in on all these things that I’ve suggested for you. And if they’re going well, this is what we’ll do. And if you didn’t, none of them, this is what we’ll do. And so that they can know like there is space here. It is safe here. I’m not going to be like chastising them.
[59:29] And that’s part of a trauma-informed practice is to like really be very transparent with your patients and with your clients about what’s happening so that they are not going to be scared or not going to be surprised or not going to be blindsided, because trauma is like ultimately about, having your agency removed yeah so if you give people back their agency it’s a big part of the healing process yeah and i’m glad that you brought up the medical trauma piece because i think that’s huge right like i remember talking to a friend about this and she was like i just can’t take a like i can’t take a supplement or an herb that’s recommended there’s something about just.
[1:00:10] Like having you be like we should try like melissa the herb that just feels like i don’t want to just take advice when it’s given to me like there’s an immediate kind of um defense that comes up like i need to maintain my own agency so i can’t you know i’m so used to just being told what’s good for me or what’s going to happen and and i thought that was really interesting and very self-aware of her and you know we don’t always have that kind of like, awareness of when it’s happening but yeah that’s yeah like yeah but if you have yeah if you’ve got a patient that comes back and they say like okay well I didn’t do any of the stuff that you said like you can either approach that from like okay well what now or you can get curious like hey let’s explore why that felt inaccessible for you and let’s get let’s spend time like working through that so that we can figure out how to make it accessible for you yeah yeah the nice thing too about natural medicine is there’s so many herbs, supplements, angles, ways to approach something that, And something, I’m not an expert on this, but something that’s always been interesting to me is when someone kind of has an intuitive sense around an herb or supplement, like one person was like, I had a dream about this herb last night for some reason, like Hawthorne or, you know, and that’s great. Let’s go with that.
[1:01:33] Um but sometimes people like i just don’t want to take iron i don’t know why like i know it’s good for me i know and so to be able to trust that and allow that can also really help build someone’s self-trust and agency and then the therapeutic relationship okay don’t let’s not take iron let’s go somewhere else with this um as opposed to like yeah fighting or doubling down like there’s a million other ways to yeah maybe get iron or maybe there’s something else that needs to happen first and our body is so complicated that it isn’t so linear like low iron take iron you know yeah um yeah yeah totally the number one rule in my practice is no forcing like i am not going to force you to do anything i don’t want you to force yourself to do anything even if it’s a thing i’ve told you you should be doing because if if you have to force it it’s a it’s a cue to us that there’s resistance there that we should get curious about and at the very least if you’re able to force it, it’s not going to bring about sustainable change.
[1:02:34] Because most of my patients come to me with a background of trauma and either come to me directly for trauma work or for the physical manifestations of trauma. I think the no forcing rule is a very foreign concept for a lot of them because they’ve had to force themselves to do things for a long time. And also that rhetoric is really reinforced by society. Be like, oh, you’ve got a headache, take an Advil, go back to work. Oh, you’re tired? Have caffeine. Go back to work. Oh, you have your period? Suck it up. You know, like forcing is like a part of our life because of capitalism and the patriarchy and all of that stuff. And so if we can start to.
[1:03:11] And what it does is it really reinforces that you shouldn’t be listening to
[1:03:16] the messages your body is sending you. And then over time, that just dilutes your ability to even interpret them at all. So if we can really work back into a flow and a reciprocal, safe relationship with your body and its messages, and maybe it’s no iron right now, and maybe three months from now, they’ll be ready to take iron, but willingly. And and I would much rather us wait three months and then work into a plan that feels accessible to them because we’re building these plans for life and so like three months on the scale of doing being able to take care of yourself for the rest of your life is a drop in the bucket yeah but the alternative is that I like you know force you or you force yourself to do this thing in spite of what your body is saying in this moment that’s going to fracture our therapeutic relationship, likely, it’s also going to further break the trust between you and your body, and it’s not going to help you get better long term.
[1:04:10] Yeah. And a lot of this is like a patience and an immense amount of trust in the inner wisdom of the person’s nervous system. And that doesn’t always mean that their dreams are right or their intuitive sense is, you know, like, yes, that’s exactly what you need. But it’s coming from somewhere. and to honor that and to work with that and to meet the patient where they’re at I think is really the the key yeah yeah like I think you know you really want to like honor someone’s intuition and like how they’re building that trust with themselves and their gut instinct and um you know it’s not I know better or this is the way because you’re yeah um I love that yeah Yeah.
[1:04:59] And I’m also thinking, you know, how sad it would be if someone, because it takes a lot to finally reach out, right? Like many patients will say like, I’m thinking about this for eight months, a year, multiple years, like I’ve been following you, listening to your podcast. And now I’m finally booking an appointment and you know how sad it would be if there’s a rupture that you know yep, where the person’s like okay like I I need to be at a certain level of like readiness or I need to like.
[1:05:31] Take this on wholesale if I am going to get this kind of help, as opposed to being met where I’m at. Yeah. Wherever that is. Yeah. Yeah, I agree. Yeah. Yeah. You said you had something to say about psychiatric medication. Oh, that’s like that. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. This is my own personal little soapbox. So in British Columbia, natural medical doctors have a pretty broad prescribing scope. And so we prescribe most of the things that a GP can prescribe or an NP, like a primary care provider, because we are primary care providers here. We can’t prescribe anything scheduled. So like no opiates, no benzos, that kind of stuff. But all the psych meds are in our prescribing scope. And not that many of our colleagues out here are trained in them. So not that many people use them. But SSRIs are a common drug that lots of people use, especially GPs.
[1:06:25] And I think they are a really, really useful drug and potentially life-saving
[1:06:31] in a lot of cases, and they are often not well understood. And so then they are misprescribed or misused in a way that perpetuates the stereotype of them. And so I think, so the way that I use SSRIs and the way that I think they are best served or best serving the patient is to use them to support the expansion of the patient’s window of tolerance like it’s like you know you are leaning your whole body against that closet and you’ve only got one arm and an ssri like gives you a longer reach no or it gives you a second arm and it like doesn’t um it doesn’t so i think a common error that people make is prescribing too high yeah and it results in just like a numbing out like a disconnection from the feelings and for some people that is what they want because they have no skill set or understanding of like why feeling their feelings is important or how that can be productive or valuable for them.
[1:07:31] And it’s not a criticism of GPs. They aren’t properly trained in a lot of ways as well. And so they just have their patients coming back saying, I’m drowning in my anxiety, and they don’t know what else to do but to increase the dose.
[1:07:45] But I think the best and most effective dose is the lowest dose that you can get that gives you more capacity, that makes you feel like you’ve got a little bit.
[1:07:57] More room to handle what life throws at you that doesn’t numb you out that doesn’t disconnect you from your feelings and also doesn’t you know give you bad or uncomfortable side effects yeah um but with my patients um like escitalopram or lexapro is a is the most common one of the most common SSRIs that we use now and the research as done by the drug companies suggests that the starting dose is 10 milligrams. And I start a lot of my patients, most of my patients, I would say at two and a half milligrams. It’s like a literal 25% of the starting dose of what’s recommended. And most of my patients see benefit, you know, and we get up to like five milligrams or seven and a half milligrams and some they’re at 10 and that’s great. And I’m not at all opposed to people taking a higher dose when they need it. But I have a lot of patients that have a history of being on SSRIs and they came off of them because they didn’t like how disconnected they felt because they started at 10 or, you know, an equivalent starting dose of another drug. And, you know, it’s just, you know, the analogy I always make here is like, you know, it would be about equivalent of somebody saying like, oh, I’ve got a really brutal headache. And somebody say like, oh, take ibuprofen 20 milligrams. Like the minimum effective dose of ibuprofen is 200 milligrams in most people. And so if you don’t, if you’re not familiar with that, you’d take 20 milligrams of ibuprofen, you’d be like, oh, that drug is stupid. It doesn’t work.
[1:09:24] And it was actually just not the right dose. And the same thing is true in a lot of drugs, but especially in SSRIs, which have just such a really bad rap. Yeah. Because I think they’re often dosed too high. Yeah, I agree. Like, yeah, I think I’m really happy that you mentioned that because I think a lot of the way that studies are designed, you want to see an outcome, you want to see an effect. You don’t want to do a really, really long study because that’s very expensive. And you’re also going to get like a placebo response in the placebo group that’s pretty robust, especially with subjective symptoms like mental health. You know, you’re not measuring blood pressure. You’re not looking at like an MRI. not like you’re just how are you feeling are you eating like so yeah but what i i totally agree like i think um what i see very often it’s interesting that it’s usually like i see this so much with zoloft or sertraline for ocd which can be extremely crippling for a lot of people that’s not a good word but like destabilizing for a lot of people like caught up in like rumination and unable to function and just really trapped in those sort of thought loops.
[1:10:37] And very often, like, okay, I’m trying Zoloft, you know, first, I think it’s 25. And they’re like, and that’s great. That works really well. And then their GP is very often like, okay, so you’re tolerating it. Okay, so we’re going to 50.
[1:10:53] And then they don’t feel as great. And the benefit isn’t really there. And we often have a conversation where I’m like, let’s just stay at 25. But maybe even better to start even lower and just see what’s the minimum effective dose because there’s yeah you know often a trade-off like the more the higher the dose the more the side effects you know yeah yeah exactly yeah and i think um i end up starting with lexapro often because it’s a tablet so you can cut it in half but my patients uh who prefer serotonin will just get it compounded and then we do drop dosing to figure out whatever less than 25 milligrams is a good place for them to start. I think it’s a common misconception that the.
[1:11:32] Instructions that are determined in a study are exactly how you’re supposed to do it in in your clinical community practice and having you know interacted with researchers that are running these studies like they are out there saying like no no this is not what this is to determine safety and efficacy this is not to determine best practices yeah and I think that’s a thing that’s often overlooked and like we could talk about how like you only have five minutes with the patient and so you don’t have time to think about like what’s the best practice you’re just trying to do the best that you can in a really limited amount of time in the conventional system at least so I understand the contributing factors but I think there’s a lot of art to prescribing yeah and I think it’s worth it to talk about it because these drugs I have so many patients that it took them like five plus years to get comfortable with taking this drug because there’s so much negative rhetoric around taking SSRIs or taking any medication for your mental health stuff. And so many of these patients are like, oh my God, I have a life now. I wish I started taking this drug five years ago. Yeah. It’s a good point too, to point out how that might perpetuate a stigma.
[1:12:47] Also, it’s held up as like, this is the first line treatment. If you have depression or anxiety, then you get one of these medications and that’s kind of it. Yeah. Versus the, and that is kind of how it’s studied, right? It’s like, we just want to see what’s the effect on like the GAD score for your anxiety, you know, like, is there going to be an effect? And you’d probably have to prescribe pretty high to see something change. But I love that you talk about the window of tolerance. It’s like, we don’t want to numb your feelings. We just want to create a bit of softness around and expand. And for listening, window of tolerance is sort of like.
[1:13:23] You know, where you’re regulated and connected to yourself and above the window you’re hyper aroused and below you’re in a dissociative state or under aroused.
[1:13:33] And like the work is kind of done within that window. So if you can kind of soften the edges and like open it up a little bit, then work is done inside of that, whether it’s like lifestyle stuff or therapy. Be but that also implies that there’s like other things that you’re going to receive, in terms of treatment not just the substance you know yeah and like a one of the there are kind of a few main questions that i use to help people decide if starting medication is the right choice for them and like we already said earlier like it’s it’s almost never the place that i start like we start with all the foundational stuff but one of the big questions is do you feel like you have the capacity to add more things into your life in terms of supplements or therapy or practices or meditation or exercise or whatever in order to continue to work on improving your mental health right now and um or do you not have capacity for that right now and in which case sometimes medication is the right answer because it very quickly gives you more capacity like it expands your window of tolerance which like allows you to.
[1:14:39] Takes the intensity down off of the like high highs and the low lows. That’s what the drug does. And then expanding your window of tolerance gives you more capacity to handle feelings and stress and tasks without getting super dysregulated. And then another question that I use to help people make this decision is like, do you have, based on how you’re feeling right now, do you feel like you could hang out here for another like two or three months while we build these practices and like get you to eat regularly and get you to take your meds and or take your supplements and do your workouts and do your journaling and go to therapy? Or do you feel like, no, I need to feel better yesterday or else something bad is going to happen? Then, okay, that also helps us to decide what is the first treatment. And like you said, if I’m prescribing a medication, that’s by no means the only thing I’m doing. It’s just the beginning or like a step in giving us more capacity to be able to implement all the other things. And for some people, it’s this is a drug they want to be on for the rest of their lives. And for some people, it’s more capacity temporarily so they can learn how to do all this other.
[1:15:43] Tools and like ways of managing their mental health so that they don’t need the drug down the road and like i’ve got no attachment to one one outcome or the other it’s just how can we help you to feel better and get to the place you want to be yeah so it’s like yeah true holistic kind of biopsychosocial prescribing of like yeah do you need to do you need immediate relief and And, you know, I mean, our style of medicine is quite active, you know, so if that and that’s not always accessible for people like, you know, we’re asking you to, okay, like, add some things and take some things and that’s adding more to your plate. So, you know, if you’re already squeezed, then it may not be possible to add more things. Those are great questions. Yeah.
[1:16:30] And then a low dose is easier to wean off of. Yeah. Yeah.
[1:16:36] Yeah. And it’s also like the slower we build, even if we end up working up to 10 milligrams, if we do it slowly, then we’re also in the process giving you more opportunity to get to know what your body is saying and to feel the changes and to as opposed to just like barreling through and like placing you in this new mindset of like, oh, I’m not drowning in depression anymore. Like, well, actually, let’s give you the opportunity to be present in that process so that you can really understand what it feels like as you start to feel lighter or feel things less intensely or feel more capacity, which is a part of, you know, like learning how to.
[1:17:14] Like, the process of healing, especially in trauma, mental health, nervous system recovery stuff, is learning to have a relationship with your nervous system. And you can’t have a healthier relationship with anything if you don’t speak its language. Yeah. And this is the part like we have and learning language takes time. Yeah. And and and it also takes exposure. And so if we build that up more slowly, then we have a greater capacity for exposure to the signals that your body is giving you that you can then learn to interpret and that strengthens your ability to speak to and engage with your nervous system and with your body in a healing, sustainable way.
[1:17:51] Yeah that’s a great point right when you’re like kind of titrating up very slowly you can like watch the change like what do i feel as opposed to oh my gosh i’m at 25 milligrams this is like maybe too high for me yeah and it’s like too big of a jump and yeah are there oh go ahead yeah go ahead like you said like some people are in such an acute state that they like that’s not the time where we learn the language like that’s the time where we get immediate relief and so we we don’t have to do it slowly we can do the slow on the other end as we taper down as well so it’s just it’s really it’s about meeting the patient where they’re on as opposed to just like applying a protocol to every patient universally yeah it’s like if someone’s screaming at you in a language you don’t speak you’re like i’m not gonna get my like book out i don’t know yes yeah like do i need to get off the road am i like stepping on something you know yeah yeah Yeah.
[1:18:48] So like I need to calm down or have like a more regulated state to be able to like start to interpret and learn the vocabulary and hear the syllables.
[1:18:59] I was going to ask, though, if there are other, so for people who are very against medication or for us Ontario practitioners that don’t have prescribing and can’t kind of titrate doses, do you use other stuff that works in the serotonin pathway? Like have you find that that’s effective or yeah yeah I it works a little bit differently than medication but for a lot of people it’s the right choice for for various reasons um,
[1:19:25] I use a combination of supplemental nutrients and botanical medicine. Lots of magnesium and higher dose EPA omega-3s and St. John’s Word in really high doses, but like concentrated doses.
[1:19:42] Saffron, ashwagandha, theanine, inositol. There’s lots of nutrients and a handful of plants. Um hawthorne is a nice one for like the the panic palpitations that people feel so yeah there’s there’s a combination of things that i will use for sure and lots of my patients don’t want to be on meds or can’t be on meds or you know were and had a bad time and so there’s like many many tools that we can use and a lot of it is also about getting really curious about so like once we’ve established the foundations what are the underlying drivers that are contributing to the anxiety or the depression and like in some people yes it is just like pure you know neurotransmitter biochemical imbalance we think but there are a lot of people for whom it’s like you know a histamine thing or a reproductive hormones thing or a menopause thing or a gut health microbiome thing or an inflammatory thing and so it’s also really a lot about like what getting curious about what or the root causes that we can influence from a more broad perspective.
[1:20:52] And that just generally also tends to work better, more sustainably, and gets us away from just like symptomatic management and like the, you know, they call in school, they call it green allopathy, like prescribing a supplement for a symptom, which is like sometimes the trap that GPs or MDs can fall into as well. Yeah. So, yeah, it’s so easy to kind of Yeah, I get wrapped up into like, I just want to help. I just want someone to feel better. And you, um, the fixing part or the performance part wants to kind of like, you know, um, yeah, one of my most popular, like I made this YouTube video, I don’t even know, 10 years ago, I don’t know about, uh, about, uh, amino acids. I don’t even know. It’s not even a good video, but it’s so popular compared to my other YouTube. And it’s just very interesting because like I always think I’m like what is so attractive about the idea but I think I mean this idea of like you’re right my medication stigmatized so people looking for kind of an alternative based on that neurotransmitter idea but also this I just want relief I just want to feel better you know so I did a follow-up video saying like yeah they can be helpful, but I, you know, kind of like a pyramid. I mean, you know, by the time that we’re working on neurotransmitters.
[1:22:16] Maybe we find that’s not really the thing that’s out of balance, you know, but I like that. I like the frame that you created of like, well, you know, when do we start with foundations and when do we start kind of at the top of the pyramid to provide relief? You know yeah exactly yeah yeah which is like functionally it’s are your symptoms the thing that is impairing you from being able to sleep or eat or take care of yourself yeah okay well then we treat your symptoms first so that we can then down the road or three weeks or it’s free you know a month from now start working on the foundations but it’s it’s the same thing we were saying before like if you just shout louder at somebody that they need to sleep more and eat more and that It doesn’t address the reason why they’re struggling to do so. Right. Yeah. Yeah. We talk a lot about like vicious cycles, right? So where do you address it? And where do like chicken and egg kind of cycles? Like where do you start with the chicken or the egg? And sometimes it doesn’t matter. It’s just about patient preference and what, you know, they intuitively feel because, you know, if you take a neurotransmitter to help with sleep and then you sleep better, well, then now you’re sleeping better. And then that’s addressing the underlying thing or if you’re able to work on sleep then might regulate your neurotransmitters so it’s kind of just about where it makes sense to start and yeah yeah i love that collaborative aspect i think um.
[1:23:39] It can feel a little bit foreign for a lot of people that has a practitioner that’s like, you know, woody, like kind of turning it over to you and not just telling you what to do. I think a lot of people are like, oh, my gosh, wait, I have to make the decision. I don’t know what I need to do. You’re the doctor.
[1:23:53] Yeah. Yeah. And I ask my patient that question all the time. Like, hey, here are some options.
[1:23:58] Which path do you think feels the most accessible or the most aligned with you? And, yeah, often people are caught off guard. And so, like, sometimes I will walk them through, like, here are my thoughts. Like, here are the pros and cons. Here’s how I would make that decision but I think it’s actually really important for us to.
[1:24:14] Give the power back to the patient like a lot of the values that I operate from in my practice is that to like minimize the power differential as much as possible like I’m not the boss I also don’t know what’s best for your body more than you do yeah and so but but the the world, and the medical system and especially if you’re a woman especially if you’ve got any mental health challenges has just told you over and over and over that like you have to outsource everything to somebody smarter than you or with more letters after your name or with more power than you and like that is part of the problem yeah totally yeah i just had this conversation with a friend it’s a little bit of a non-sequitur but we were talking about societal pressure to like for women to have children and i’m like you know it’s like if somebody’s like don’t you have kids and it’s like okay let’s like unpack this for a second like I would have to be the one to be pregnant to deliver a baby to care for a baby so you know you’re you’re telling somebody you need to take iron but you’re not the one going to buy the iron taking the iron swallowing iron maybe feeling nauseous from the iron so it’s all well and good to give someone advice but to actually have the burden of having to follow through and do it and be in the body.
[1:25:32] Is, yeah, that’s, you know, that’s something else. So, yeah, to be able to, like… Allow someone to embody their health experience again.
[1:25:42] And information is so accessible that I think maybe that is helpful for the power differential a little bit too. Like a lot of patients are coming in with a lot of, like kind of a massive confusa of information that, you know. As long as we are receiving it with grace and being like, yeah, bring me your questions. I would love to, you know, like dispel your Reddit myths or show you the data on why I think this is true but conversely if we’re if we’re receiving that as an attack or a threat to our ego or you know like you know shut up about your doctor google like that’s just going to perpetuate the problem but yeah yeah yeah but i that’s one of my favorite things to do is like yeah bring me all the nonsense you find out on tiktok and we’ll parse it apart here’s the evidence that i know here’s the evidence that disproves that here’s the question mark or the gray area that like maybe that’s true but here are the risks here’s how you make that choice because i i think it’s you know our jobs are evolving as the world around us evolves and i think part of you know like, docere is the root, you know, Latin word for doctor, which means teacher. And I think that’s a big part of our job is to give people the opportunity to learn how to take care of themselves in the world that we are living in in 2025, which now means how do you interpret.
[1:27:00] Media and social media and all of the nonsense that’s out there? And how do you figure out what’s right for you? Yeah, exactly. Like the common, I’m sure you get questions. I get question all the time and the answer is always it depends because there’s a reason that the intakes are an hour and a half like we got to sit with everything and go through it and but another thing i really love is the the broad spectrum of of being an nd is that i don’t feel beholden to any or in love with any particular therapy of course i have my biases like we all do but, I’m okay with killing off darlings like you know I’m there’s I don’t want to make myself sound amazing I’m sure there’s lots of resistance that my parents have encountered sometimes but um you know like because we there’s a big toolbox yeah like okay supplement like one person came in um a few people actually have been like it’s not good to take vitamin d and so I kind of went down a rabbit hole and unpacked it and came in and out of the cave. And I think my point that I’m sitting at now is that maybe we should probably take vitamin D in the winter because we don’t make it. But, you know, our bodies are complicated and the thing like there really isn’t an answer. Like even the best study with the best outcome is not going to be 100% effective.
[1:28:25] You know, whatever it is, even exercise, even all the things that we know are amazing, like exercise, like the you know um there’s tons and tons of nuance and uh so much individuality and everyone’s different so it’s nice to kind of be a little bit you know like on our toes like a little bit um flexible with how you know yeah it’s that like open-minded um like personality trait that we it earlier i think there’s a make somebody a really good physician because i think the analogy i are the example i always use here is like the doctors in the early 1900s were making fun of and laughing at the guy who suggested that we start washing our hands between autopsies and deliveries because he they were like yeah you right yeah right there’s like imaginary invisible little poisonous dudes in the air you know and it turns out germ theory is real yeah we didn’t have the right tools to study at back then. And so those guys that thought he was.
[1:29:28] Making stuff up, didn’t have any evidence for germ theory. And, like, it’s hard to fault them for that. And I think it’s really worthwhile for us to remember that, like, we are not by any means at the pinnacle of our understanding of the body or science or of medicine. Like, we know way more than we did five years ago and, you know, a ton more than we did 100 years ago, but we do not know everything.
[1:29:51] And it is really complicated. And I think it’s really important to, as a care provider to not get trapped in the like belief that we have all the answers because it’s it’s an ego trap it’s going to result in you know like making an unsafe space for your patients but also.
[1:30:12] Closing like prematurely closing your mind to what the possible solutions are, yeah i love yeah and the that story with saml weiss saml weiss yeah yeah yeah wasn’t he um He had his license removed. Yeah. That’s for being like, oh, you know, maybe we shouldn’t deliver babies after we handle cadavers without washing our hands in between. And they were like, you’re a quack. Yeah.
[1:30:40] Yeah, totally. Yeah. A lot of humility in that, you know. It’s funny, though, like you hear that story of when you’re like, oh, yeah, we would never. They were idiots back then. But then, you know, you can really humble yourself by thinking like, well, what are we doing now that we’re going to be disgusted by in like 50 years or 100 years, you know? Yeah. So tread kind of carefully, you know? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. Live with that uncertainty a little bit, I think. Yeah, I think you’re right. I think, you know, kind of flexibility, open-mindedness, humility, curiosity is important to be a practitioner and give the power back to patients because there has been an era in medicine where people have been disempowered and there’s like authoritarian structures in medicine. It’s like a very authoritarian system that I think is being dismantled. Like my GP feels very different. I know like the new generation of doctors feels a bit different. Agreed. Yeah. All of my peers that are like our age that are MDs are very different than the doctors that I grew up knowing. So, yeah, it is changing.
[1:31:47] And patients are different, too. Like people are encountering like a doctor who’s like, you know, not really working with them. And they’re pushing back or looking for a different practitioner, kind of not just accepting that answer. So, yeah, really encouraging and good. Yeah, agreed. I don’t think we’re mistaken about that in 100 years. They’re like, no, no, the authoritarian systems were right. Yeah, we’ll see, but I don’t think we’re mistaken about that. Yeah, I think we’re good. Yeah, I think it’s important for people to be empowered. I think that’s universally a good thing. I agree. Yeah. Any last thoughts, Jessica? Anything you’re offering? Anything you want people to know?
[1:32:30] Yeah, my private practice is in Vancouver, BC. I can see patients anywhere in British Columbia. So I do lots of virtual work as well as in-person work.
[1:32:39] I do have a little bit of private trauma recovery coaching, like separate from my medical practice for people that are outside of BC, if that’s of interest to you, if you’ve got specific like psychedelic integration stuff that you want to talk to me about um and hopefully by the end of this year i’ll have a trauma recovery um online program it’s like with my guidance um but again like more available for people at like a lower cost than seeing me in person and also not restricted to british columbia um but yeah i’m on instagram and the internet dr jess eastman that’s pretty Yeah, I think there’s a huge place for programs like psychoeducation programs and teaching people skills and having some guidance and can drop the burden of cost down a lot. Yeah. I’m glad you’re offering that. Yeah. Even for practitioners to take to learn, you know. Yeah, totally. It’s for everybody. But yeah, it feels important.
[1:33:35] Like I, you know, Vancouver is an expensive city and our work is expensive. And so I am very aware that the cost of seeing you or I is not accessible to everybody. And I hate that. And I also have to pay my bills. And but it’s important to me to make an offering that makes it more accessible to more people.
[1:33:57] Yeah. Amazing. OK, so people I’ll have links for people to find you and yeah, hopefully they can join in. And thank you so much for talking with me. Yeah, thank you. It was really lovely.
On Pet Loss, Crossing the Rainbow Bridge, and The Places Grief Lives
My grief is tremendous, but my love is bigger.
– Cheryl Strayed
For my entire childhood, I wanted a dog. I didn’t care what kind of dog it was; I just wanted one. A sensitive child entering the world of broken promises and ruptured friendships, I craved the unconditional love of an animal. I would read to him and tell her about school: my dissociated teachers, the kids who had hurt my feelings, and my dreams and aspirations. I imagined he would sit there, forever interested, lovingly listening.
My parents promised my brother and me a puppy when I was nine and he was six. Instead, we got hamsters, gerbils, fish, and turtles.
After spending Christmas with my family in Canada, I returned to Bogota, Colombia, with my ex-boyfriend, Joe. I was 24 years old and taught English for two years out of university. I walked into our shared apartment, set down my things, looked up, and there he was! A tiny, black and tan Yorkshire terrier—Coco Loco.
I sat with him across my lap. He tucked his little head inside the crook of my elbow—lights out. His soft head and cold, wet nose tickled the inside of my arm. He and I would sit this way, my arms around his curled-up body, his head tucked—yoked together in warmth and comfort until his last day.
Small, rambunctious and mischievous, Coco was a ferocious ball of unbridled puppy joy. He chewed everything, peed everywhere, and once unravelled an entire roll of toilet paper while waiting for me to get out of the shower.
We walked everywhere in Bogota. He travelled on buses and accompanied Joe and me on long hikes through the Colombian jungles and countryside, harassing chickens and balancing on logs stretched over deep, rushing streams. He was curious and intelligent, head cocked, ears alert, always with some agenda.
When it was time for me to leave Bogota and return to Toronto to start naturopathic college, Coco flew with me. Emerging from the confines of his travels, he was soon bounding around my parents’ yard, paws touching new soil. He loved Canada: the snow, the squirrels, his family. He grew to be 16 pounds, giant for a Yorkie.
For the next 15 years, Coco was my faithful shadow. He was there throughout my four years at the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine, witnessing me studying for and passing my board exams. Coco joined me on the ride to the centre for the first round of board exams, perched on my knees. As we pulled into the parking lot, he sensed my anxiety and started shaking. He was my emotional mirror, our bodies empathically in tune.
He watched me graduate and start my clinical practice. He saw me fall in and out of love, move, try and fail, and try again, his nose nudging my tears after every heartbreak and disappointment.
My naturopathic medicine practice moved online in 2020, and I became a psychotherapist in 2024. Coco was at my feet during every patient encounter, absorbing all your stories and witnessing your humanity.
For 11 years, Coco volunteered as a St. John’s Ambulance Therapy Dog. Once a week, he would proudly wait for my dad by the door in his uniform—a bandana that read, “Please Pet Me.” They’d roam the hospital halls, bringing cheer to patients and burnt-out staff.
In a blog I kept while at the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine, I wrote many posts about how Coco taught me to live. He brought me fully into my kinship with nature. We hiked through parks in Toronto and logged hundreds of kilometres on the Bruce Trail. I remember him gliding ahead along the narrow path, light streaming through the trees, an orchestra of birds punctuating the quiet rhythm of our footsteps and breath, hearts held by the magnanimous life that was all around.
Dogs offer us a pure form of love and connection. Their unconditional love can soothe the wounds accumulated from our imperfect human attachments.
They are grounded, noses connected to the Earth. And this grounding keeps their lives in the moment, up for adventure, and free from the overthinking and neurosis that block our trust and joy.
Dogs remind us of our ancient history, when we lived in tune with nature’s frequencies, a time long forgotten but deeply missed. Dogs’ presence tells us the truth: the doors on our cages and cubicles are unlocked. We are still wild. And the earth patiently awaits our return.
Nature has guided me through pain and heartache. When I lose touch with myself, I return to the beach and the forest to find it. Coco taught me this.
He brought me to the forest, set me free, and left me there. He died on April 22, 2025. And I’ve returned many times to find him among the roots, the leaves, and the joy of other dogs living fully, who love their lives enough to lose them.
Over a year ago, Coco stopped eating. As the vet was running tests, my stomach turned over with anguish. He was diagnosed with an inflammatory bowel disease, and his prognosis was poor. But, despite their size and teddy bear appearance, terriers are persistent, tenacious fighters. After a few days of steroids, antibiotics, and a special diet, Coco miraculously bounced back. Still, the vet cautioned that he would likely need to be on prednisone and his condition closely monitored for the rest of his life.
Over the next year, Coco stoically trudged on. He kept up his fighting spirit until his last day—terriers never give up. Although duller and more easily fatigued, he motored along Great Lakes beaches and hiked in Nova Scotia. When he could no longer walk much, he rolled around in his dog stroller or rode on my back. When he was too tired to lift his head, I sometimes walked alone.
The prednisone thinned his fur, whithered his muscles, and messed with his sleep. I had to carry him up and downstairs, help him stand, and carry him outside. Each night, at two, three, four in the morning, sometimes several times a night, I would haul myself out of bed, nauseous with exhaustion, to take him out. I would fumble for my keys and coat in the darkness, and we would stand outside, wordlessly shivering with cold. I would wait for him, watching the snow blow in the glow of the street lamps, my body begging to return to the warmth of my bed.
Other nights, I was too late and calmly cleaned his mess while he watched me, confused and ashamed.
Eventually, the vet confirmed his kidneys were failing. He stopped keeping his food down. He began coughing and struggling to breathe. His heart was failing.
When referring to putting down a pet, people will tell you you’ll know the right time. They will tell you a dog won’t get up, or they’ll stop eating. Or, the vet will confirm it, waking you from your indecision and denial. Sometimes old dogs will pass peacefully in their sleep. Most likely, however, you will have to decide when, where, and how to end your best friend’s life.
Euthanasia is an impossible choice, like cutting off a part of yourself to spare the whole. Coco couldn’t tell me in words what he wanted, but if he could, how could one choose a road unseen, with the destination unknown? When pets die, the poem goes, they cross the Rainbow Bridge. Beyond the bridge lies a lush, sunlit meadow, where animals run free with old friends, and rest in warmth and comfort, nourished and unhurt. It’s an image that’s brought comfort to many pet owners. I don’t know if the Rainbow Bridge exists, but I knew he was suffering here.
My heart cracked under the weight of it all, and I made the call: I would lovingly release him from this life and guide him to the bridge. It was time.
There is a saying in veterinary medicine, “Better a month too early than a day too late,” and I let that steady my hand as I made the arrangement for a hospice vet to come to our house on April 22nd at 4:00 p.m.
When the vet came and eventually took Coco away, she left a pamphlet that contained this poem, called The Last Battle, author unknown, that reads,
If it should be that I grow frail and weak
And pain should keep me from my sleep,
Then will you do what must be done,
For this — the last battle — can’t be won.
You will be sad I understand,
But don’t let grief then stay your hand,
For on this day, more than the rest,
Your love and friendship must stand the test.
We have had so many happy years,
You wouldn’t want me to suffer so.
When the time comes, please let me go.
Many pet owners wrestle with the idea that we shouldn’t have the power to end our companions’ lives. Yet we’ve made every other choice for them: what they eat, where they sleep, when they go out. “Euthanasia” means “good death.” Offering this to Coco felt like a final act of stewardship: a responsibility to our bond and a firm expression of my love. When the time comes, please let me go.
It is hard to describe those final days, as we both hung between worlds, at the threshold of the Rainbow Bridge. Time slowed down. Every breath and moment hung heavy before evaporating into the ethers of the past. Soon, the past was all we’d have.
Anxiety, fear, and doubt swirling around, I found the eye of the hurricane on those last days. We walked to the lake on our final night together to watch the sunset. A thick mist fell, and we settled on Muskoka chairs, Coco’s head tucked, our breathing in sync. I could feel his last few heartbeats against my thigh.
On April 22nd, I gave him a Perfect Last Day. We went to the Pet Store, ate cheeseburgers, wheeled through High Park, and took our last hike together, the sun warming our faces. Something in the air must have revealed the gravity of the moment, the brevity of our time and the impending goodbye, because people lingered around us.
Two older women walking in the park smiled as they passed, “He looks so comfortable in his stroller,” one said. When I told them it was his last day, they both embraced me as I sobbed. One of them took a picture of us together.
After saying goodbye to her beloved 19-year-old dog, my friend and her husband went to the lake. A lady snapped a photo of them, saying they looked beautiful watching the sunrise together. “Sometimes people can sense when a stranger needs a beautiful moment to hold on to,” she said. Grief can soften our walls and invite others in.
We went home and sat together that last hour, waiting for the vet. He lay on my chest. The sun was beautiful. I saw the shape of Yorkies in the clouds.
His last moments were peaceful; he never left my arms. “He’s gone,” said the hospice vet, gently. She gathered her things as I sat with him. Then she wrapped him up, and they were gone.
The mantle of loneliness wrapped me tightly. Now it was just my grief and I.
The word “grief” comes from the Latin “gravis,” which means “heavy” or “serious.” Related words are “grave,” “gravity,” and even “gravitas.”
As a society, we squirm away from grief. We fumble with the words to comfort and wrestle away from the stronghold of sorrow. We numb, distract, try to move on, and forget. But life’s truth is harsh: we will lose everything we love. Grief comes for us all; it is the work of the living to hold and process it.
Psychoanalyst Francis Weller says, “Grief is much more than an emotion. It is one of the central faculties of being human.
“Grief is a core capacity that allows us to digest the most bitter experiences into something meaningful, perhaps beautiful, something vital and alive.”
So often, depression is not depression at all, but oppression, unprocessed grief that accumulates around the heart like a sediment, blocking us from our vitality and the joy of our being (Weller, 2015). To chip away at this hardened sludge, we must learn to sit with grief, invite it in, name it, and give it space to release, thus becoming “skilled in the art of loss.” Grief work keeps the heart fluid and soft.
And so, I wade into the dark waters, welcomed by the other bereaved. When we dive into the blackness, we join the collective pool of human suffering. This community expands the heart’s container, deepening its wells of compassion. Grief work is soul work. It is necessary work.
Poet Rainer Maria Rilke says, “Yet, no matter how deeply I go down into myself, my God is dark, and like a webbing made of a hundred roots that drink in silence.”
We live in a culture of lightness, upward mobility, positivity, and optimism. We fear the descent into blackness.But my God is dark. We were gestated in the darkness of our mothers’ wombs. Our hearts beat in darkness. Seeds grow below the dark depths of the earth. Sometimes, we must enter the shadows, the depths of despair, to bring the riches back up to the light. Alchemical Psychology calls this descent “the nigredo.”
In the nigredo of grief, the ego softens. The rigid self we once hid behind begins to dissolve (Barn Life Recovery, 2020). We lose our usual sense of who we are, yet somehow become more fully ourselves. As we feel the pain of losing what we loved, we also feel love in its purest form. This is soul work because in the end, the soul remains.
Terry Tempest Williams says, “Grief dares us to love once more.”
What if we approach our grief experience not with resistance but hands together and head bowed in reverence?
According to Francis Weller, when we hold gratitude in one hand and grief in the other, and bring them together, we are now in the prayer of life. Oscar Wilde says, “Where there is sorrow, there is holy ground.”
In The Smell of Rain on Dust, Martín Prechtel writes that grief work is not only about expressing sorrow but transforming pain into beauty using the gifts given by the spirits. Grief requires a container and release. We must keep it warm through writing, poetry, meditation, contemplation, and art. Through creating, we weave the memories of those we’ve lost into the fabric of life and unravel the cycles of trauma born from unexpressed grief.
The morning after Coco died, I leapt out of the shower in a panic. I grabbed my phone and texted the hospice vet, asking them to change the urn I requested. I got back in the shower, calmer. Wait, was I crazy? I settled for a second, then threw open the shower curtain, suds flying, and texted back, “Sorry, no wait, the original decision stands, sorry, I changed my mind…again.” Was I insane?
Before Coco died, they had talked about the ashes. Did I want a private cremation? What did I wish for the ashes? The details had felt irrelevant, far away. I just wanted my dog. In Scandinavia, an individual would spend a sacred season in the ashes of their loss, occupying a parallel world of mourning, from which they would emerge changed (Weller, 2015). Ashes carry the gravity of what we’ve lost. My soul, too, knew it wanted to walk with the ashes. What would be reborn there?
In my closet now sits a memory box containing some of Coco’s things: his sweater, a collar, and a cherry twig, with buds, which I picked up the day of our last hike in a moment frozen in late April before the cherries blossomed. Martin Pretchel reminds us that grief is praise. It is a natural way to honour what one misses.
Many people offered comforting words, reminding me that Coco had a “Good Life.” In his book Going Home: Finding Peace When Pets Die, John Katz (2012) discusses the idea of the “Good Life.” He says, “When you clear away all of the emotional confusion, there is this: all we can give our pets is a Good Life. We can’t do more than that. We miss them because that life was good, loving, and joyful. Too often, this truth is lost in our grieving.”
Camus echoes the sentiment in saying, “The deeper the sorrow, the greater the joy.”
The box contains a framed picture of us at a lake in Quebec, watching the sunset—one beautiful moment among many of a life well-lived.
One thing people have said is that Coco will always be with me. I want to believe this, but as the distance from our last day grows, I feel him fading. I haven’t forgotten, but his presence feels quieter, harder to reach.
In his beautiful poem, For Grief, John O’Donahue writes,
Gradually, you will learn acquaintance
With the invisible form of your departed;
And, when the work of grief is done,
The wound of loss will heal
And you will have learned
To wean your eyes
From that gap in the air
And be able to enter the hearth
In your soul where your loved one
Has awaited your return
All the time.
Cheryl Strayed (2021) describes how her mother wanted her tombstone to say, I am always with you. “But I want you actually with me!” She protested. Coco and I will never make new memories again. He is another ghost gone into the gap in the air.
On the 30th anniversary of her mother’s death, Strayed writes, “Thirty years gone and my mother is always with me. Thirty years gone, and I still ache for her every day. Thirty years gone, and my sorrow has sweetened into gratitude.
“How lucky I am to have been her daughter. To still be. To feel her shimmering in my bones with every step.”
Sweet, little Coco, you will always be my dog.
Last week, I had my brother’s dog, Toby, with me. He is a 4-year-old mini golden doodle with nowhere to go while my brother and sister-in-law work, so I take him out sometimes. That day, he bounded around the beach, wild with joy, with a newfound freedom that must have felt like a dream.
I watched him with a heart that wanted to meet him in his happiness, but my heart still feels lost in the nigredo. When the work of grief is done, and the sediment is cleared, I’m not sure what I will find in my soul’s hearth, on the other side of sorrow’s edge. Maybe it will be Toby’s wild doggy grin, inviting me to play and dance among the dunes.
The poem I Walk With You (Author Unknown) goes,
I stood by your bed last night, I came to have a peep. I could see that you were crying, You found it hard to sleep.
I whined to you softly as you brushed away a tear, “It’s me, I haven’t left you, I’m well, I’m fine, I’m here.”
I was close to you at breakfast, I watched you pour the tea, You were thinking of the many times, your hands reached down to me.
I was with you at the shops today, Your arms were getting sore. I longed to take your parcels, I wish I could do more.
I was with you at my grave today, You tend it with such care. I want to reassure you, that I’m not lying there.
I walked with you towards the house, as you fumbled for your key. I gently put my paw on you, I smiled and said “it’s me.”
You looked so very tired, and sank into a chair. I tried so hard to let you know, that I was standing there.
It’s possible for me, to be so near you everyday. To say to you with certainty, “I never went away.”
You sat there very quietly, then smiled, I think you knew … In the stillness of that evening, I was very close to you.
The day is over and I smile and watch you yawning And say “goodnight, God bless, I’ll see you in the morning.”
And when the time is right for you to cross the brief divide, I’ll rush across to greet you and we’ll stand, side by side.
I have so many things to show you, there is so much for you to see. Be patient, live your journey out, then come home to be with me.
Last year, Nonna passed away, a few weeks before her 97th birthday. We must carry her with us, telling the “Nonna Stories” that capture her witty mind and fierce heart.
I took Toby to the woods where Coco and I used to walk. Young and free, he tore through the trees. “He doesn’t hike like Coco,” I told my mom. “He runs around in circles and doesn’t listen.”
“He’ll learn,” She said.
Last week, we found a quiet rhythm as we walked; Toby was a few paces ahead. He stopped, turned, and waited for me. Birdsong carried through the stillness. Something in the way he cocked his head reminded me of Coco. My heart still feels empty and full of missing him, but maybe, in the quiet hearth of my soul, head tilted, ears listening, he waits, too,
What the Aubrey Marcus “Radical Monogamy” Spectacle Can Teach Us About Betrayal Trauma, DARVO, and Coercive Control
On the surface, this is just another drama involving a handful of relatively obscure wellness influencers. Many of you may not even know who Aubrey Marcus is. But after diving into the podcast and wading through thousands of now-deleted comments, I was captivated by something more profound, and my mind couldn’t let go. The story provides an unsettling case study of the exploitation of trauma, patriarchal belief systems, and coercive control that can poison spiritual communities.
The almost three-hour podcast permeated the health and wellness space with the pungent stench of a multi-layered onion of betrayal, trauma, and cult psychology. Viewers witnessed a popular spiritual wellness influencer gaslight his wife, younger girlfriend, and followers, with the help of a mentor accused of predatory behaviour.
Something stirs as we reflect on collective stories of self-abandonment and blurred boundaries. What so often stays hidden is now available to name as we gather the missing pieces of ourselves, lost in our own battles of betrayal.
This Might Help with Dr. Talia ND, is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.Subscribed
Aubrey Marcus founded the supplement company, Onnit, with podcaster Joe Rogan. After selling the brand to Unilever, Aubrey launched into the wellness influencer/spiritual guru space. His offerings include podcasts, books, and Fit for Service, which offers “courses, events, and a community to transform your life.” His podcasts vividly detail forays with psychedelic medicines and explorations in love and relationships.
Aubrey built his brand on a sort of authenticity porn, trading vulnerability for views. He gazes into the camera, voice earnest and sincere, sharing the often deeply personal revelations he’s gleaned along his journey.
Essential to his poetic persona are unfiltered confessions about his sometimes complicated love life. He drags his partners into the spotlight, having recorded multiple podcasts with his ex-fiancée, Whitney Miller, and their experimentation with polyamory. Whitney was initially reluctant to open the relationship, and both encountered difficulties, which they shared openly.
In 2020, Aubrey abruptly left Whitney for Vylana after a ketamine trip revealed they were already divinely paired. Vylana was monogamous and, all of a sudden, so was Aubrey. Two weeks later, they were married. They launched their relationship to their followers in a podcast called “How to Prepare for True Love”(Marcus, 2020). The YouTube title on the episode reads, “Life was preparing us for this,” and the episode plays like relationship self-help advice. I remember listening to it while doing laundry, still reeling from the end of my last partnership, and feeling painfully lonely.
The episode lays out their love story in a display of enlightened exhibitionism. Aubrey reads out loud from his love letter to Vylana as her head leans back, eyes cast skyward, seemingly savouring a memory:
Dear Vylana,
What would it feel like to know that you are chosen, beyond a doubt?
How would it feel to be fully seen, for the full potential of who you are?
How would your heart feel never to worry that you were too much or not enough?
The magic has since worn off, but it’s embarrassing to admit a part of me fell for it. At the time, love had forsaken me, and I was snatching at whatever hope I could reach. Here was a real-life Beauty and the Beast-like fantasy love story—Divine Sacred Union. It was proof that one can heal attachment traumas and fear of intimacy with ferocious self-love. Vylana, with her sound bowls, angelic voice, and chiselled abs, finally claimed by her masculine equal, was now Queen of the Marcus brand.
I followed the love story for another episode and then dropped off. Their oversharing and tone-deaf Burning Man-style Indigenous cosplay became a bit much. However, many people continued to listen to the podcasts, attend Fit for Service events, and buy their relationship courses. Many held up the Aubrey and Vy Sacred Union as relationship inspiration. And so when it all blew up at the release of “A New Pattern of Sacred Relationship Emerges,” people erupted (Marcus, 2025).
Without the flowery word salad, the podcast can be summarized as follows: Aubrey and Vylana decided to open up their relationship. Alana is Aubrey’s new (younger) girlfriend. The three of them all get along, but the road wasn’t easy, so their friend, Dr. Marc Gafni (more on him later), has served as their mentor as they navigate this new dynamic.
However, much more was said. And even more was said beyond the confusing and often nonsensical wall of words.
The almost three-hour conversation is a case study in coercive control. Aubrey and Gafni sit on either side of the two women, Vylana and Alana (I know, and they look alike too), who do not speak until at least 20 minutes in.
First, Gafni takes the reins. He outlines a sort of Hegelian Dialectic: monogamous relationships are beautiful in theory, but are riddled with dishonesty and infidelity in reality. Aubrey confirms this; his friends suffer from the stress of cheating with physical health conditions like psoriasis (there is no talk of how their partners suffer).
When Vylana eventually speaks, she concurs. She has suffered relationship betrayal at the hands of all her previous partners, and this trauma still lives in her body. The solution is a new model of relationships in which (it is implied male) sexuality can be liberated from shame and secrecy and live in the glorious light of honesty and trust.
So, if you’re thinking, this seems like they’re just describing an open relationship, you’d be right. Except that Gafni says,
“Paradoxically, this is not about polyamory. That’s the paradox. It’s about radical monogamy, a deep, exclusive, lifelong, committed relationship. But not in the classic monogamous sense, it’s an EXPANDED monogamy. There’s a radical monogamy, but it’s not just a monogamy of two; it’s a slightly bigger monogamy.
“It’s a radical monogamy of deep exclusivity. And then there’s a new goddess who will also step into this field of radical monogamy in the field of erotic mystics.”
Got it? Much of the podcast is Gafni besieging listeners with blocks of text filled with nonsensical double-speak. The name “Radical Monogamy” is loaded language that inverts the meaning and is needlessly confusing.
Why is all this necessary? Aubrey’s marital vows aside, using the existing Ethical Non-Monogamy framework based on honesty, integrity, open communication, vulnerability, and trust would probably be a better approach to open the relationship. This way, they would benefit from the research, advice, and resources of others who have already forged the path.
I’m not an expert. But, after perusing essays and resources (including Reddit), I know that ethical non-monogamy requires consent. Consent must be informed, enthusiastic, specific, and freely given, without undue pressure or influence.
And, as we listen to the podcast further, it’s clear that Vylana doesn’t really want this. Throughout the conversation, she becomes visibly distressed, her shoulders tense, and she cries several times. Vylana talks about how she’s been pushed “past her edges” repeatedly and has “died hundreds of times.” Far from the sacred relationship that frauded their audience, this doesn’t seem healthy. It sounds abusive.
When consent is lacking, coercion is required. The 5 Ds—Double-speak, Double-vision, Double-binds, Double standards, and DARVO, which stands for Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim, and Offender—characterize coercive control (Rankin, n.d.). Gafni starts the party with double-speak: this isn’t non-monogamy, it’s radical monogamy, Trojan-horsed under a different name, mixed into a bowl of word salad.
Double-speak confuses the listener. It reinvents words and uses dissociated, abstract language to obscure true meaning. In the podcast, virtually no one gives clear examples or context. Vylana and Alana speak almost entirely using metaphors.
One commenter pointed out that it sounds like Alana is using predictive text, one ethereal word following another. When words and meanings are twisted and inverted, one can assume they’re in doublespeak territory (IndoctriNation, 2023).
On the first listen, it worked on me, because while their speech is disembodied and devoid of substance, it’s also incredibly persuasive. Despite my gut feelings, frustration and impatience while listening, I also envied the certainty and conviction with which they all spoke. I remember thinking that maybe I was the close-minded one, while the rest were moving into higher plains of human evolution. However, two memorable whack-a-doodle moments in the episode keep even the most open-minded firmly on the earth.
First, Aubrey shares that he got a message from “Spirit” in the middle of a workout telling him to go on the exclusive dating app, Raya (“So, I’m in the middle of my workout and I just get this message. And the message is ‘Go on Raya right now and you’re going to find somebody there that’s important’… and to ignore God at the moment to finish my workout, would be absurd”).
He swipes past the first girl (“No, that’s not it”) and sees Alana, a 28-year-old model who describes herself as “lost” at the time, moving out of Miami in a few weeks. Even though Spirit required a swipe, Aubrey was aging out of her preferences in a month (he’s 44), which proves that the match was rapturously ordained. The synchronicities abound.
It gets more unhinged. Vylana bonds with and befriends Alana, but trouble finds them. While in Egypt, Aubrey receives another divine download, this time from Isis,
“And I was in the sanctum sanctorum of this temple. And I received a message as clear as any message I’ve ever received, and it felt to me like it was coming from the voice of Isis, and it says, ‘You need to have children with both of them.’
“And my heart sank into my belly, and I was like ‘Fuck!’ Because I knew that that was not the covenant I made with Vy that brought her in.”
…I know. What in the names of Joseph Smith, Warren Jeffs, Keith Raniere, and Samuel Bateman is this?
Why, rather than telling wealthy and powerful spiritual men to give all their money to starving children, does God always insist on telling them to impregnate a harem? I’m surprised that the God of a Poet King would resort to such a tired cliche.
When Aubrey tells Vylana this story, she sees no humour in it. As she recounts the story, she says, “It was bringing up that piece of me that feels like I always get hit out of left field as soon as I feel safe…” Her voice cracks.
This is the betrayal trauma her body remembers. Even though everything is out in the open, her boundaries are being bulldozed; She still isn’t safe, and her body knows it.
Betrayal trauma is defined as harm that occurs at the hands of someone we trust or are dependent on (Birrel & Freyd, 2006). Betrayal can occur at the hands of romantic partners, parents, caregivers, friends, colleagues, bosses, teachers, and even organizations and institutions. It puts the nervous system in the high-stress state of fight, flight, freeze or fawn, disrupting one’s mental, emotional, physical, social and spiritual health.
When traumatically bonded, cognitive dissonance and double-vision can be incredibly common. Vylana sobs as she talks about transcending, killing off, and eventually grieving the part of her that desires exclusivity. She talks about how free she’s felt as she leans into the pain and discomfort of being pressured into an open relationship. She talks about giving up her needs and desires for monogamy as part of a “unique sacrifice to the masculine.” Perhaps she can convince herself that she’s choosing this.
Betrayal blindness is a typical response when we depend on a relationship and can’t leave or fight back (Freyd & Birrell, 2013).
Vylana urges us not to project onto her. She tells the audience she’s making choices and is happy: she’s never felt so loved. Only she truly knows, but betrayal blindness can manifest as spiritual bypassing, in which individuals interpret their emotional discomfort as wounds they are responsible for healing and overcoming, rather than signs of harm.
Manipulators exploit spiritual beliefs to convince victims that freedom and enlightenment lie on the other side of their mental, emotional, relational (and sometimes even physical) pain. Spiritual bypassing cuts one off from the instincts that protect boundaries. Vylana speaks about her mission and destiny—she must override her gut feelings and accept this arrangement to serve their unborn children.
We might interpret Aubrey’s messages from God as spiritual bypassing to avoid accountability, i.e., “Yes, I made a vow, but this is not what I want; it’s what God wants.” He might even believe it.
Betrayal blindness can cause self-fragmentation and silencing as a way to survive, like a mirror shattered into a million pieces. Recovery often involves gathering these parts and finding a way to put them back together, not cutting them off.
Victims of betrayal blindness describe a foggy sense of self, confusion around trust, and difficulty forming attachments. Rumination is extremely common as their minds turn over what happened, trying to gain more information about the situation that might prevent further betrayal. Many ruminations turn self-hating, i.e., “If I’m at fault, I am empowered.”
DARVO (Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender), a concept developed by Jennifer Freyd, is a tool of coercive control that can confuse, fragment, and silence a victim (Freyd & Birrell, 2013). It encompasses gaslighting, or denying any wrongdoing and making the victim feel that they are crazy. Even worse, it leaves them feeling at fault: rather than the perpetrator’s actions, their expectations, desires, and often reasonable reactions to abuse are to blame.
Vylana’s journey is described as one of sacrifice, spiritual growth, and healing, even as her body language says the opposite. She says she told the part of herself that grieved this arrangement, “I know this is not what you want, but it’s what you need.” This would be an excellent subtitle for a DARVO 101 manual.
Aubrey and Gafni’s theories frame Vylana’s desires as unreasonable and misguided. It is not Aubrey who needs to examine his unwillingness to commit. Vylana’s needs are the result of unhealed wounds, and she must amputate the infected parts. Her very normal reactions of anger and destabilization when her boundaries are violated are labelled “insane.” At one point, Vylana cries and thanks the rest of them for being so patient with her.
There are many problematic power imbalances in the group. Aubrey is a wealthy man with a lot of influence. There are gender and age gaps. The trio are speaking on Aubrey’s platform. To his credit, Aubrey points out that he doesn’t want to withhold resources from either of the women. If Vylana were to leave, he would ensure she was provided for. However, it’s impossible to know the details of this arrangement. What share does she have in the company she’s helped build for the last five years? Is there a non-disclosure or non-disparaging agreement preventing her from sharing her story? Vylana has built a public persona around the Marcus brand.
Further, bonding, particularly trauma-bonding, can obstruct our power to choose, keeping us in a double-bind.
Humans are wired to attach to people we love. Love is essential for survival, but attachment and emotional dependence can sometimes create power imbalances and leave one susceptible to abuse (Freyd & Birrell, 2013). Someone who has experienced relationship betrayal may learn that manipulation and love are wrapped in one another, and boundaries must be sacrificed to preserve relationships (DePrince, 2005).
Patterns of wounding can prevent individuals from seeing where they may be empowered to leave or stand up for themselves. In this way, Vylana’s history of betrayal leaves her vulnerable. Her comfort is challenged like a frog slowly boiling.
First, she agreed to be “monogamish.” Then, she accepted adding a third person to the dynamic. Next, Alana became Aubrey’s girlfriend. Vylana “can see the beauty” in Aubrey having children with Alana, even if the thought brings her to tears. Her boundaries are slowly eroded step by step. Whatever line she holds, she must eventually give up or lose the relationship.
What would it feel like to know that you are chosen, beyond a doubt?
Many people have pointed out the double standards present in the dynamic. While Vylana and Alana are allowed to have lovers, Aubrey emphasizes that Vylana’s relationship with Josh was not as deep as the one he shares with Alana. It is unclear if either of them can have children with other men.
Patriarchal gender essentialism is a covert theme in this brand of spiritual control. Gafni references Romanian men who work 17-hour days, an example of how men “pour” into women in different ways, so women can pour love back in their way (by letting them have a sidepiece). It’s fair, but not equal (or was it equal, but not fair? I can’t remember).
Alana references her teacher, Kelsey Kazarian, who runs workshops in which she teaches masculine devotion and promotes ideas like “Women love to hear the word no.” These theories frame women as submissive and nurturing and men as leaders, protectors, and providers.
Drawn out to its logical ends, gender essentialism can create a dynamic in which it is considered “unfeminine” (in a heterosexual dynamic) to uphold boundaries. It gaslights women into thinking that submission is empowering, while men occupy actual positions of power and influence in their relationships and society.
Alaska Wolfe (2025) released a podcast episode that eloquently unpacks the subtle misogyny and unequal relationship dynamics.
Altered states of consciousness through the use of psychedelics can make individuals susceptible and decrease their agency. Aubrey and Vylana share a disturbing story in which they offer Alana a “God Bomb Ceremony” on their second meeting. The ceremony involves powerful psychedelics, body work (i.e. physical touch), and sound healing. They joke that Alana has good instincts to trust them so early. But, plant medicines lower defences, increase openness and trust, blur boundaries, and increase bonding through feelings of intimacy and spiritual connection. Aubrey and Vylana love-bomb her, telling her they’ve never worked with energy so pure, and Alana says she’s never felt so seen. Later, Aubrey launches into an emotional monologue idealizing Alana’s purity. After watching Vylana break down several times, it’s the only instance we see him in tears. The whole thing smacks of cult grooming.
No doubt, the voices that speak to Aubrey have something to do with his heavy use of psychedelics. But the fact that his comments don’t immediately elicit an eye-roll from his posse suggests that they frequently enter the altered states that make these revelations fairly standard-issue.
The use of Marc Gafni as their therapist is problematic. Vylana states they wouldn’t have gotten this far without his theories that frame and anchor her experience. Gafni is an excommunicated rabbi accused of multiple counts of sexual misconduct, including sex with underage women (ages 13, 14, and 16).
He denies these allegations, blaming the victims for creating a witch hunt against him. Watch his interview with Dr. Phil for a textbook example of DARVO (24×7 Network, 2024). At the end of the interview, he lectures the viewer on the dangers of online smear campaigns. It’s really something to behold.
Online, you can find the testimonies of many of his (alleged) victims, including Sara Kabokov (2016), who was 13, and Donna Zerner (2016, 2019), who worked for him and with whom he had a sexual relationship with fuzzy boundaries and questionable consent. Zerner is an engaging storyteller, and her videos are worth watching.
Aubrey publicly stated that he believes Gafni. Donna Zerner said she kept her knowledge about Gafni a secret because she believed in his mission. I can’t help but wonder if Aubrey fears that the allegations against Gafni might prevent his teachings, which Aubrey openly praises, from reaching a wider audience, so he chooses to look away. Paul Levy (2016) writes about how organizations can become blind to sexual misconduct, especially when such denial helps them avoid confronting their shadows.
Aubrey’s decision to bring Gafni in as a teacher seems, in part, aimed at persuading Vylana and Alana to embrace this dynamic. Unsurprisingly, this situation appears infused with his (alleged) pathologies.
At one point, Alana talks about how she can feel the resonance of truth in her body. It has never failed her, leading her to places beyond her wildest dreams (i.e., in front of a 100,000-person podcast audience and inside a private RV at Burning Man). At first, her soft-spoken conviction persuades me. I wish I had her level of certainty. Then, I remember she is sitting next to Gafni.
Watching him through the screen, I have a gut feeling: a mixture of disgust and fear. I believe Gen Z call this “The Ick.” However, Aubrey, Vylana, and Alana lean in. They laugh at his unfunny jokes, defusing nervous tension. Vylana fawns the most. She turns to him to finish her thoughts and appears to monitor his reactions when she speaks.
So, does Alana not feel her stomach knot when Gafni floods the space with his rhythmic cadence of pressured speech that says nothing?
I wonder if anyone in the polycule has bothered to contact his accusers. How might the “truth resonate” (or not) in their bodies as they listen to Donna Zerner speak?
Aubrey and Vylana Marcus have accused the audience of projecting. “Don’t project on me that I’m not choosing this,” pleads Vylana. Of course, it’s impossible to tell what goes on between them when they are no longer performing. I don’t know any of them, so my impressions are filtered through my experiences. But, as many commenters have pointed out, we’re also forming and expressing opinions, judgments, concerns, moral outrage, and skepticism. People are naming what they see, and it’s not a projection to point out something looks unethical.
It’s also worth pointing out the irony of accusing the audience of projection when your marketing capitalizes on your parasocial relationship with them. Projection is the foundation of the brand.
Many followers feel misled and betrayed. They were invested in what they thought was an exemplary monogamous partnership, and many signed up for their courses and heeded their advice.
A commenter who attended a relationship workshop with them wrote, “They went on and on about their monogamous love… It was like he was making us all long for a love like that. I remember leaving feeling confused. I wouldn’t be surprised if a bunch of people went home and left their relationships, thinking ‘If I can’t have a love like that, I don’t want any love.'”
Thousands of comments were deleted from the YouTube video and Aubrey and Vylana’s social media posts. The majority were critical, but kind. People wrote about the gut feelings they were learning to trust again—in fact, the episode is a great way to practice feeling that sense we have often been taught to ignore. Women shared their disappointment that a relationship that brought them hope appeared to be another example of a woman being asked to abandon her needs and desires for a man. Something is cracking open as grounded psychological concepts like boundaries, gut instincts, and healthy relational conflict meet the disembodied wishful thinking of the spiritual community.
So, where do we go next? If Aubrey, Vylana, and Alana sat in my office, what would I tell them? What would I tell the thousands of disappointed followers and commenters?
First, remove the relationship from the public eye, but open the comments. Vylana already seems to be backing away, which appears healthy. Oversharing can be damaging when there is real pain involved. There’s a fine line to walk with performative vulnerability: How much do you share to appear sincere and open without baring everything?
However, Aubrey should consider republishing the comments and letting the audience talk, rather than DARVO’ing them and blaming them for Vylana and Alana’s distress. Many commenters are survivors of cults and abusive relationships. One commenter noted that the still-flowing conversations served as “sacred fire for abused women to take back their power.” Avoid silencing and fragmenting. Let the group process, offer support, and heal.
Thoroughly investigate the accusations against Marc Gafni. Marc Gafni’s presence in this dynamic raises serious ethical questions. Listen to his alleged victims. Read Paul Levy’s (2016) paper on wetiko to understand how followers can engage in collective betrayal blindness to preserve power structures, protect the “mission,” and avoid confronting their shadows.
Regardless of the allegations, Gafni does not appear to be a safe and appropriate person to provide relationship guidance. How does Gafni manage his dual roles as friend and mentor to Aubrey and therapist to the polycule? How does he maintain professional and ethical boundaries? How does he distance himself from his theories of male sexuality and gender roles and hold space for alternate worldviews?
Hire a licensed, regulated therapist. Look for a therapist in good standing with their regulatory body, who receives ongoing supervision, is transparent about their theoretical orientation, and is accountable to an ethical code of conduct and standard of practice (American Psychological Association, 2017).
Ask about their training. What psychological theories and frameworks inform their work? Do they have experience with non-monogamous dynamics and know how to support honest communication, boundaries, and consent? Are they trauma-informed and attuned to nervous system states such as hyperarousal, dissociation, and shutdown? How do their spiritual, political, or gender beliefs shape their work?
A good therapist honours their fiduciary relationship to the client, supports autonomy, recognizes double-binds, and monitors their biases.
On that note, be cautious of courses marketed as group therapy. Fit for Service course advertisements use peak emotional imagery: intense eye contact and streaming tears. I can’t help but compare these marketing videos to the evidence-based, quiet, regulated spaces of the retreats that social workers and couples therapists, like Melissa Johari, offer. Rooted in Gottman and EFT (Emotionally Focused Therapy) frameworks, against a simple backdrop of a suburban conference centre, the only “mind expansion” is the clarity and presence of mind participants might feel from leaving their phones in their rooms. The only “transformation” is the psychoeducation they receive and the skills they continue to work on. It’s the real, grounded work of learning to care for ourselves and others as we navigate daily life.
Pause the use of psychedelics. Psychedelic medicine can have profound healing effects. Currently, CAMH is running a trial on the use of psilocybin in treatment-resistant depression. But psychedelics render the individual highly vulnerable, putting them at risk of retraumatization, spiritual bypassing, and serious boundary violations. Integrating these experiences requires time, space, and a safe container to allow blasted open neural connections to settle.
Safe, ethical use means an accountable structure that ensures power dynamics between participants and facilitators are explicit, consensual, and trauma-informed. And, it should go without saying that sexual relationships with participants are a serious violation of this vulnerability and trust.
Learn about coercive control and cult psychology. Aubrey, Vylana, and Alana should become familiar with concepts like betrayal blindness, trauma bonding, DARVO and the other D’s (Double-speak, Double vision, Double standards, and Double-binds). They should be empowered to walk away. This might involve working out legal contracts that protect each individual’s agency and contribution to the brand.
I checked on Whitney Miller, Aubrey’s ex, in all the drama. She’s posted a few things without naming names. Overall, it seems she’s been vindicated.
She reminds followers dealing with heartbreak that one day, you will realize it was never about you not being enough. She’s had a lot of therapy.
A while back, she posted a video on Instagram about a self-defence class for women she helped facilitate. There is no forced vulnerability or crying on cue. The atmosphere is light. Women laugh, playfully fumble through the moves, and support each other with warmth and humour. They eat snacks. Rather than performative and pretentious, it feels wholesome.
But who knows?
It is social media, after all.
This Might Help with Dr. Talia ND is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.Subscribed
References:
24×7 Network. (2024, June 14). Spiritual Leader in the Spotlight: Ex-Rabbi Marc Gafni [Video]. YouTube.
DePrince, A. P. (2005). Social cognition and revictimization risk. Journal of Trauma & Dissociation, 6(1), 125–141. https://doi.org/10.1300/j229v06n01_08
Freyd, J., & Birrell, P. (2013). Blind to betrayal. John Wiley & Sons.
IndoctriNation. (2023, March 22). Ending coercive control with Kate Amber [Video]. YouTube.
Wolfe, A. (2025). God told me to have children with two women: Aubrey marcus, feminine sacrifice and how the f*ck to choose yourself. [Podcast]. Heartbreak Alchemy.
Dr. Nastasia Irons, ND, is a fellow naturopathic doctor and CCNM class of 2014 graduate. She also completed a 2-year residency program, furthering her training in acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine, cosmetic acupuncture, and herbal medicine. She has a special interest in hormones, skin, and digestion, but has a passion for fitness and movement and is a prominent fitness advocate within our naturopathic community. She is a spin instructor and inspires everyone (particularly women) to build mental, emotional, and physical resilience by lifting weights and building muscle.
Dr. Nastasia Irons discusses her transformative journey into fitness and its integration with her work as a naturopathic doctor. She shares how fitness helped her during a challenging breakup and highlights the importance of mental health and strength training, particularly for women. Dr. Irons offers practical advice for beginners, emphasizing consistency, accountability, and addressing misconceptions about strength training. She underscores its long-term health benefits, especially for women, and shares her personal experiences with resilience through fitness. The conversation concludes with an invitation for listeners to engage and find joy in their movement.
Speaker1: [0:02] Hey welcome staz dr nastasia irons yes either one’s fine we look so similar i know i think an ex of yours like thought i was you there was like a drama do you remember there was something about this i don’t know i
Speaker0: [0:24] Don’t remember Dory from Finding Nemo so yeah but I think yeah there is that
Speaker0: [0:30] in this world people have told me that before too.
Speaker1: [0:32] Yeah it’s good it’s like
Speaker0: [0:34] On the same in the same neighborhood.
Speaker1: [0:36] Yeah that’s true yeah you work like near High Park right which is where I um I live kind of the opposite end of the park but in the same area yeah wow yeah so we’re here I wanted to talk to you guys I was just saying for a while um because you’ve been posting a lot of really cool stuff on your Instagram very inspiring about, I don’t know what you would call it, like a fitness journey.
Speaker0: [0:59] Yeah.
Speaker1: [1:00] Yeah.
Speaker0: [1:01] Just like I got into the fitness world a little bit after I became a naturopathic doctor. And the combination of the two for me has been really nice. Like from a personal journey, it was something that helped me get through some darker emotional times. Like when I was going through a really bad breakup, I actually found a spin class, tried it for the first time. And it just allowed me to feel like me again, almost. And then I did that for years. And I still teach spin. But then I got into strength training a year ago more seriously. And that’s when I realized that this is a huge part of women’s health that we’re not taught a lot about.
Speaker0: [1:42] And it’s probably one of the best things you can do for your body long term. And so I want of focus a lot of my practice now, which is a lot of my patients are actually women, not all of them, but just teaching people how to incorporate nutrition and strength training into their everyday life.
Speaker1: [1:59] Yeah, this is so cool. It’s such a big thing now. I don’t know what you would say, maybe in the last, it seems like five years, maybe 10, where now women are interested in and building muscle and strength training. And how did you find your way into it? Like, so it was for your mental health and then.
Speaker0: [2:19] Yeah, fitness was, I used to be a dancer. So before I became a naturopath, I was a competitive dancer. And then when I moved to Toronto, I didn’t have a community anymore to, that felt like the same as my dance team. So I started going to the gym, I joined a few gyms here and there, but I still also felt like I was just walking around by myself. And I was really lost in terms of what to do. So I stopped working out. And then when we became students at CCNM, I think that just took over my life. And I lost like, that other side of me that I think was part of my life since I was a kid. And it wasn’t until I became an ND that I decided to explore fitness again, I think, because we finally had time. But spin was one of those moments that it was life-changing for me from my first class till even now. I just taught a class this morning. I had this moment in the room where I felt like myself or part of my personality came back. And it’s like when you go through a lot in life, you sometimes lose yourself a little bit in that. And when you’re in a job where you give energy out to people all day, you, again, don’t have a lot of time to hear your inner voice or really connect with who you are. For some reason in the spin room, I did. I had that moment where I was like, oh, this is missing in my life and I feel better. So I want to be able to do that for other people.
Speaker0: [3:41] And so I did that for years. But then last year I was noticing, OK, like I’m in my late 30s now. So why is that not working for me? Like my fitness seems like it’s getting thrown off, even though I’m doing so much. And I think I hear this story all the time from my patients where they’re like, I’ve been doing the same thing my whole life, but all of a sudden now it’s not working. And so I started to really explore, okay, like what’s going on with our hormones? What’s going on with our body composition as we age? And why is cardio not enough
Speaker0: [4:12] for people and like maintaining body composition? And that’s when I looked into strength training and started incorporating it for myself as like an experiment to see, okay, if I do this, what happens? And then it started to work. I was feeling better, stronger, noticing that my muscles were growing. And then I realized, oh, I’m going to teach women how to do this. And so that for a year now, I’ve been strength training a few times a week and learning how to teach others. And I might become a personal trainer too. I’m just trying to find time. That’s cool.
Speaker1: [4:44] That’s good. Yeah. Because personal trainers are great people to refer to because like how did you maybe you can explain kind of your journey and getting into it because I feel like it’s daunting for people to know where to start how to begin like you know what exercises do I do how do I put a plan together like you know specifically
Speaker0: [5:02] Yeah I think that um, Obviously, nowadays, we have a lot of resources online. So if you have internal motivation to get yourself to the gym or if you have a gym in your condo or weights at home, you can start on your own. But I find that the biggest hurdle for people is just the day one. Like, when do you start? What does that look like? And if you walk into a gym and you feel kind of like you don’t know what you’re doing, it doesn’t feel very fulfilling. And strength training is different than going in and doing a cardio class because it might not feel like as sweaty or as intense, but the reality is, is what’s happening in your body is really beneficial. So it’s about the long game and learning how to stay committed and keep yourself consistently going for about six months. Then you start to really feel different. But the best way to get started is to either get yourself set up with a personal trainer. So if you have money to pay someone just to watch you work out and help you a couple sessions at a local gym would be really helpful. If that’s not in your budget, then I would say the next best thing to do would be if you have a naturopath or someone you work with on your health team who could design a plan for you, they could design a plan that has like, okay, let’s start with two times a week, upper body and lower body, four workouts each time. And here’s a link to a YouTube video on how you could do it. So I do that for people.
Speaker0: [6:30] Then you can actually in the visit, go over like the workouts with them, make sure they understand. If that’s still not in your budget, that’s okay too. You can honestly just go online and like type in what you’re looking for. There’s a lot of apps that exist now that you can use to design your own plan or you can pay for like a yearly membership, which is usually pretty affordable to something like the sweat app or Marcus Philly has a bodybuilding app and they go through whether you’re a beginner intermediate or advanced they’ll design a plan for you and then videos and everything to take you through it so how to do it is actually getting easier and easier these days the the getting yourself there and starting I would say has to come from within so there has to be some desire to do it and then it’s all about whether you can get yourself there or if you maybe set a plan with a friend or someone you do it with and go with them. That’s another way I help, you know, get people to motivate themselves or stay motivated. Um.
Speaker0: [7:29] Oftentimes I find like booking yourself in with a trainer or a class or getting started by like putting it in your calendar and making yourself like Tuesday at 7 a.m. This is what I’m doing. And that it’s like booking a class like the morning of if you canceled, you would have to pay $30. So maybe incentivize yourself somehow to like take $30 out of your bank account and put it somewhere else if you don’t do the workout. I mean, I don’t know. You have to find little ways. But I think once you get started, then it’s much easier to keep going. It’s just about that, like, first couple weeks.
Speaker1: [8:03] Yeah, you find, like, you’re, yeah, the scheduling it in, like, I recently started doing that because I was doing a whole course on insulin resistance, and a huge part of that is, like, strength training. And I was like, I don’t, I’m, like, preaching how to support your insulin levels. I’m like, I don’t think I do strength training twice a week. I randomly sprinkle it in. So I started actually scheduling it like, okay, Tuesdays, Thursdays, lift a kettlebell, like, you know,
Speaker0: [8:29] Even if you have to.
Speaker1: [8:30] Yeah.
Speaker0: [8:31] I have a lot of patients who just have their own dumbbells at home and just have to do a couple different workouts. That’s getting started. And people are always like, oh, well, if I don’t go to the gym and put an hour in, then I’m not going to go. But honestly, 15 minutes is great. Like wherever you can start. And there’s a lot of free videos on YouTube that you can use to just watch and learn. Um and we can link them after if people want some idea yeah yeah yeah and i think um, we can we’ll talk about this later but like with strength training there’s a lot of options even if you only have um like a couple dumbbells you can do more than uh just use heavy weights you can use like slower movements to help gain muscle for example um and like do a couple tricks so that you’re slowly building muscle and not staying the same, even from what you have access to at home.
Speaker1: [9:24] Yeah, that’s a good point. There’s somebody I follow I’m thinking of who taught me a lot just from kind of following her. She’s just an Instagram influencer built by Becky.
Speaker0: [9:34] Oh, cool.
Speaker1: [9:35] Yeah. Have you heard of her? Yeah. So she, one of the things I learned from her is just like how long it takes to, for the body recomposition. Like she’s like, I’ve been doing this consistently for four years. So we think we’ve been kind of coached or taught to think that it’s like, 10 weeks or two weeks or lose 10 pounds in half a day.
Speaker0: [9:59] Honestly, I think that’s my biggest problem with like some fitness influencers online right now. They’re selling products like here’s my eight week total body shred program. Okay. If you look at my Instagram, you can see from a year ago, I started this journey and I said on end, I was like, okay, it was like July 8th. So I’m coming up on almost a year. And I told everybody, I’m going to do this like 10K a day walk, 10K steps a day walk. I’m going to do strength training. And in eight weeks, I’m going to check back in and show you what happened. And obviously we’re all different and like everybody’s story is different. And I did start with a bit of an active background already, but you can see like in those eight weeks, your body composition can change a tiny little bit. Within 12 weeks, you can see some muscles start to show. Like there obviously is change. People always want to know like how long will it take. I mean, within 12 weeks, body composition will change, but noticeable long-term changes to things like your measurements, stepping on the scale, seeing a change there, which we can talk about later, but like that’s kind of a useless one. But measurements and muscle growth, really we’re looking at six months and then check back in in a year. You will be shocked at how your body looks. It will be different. I suggest that people take a picture of like one picture of in their underwear, keep it for themselves, but do it every four weeks.
Speaker0: [11:21] If that triggers you maybe only every like once every four months like every quarter but, it should help you see that maybe what you feel on the inside is like you’re not changing at all or the scale is going up or like all these things that people are afraid of like or they’re going to get bulky what you’ll actually see is the the what you see it first of all in your own picture is probably better than what you think it’s going to be even from that first one and then as you go along you’ll see the change to your body more than what like if I just asked you if you feel different that’s a harder thing but when you look in the pictures you’ll start to see the definition and the muscle growth and it’s pretty amazing yeah.
Speaker1: [11:59] That’s cool and to like think of it as like a long game like a long game
Speaker0: [12:02] Yeah like every year every year if you stay consistent and it seems really it seems like so much when you’re just starting I get that it’s like looking up at a mountain thinking oh my god I have to hike that whole thing but one day you get to the top and you’re like, okay, I did that. Right. And then if you look back, it doesn’t feel that long. So it’s just getting started.
Speaker1: [12:22] Yeah. It’s like four years goes by anyway. So you might as well look shredded at the end of it.
Speaker0: [12:27] And then honestly, like the benefits are incredible. So it’s worth it. Even if, um, if you’re doing it for a purely just look changing the way you look, that’s one thing, but the benefits to gaining more muscle on your body go way beyond how you look.
Speaker1: [12:42] And we’ll talk about that too but I also want to say just to acknowledge what you said before about you can do kind of slower more intentional movements not necessarily using like huge weights and that’s another thing i learned from the build by becky like her whole style was just to do like pulsing like very intentional very slow very mindful um movement using like dumbbells basically at home and that was the whole plan so yeah that’s a good point that it doesn’t have to be like you know huge barbells where you’re squatting like your body weight or more you know
Speaker0: [13:18] Like definitely if the weights are heavy you’re going to see more change especially as you get into like perimenopause um when your estrogen levels start to change a little bit we have less of that tissue response to build muscle that anabolic response so you are going to get more results the heavier you can lift but that’s not necessarily like humongous humongous um barbells it’s just that your um the two ways to stimulate muscle that are really going to help you are one time under tension. So what we talked about, like going a lot slower and with the purposeful movement, focusing on your form. So for example, if it’s like a bench press or something and you’re pushing the dumbbells out, you’re going to push out for one and then you’re going to pull in for three long seconds. And so that time that your muscles are under all that tension is longer than if it was just like one, one, one, one, and that’s going to build muscle. So you can, a lot of times when you do it slower, the weight feels way heavier. So it’s okay to use lighter weights. And then you also want to use progressive overload technique. So over time, those weights are going to feel a little easier and you should be stimulating the muscle a little more by going up a couple pounds, go up a couple pounds. It doesn’t have to be huge jumps, but if you’re training properly and eating enough protein, your body should be feeling like it can handle a little more. And that progressive overload is going to get you bigger muscles too.
Speaker1: [14:44] That’s good. That’s really good tips. Yeah. So yeah, the longer, it’s not about like maybe as many reps as like, yeah. And then, um, and then yeah, like slowly adding more weight, which if you’re just starting, you could maybe start with body weight or resistance bands and work your way up. Yeah.
Speaker0: [15:02] And the other thing too, is that, um, what feels like a nine out of 10 when you’re just starting is going to be different than one year in. And one thing I think, especially women, um, what holds us back a lot is our feeling of confidence when we go to the gym or when we’re going to lift a weight. It’s like, oh, I don’t think I can do that. I’m going to push, use 10. I see women all the time. They’ll choose 10 for themselves, but by the time they’ve worked with me once, they’ll take 30s when they’re doing a chest press because you actually can lift a lot more than you think. It’s your head that keeps you back. So your true nine out of 10 feeling means like we talked about this in the gym a lot. It’s like nine RP. So what does that mean? It means that you probably could do one or two more probably only one if I asked you to but you couldn’t do three so if if you can still do more reps and you’re not getting to that eight or nine out of ten and like you could do another six it’s not heavy enough for you uh-huh.
Speaker1: [15:56] Yeah so you’re like you should be able to kind of like really
Speaker0: [15:59] Yeah I guess with.
Speaker1: [16:00] Good form get one more in yeah
Speaker0: [16:02] Yeah yeah so keep your form good right because if you have to totally change your form to try to get that rep in probably it’s too heavy but but if you can keep good form and and do three more then maybe you can go up in your weights a bit so that that feeling of a little bit of a struggle when you’re getting that last couple of set reps should be there for if we’re looking at true strength training that’s.
Speaker1: [16:24] I think like the beauty of having a trainer is having somebody kind of like helping you get out of your head and like no i know you can do it like let’s give me one more And then that extra rep is probably making a huge difference in progress.
Speaker0: [16:39] And that’s what you learn. So when I started the journey last year in June, July, I was doing it on my own using an app and just going to the gym and trying it. And that was fun. It felt really like empowering. And I was getting stronger. But then I started working with a trainer a little at this gym called Strong. His name is Callum. He’s amazing. And he was like, pick a heavier weight, Jazz. And every time he made me go heavier and heavier. And I thought like, is this what it’s supposed to feel like? It’s trembling. I thought it was going to throw up a little, but it’s just calmly like, you know, pushing me beyond where I would normally keep myself. And then I got stronger way faster. I learned to have confidence in my own ability at the gym and I learned what a true nine out of 10 is. So now I can push myself on my own to that limit. You still will always work out a little harder with a trainer, but that experience having someone just look at you and help you do a little more and give you the right confidence and form recommendations at first is.
Speaker1: [17:39] Really valuable that’s a good yeah that’s i love that like oh is this what it’s supposed to feel like and then you’re basically gonna puke but i don’t okay and then yeah then then also like this part about like one thing i don’t do at the gym enough i think is like resting between sets and yeah okay
Speaker0: [18:00] The thing this is a really cool fact okay so because typically uh women do a lot more cardio than men at first. Yeah. When you go to the gym and you start doing strength training, your cardiovascular ability is usually pretty high. So when you’re lifting weights and they’re not maybe as heavy yet, you might feel like you don’t really need to take breaks. Like, you know, when you see people at the gym and they’re like, and like, they’re kind of making weird noises and they’re taking time and you know, a minute goes by and then they go back. I always used to think to myself, that’s taking so much longer. Why don’t you just push the reps So like, let’s go get in, get out.
Speaker1: [18:37] Phone, get out, get back on it.
Speaker0: [18:40] When I talked to my trainer about this and he was like, you know, I think women at first don’t feel like they need the break because their cardio is better than their strength. Once your strength starts to get there and you’re doing that split squat and you’re like, you have, you do eight and then you like, I need the break in between. I almost feel like if not, I’m not going to feel well. Like you should be feeling a little bit like, like your heart rate’s picking up enough that you actually need to take a minute to breathe. The other purpose is just allowing your muscles to refill with blood and get like rested enough so that you can push again and get a true 9 out of 10 experience again. So you’re not just like failing at five because then your body just needs a little bit of time in between each one to recover, to get the most out of the workout.
Speaker1: [19:24] Yeah. And I’m also just thinking too, the nervous system, like when you’re at that point where you’re pushing so far beyond kind of like what feels like a limit or I mean you’re really at your limit I guess like you’re nine out of ten it takes some time to kind of like recalibrate that all like with your nerves even you know
Speaker0: [19:41] And like normally feel like a tiny bit dizzy you know pushing it really hard and that’s the goal uh and then you take a minute everything kind of settles and you try again and then a couple of those and you know on to the next workout or call it a day like whatever that workout time is for you make make the most out of it but definitely do it heavy enough that you need to take a little bit of like I would say like a 60 second to 90 second break between each one yeah.
Speaker1: [20:10] So all this sounds unpleasant
Speaker0: [20:13] Yeah I know it’s selling it am I you’re.
Speaker1: [20:20] Just like yeah you should be like vomiting and like you’re dizzy and you want to died but and i guess you know there’s like we can get into like the mental health benefits of even that repeatedly like entering into that experience where you’re like pushing yourself into an uncomfortable place then you’re overcoming that like repeatedly like you’re doing that multiple times in a set in a workout and then you’re doing that a few times a week and like you know the effects on your mind and body of just being able to push yourself feel uncomfortable and survive it and get stronger from it
Speaker0: [20:57] Yeah oh it’s such an amazing thing to learn I feel like that probably was the reason for why I loved spin so much and it got through a lot of um let’s say like challenging times in my life one being like the grief I experienced right before finding the spin class and then feeling like I could yeah push myself through the times that were challenging I also experienced five years into my teaching spin journey and being an ND I was riding my bike home one night.
Speaker0: [21:28] And I got hit by an Uber while I was riding my bike. And so I had a fully broken femur inside the hip joint. So like broke my hip. I had to spend time in the hospital. They obviously had to like put the titanium rods in my hip to hold it all back together. I was in a wheelchair for a while and had to learn kind of the basic things like walking again and balancing. Thing my legs turned into like spaghetti noodles like oh I lost all my muscle and this was the day after I had auditioned for a really big spin job in Los Angeles so my life would have taken a very big turn and then it didn’t and it seems kind of sad but in that moment I mean I actually felt really loved because I could all my friends came to the hospital and like I really saw you know, this you have this feeling of feeling really loved and supported once you’re going through something but then as time goes on you’re you still feel alone again in that journey it can get dark again because um you’re still going through it but maybe like the the shock of what happened to you fades for everybody else around you yeah.
Speaker1: [22:36] So it’s in
Speaker0: [22:36] Yeah those are the moments where your own self-resilience needs to come back up so a lot of times I explain this to people like it’s like a feeling of darkness inside of you or maybe there’s like a little light like a little tiny like flame from a match whereas before maybe it was a big bright light so you feel lost you have to try to find that and then it will grow inside you again so like that light can become bigger it’s just about you know going through what you have to go through and then also finding resilience so knowing that the light is there is a big thing and I talk about this in a workout too so like when you’re having a moment where you want to give up or you find it very challenging it’s the same as when you’re going through grief and you just kind of want to lay in bed all day. We’ve been there. It’s very hard. There’s times where you have to be okay with that and let it happen. And then there’s moments where you’re like, okay, I’m going to get out of bed now. I’m going to take some steps. I’m going to have a piece of bread. And then that’s like, you know, in the gym, you make choices to continue to push, even though you’re uncomfortable. That’s the same thing that you can take out into your real life. And that’s for me, like the mental health strength that we gain through feeling
Speaker0: [23:44] uncomfortable in a workout yeah.
Speaker1: [23:46] Thanks for sharing that that’s cool yeah it’s like that finding that flame it’s not completely out it’s just a lot dimmer than it might have been before the accident before the grief whatever you’re going through and then you’re trying to like okay what is it telling me to do is it you know I just rest today and don’t get out of bed or is that spark kind of asking me to push a little bit whatever that means you know yeah
Speaker0: [24:14] Sometimes hard to hear and then there’s times like I when I went through a really bad breakup during COVID this was after the accident so like six months later I actually had tried out for the spin studio again I got the job after everything and then everything shut down in the world and like it all got taken away from me again is what it felt like and then I went through a big like huge breakup there was a lot of infidelity and like emotional abuse I was probably in the darkest place I’ve ever been in my entire life and I was all alone um in Canada at the time like my family wasn’t there so I had no one to really help me through it and so I had to my family would facetime me to try to get me out of bed to like walk to the kitchen and eat but it was hard I spent two or three weeks just in my bed under the covers. Like it was a dark time.
Speaker0: [25:04] And I remember just feeling like you use what you can. So like the little FaceTime calls or like going for a walk maybe and trying to be listening to podcasts to make me feel better, trying to read a book, like little things, but like that flame was basically dead. And then one day I started going for a bit of a longer walk, which turned into like a little baby jog. And that turned into like a 2K run. And then it was a 5K run. And then all of a sudden I was running 13K in the winter and like feeling like myself again. And it was, it was that feeling of, okay, like wherever you’re at in your life, if you can come back to maybe, maybe fitness or any kind of movement, then maybe that’s the way to like bring that light back if you feel like you’ve lost it. So I feel like throughout the past decade in different part times that I’ve had, my journey with fitness has always helped me through. So that’s what I want to try to help people learn so that they can do that too.
Speaker1: [26:00] Yeah that’s beautiful yeah I mean and it’s I think really important because if we were like to pull up your Instagram right now it’s like it’s probably like you’re at the gym like you’re really fit you’re healthy you’re happy it’s like oh wow like Staz has something like one might think like Staz is something I don’t have like that’s a different person it’s a fit person so for someone who’s looking at that not just you Like anyone who’s kind of in the fitness world or the health world, somebody who’s like, I’m currently like, can’t get out of bed and I don’t even have the strength to like eat anymore. You can like kind of disidentify or feel alienated from that. But to know that it’s like you’ve been there and and maybe a background in fitness gave you that connection where you’re like, I know that this helps or I know that this is part of my identity. Um but it is possible to like build up from like like starting over completely physically but also mentally emotionally like coming back from heartbreak just being in like a total rock bottom and like building yourself up from there you know so and that’s i
Speaker0: [27:10] Think that that’s a really important thing that you brought up and i want people to know that i just want people to know that I know what it’s like to start over and to really bad place and to try again. And I, and multiple times it’s been very hard. And I would say that, yeah, looking at my Instagram now, if you don’t know that about me, or when you come to a spin class and you don’t know that you might just think, Ooh, that’s an unattainable level of spin. Like I can’t do that. Or I can never get there. Like it’s annoying that she’s doing pull-ups. Like I’m here. But I just, yeah, and it’s okay if it’s triggering because that like the fitness wellness world can be but i i want people to know that wherever you’re at in your journey whether it’s like you’re considering strength training or you don’t even know what what that would look like for you there is a space for you and there’s someone who can help you get there and i would be one of those people totally.
Speaker1: [28:05] Yeah because it’s like i you know i know what that’s like or you know yeah you’ve been there and the bleakness of like I’m sure that in those moments when your family is like okay go get something to eat you’re not thinking about you know, like a few years later when you’re going to be like, yeah, doing pull-ups or something like you’re, you’re just taking it one moment at a time, not even a day at a time, probably.
Speaker0: [28:31] Yeah. It was more like every, maybe if I could fill every hour, try to get through the hour, then maybe the next hour would feel better. I, there was a time back then that I would try to sleep in as late as I could so that the day wouldn’t be long. And then I would go to bed as early as I could so that I wouldn’t have to be awake for a lot. Like that was the worst time. So I’d probably try to wake up around lunchtime and go back to bed around six. And within that six hours, I’d go for a couple walks, cry to my family on the phone and like try really hard to eat something, but mostly couldn’t. Like it was bad. yeah um but like anything in life it doesn’t last even though it feels like it will you know like sometimes you can feel like whatever situation you’re in right now is going to be like that forever but it it doesn’t last and time does keep moving so if you can learn to just like yeah take one step in front of the other whether it’s going for a walk again or doing something that makes you feel good. That’s always a way to get through stuff. Fitness doesn’t have to mean going to the gym and lifting weights. It can just be moving your body in a way that feels good.
Speaker1: [29:45] Yeah. My life is like walking in the park. Just go outside.
Speaker0: [29:50] Yeah. I love that. I know. Just that. And then the gym doesn’t have to feel like this big scary place. You can learn so much. Just pair yourself with someone who knows or have either a mentor, an Instagram account, a health provider, anyone, a trainer, and then you can start and then that confidence will come.
Speaker1: [30:10] Yeah. It’s also making me think too of like, you know, coping mechanisms. Like we all have a variety of ways that we cope and that we can like, in a dark place, you start kind of reaching for it. So it’s like… In your psyche, in your identity, you have fitness. And so there are probably people out there, maybe listening who have not like, don’t identify at all with fitness. Like they’ve never really been athletic. They’ve never really gone to the gym. Maybe they did like cardio machines or something. So in that case, it can be something like you’re starting like a totally new thing, you know, not just kind of starting over, but it’s, this is like completely foreign thing that you’re even contemplating so um but I think the spirit is is similar where it’s like okay like then in that case maybe it’s helpful to reach out to a guide or someone that can introduce you to the world you know
Speaker0: [31:04] Or take a class where you know that um maybe like an instructor if this is something you want to try like through class pass or something or they can help motivate you and like you can become part of a family so for me it was like the community building of being at a spin studio or something like that really helped me make friends as an adult and then love fitness again and then from there you can start to get more confidence to go to the other gyms yeah so maybe it’s that that helped me yeah.
Speaker1: [31:33] That’s actually yeah that’s cool that’s a cool thing about spin that there’s like it’s it has it’s more than just a workout it has like kind of a spiritual like mental health components like a therapy session like a motivational thing you know
Speaker0: [31:46] Yeah and that’s there’s really cool research on that which you’re probably really already aware of but uh like different parts of your brain that light up when you’re doing physical activity versus just talking and where we store trauma is different parts of our brain but definitely in the posterior section versus like the frontal lobe and when we’re just talking the frontal lobe will light up and we’re definitely talking about you know our experiences and our traumas but then And when you’re actually activating the back of your brain through working out and then you’re having maybe a positive message come in or you’re processing some things, I think that’s where you can start to target some deeper information. Stored thoughts, maybe memories, maybe, you know, any kind of PTSD that they’re the same thing. Like there’s research, I think, on like different types of hallucinogens and the ways that that can activate your brain. Exercise has a similar effect. So in a spin room, you’ve got someone saying maybe some motivational things as you’re struggling on the bike, but it’s not just about that moment. Maybe it’s helping you through other things that you have processed in your brain.
Speaker1: [32:51] It’s like rewiring stuff. And actually, that’s a good point that I didn’t really put together because you have EMDR, right, where you incorporate like very basic movements, just bilateral movements, like whether it’s eye or you’re tapping bilaterally. But if you’re spinning or walking like you’re doing this bilateral kind of rhythmic thing that yeah you’re like liberating or like kind of moving stuff from other regions of the brain to like allow it to be processed and then your brain’s rewiring because it’s intense exercise and you have all this blood flow and so it’s like yeah you’re putting your body in this different physiological state you’re also like activating your nervous system in a way that like you’re you’re comfortable in kind of that fight or flight space you know yeah and
Speaker0: [33:37] That’s that’s really a very important thing for especially the type of like world we’re living in now to be able to notice when maybe your nervous system’s coming up and you’re feeling like a higher heightened feeling of stress and being able to notice that and still like stay grounded in that experience.
Speaker1: [33:54] Yeah yeah that’s one thing definitely like higher intensity exercise or like strength based exercise like can do it’s like yeah you’re comfortable like your nervous system expands to hold more of that stimulation and more of that stress and tension and then it almost like lowers your baseline activation you’re like okay like you know I brought it up to a nine out of ten and now it’s back to like a three whereas maybe I was living at a six all the time you know
Speaker0: [34:24] Yeah, totally. And that’s actually one really cool thing about saunas too. So you can incorporate heat after a workout. And for women, that’s been shown to be really beneficial for like improving blood flow, increasing our stress tolerance and increasing our temperature tolerance too. So helping with things like dehydrating the muscle more and getting more results at the gym, but also reducing your experience of hot flashes if that happens to you as we get older and your tolerability to hot environments. So like the summertime and not feeling as like heated, saunas help with that.
Speaker1: [34:58] Yeah, I’m a huge sauna lover, especially in Canada. It’s kind of like, you know, a necessity. I think everyone needs one.
Speaker0: [35:08] I agree. I’m like, just need to save up some money and get myself. Yeah. A lot of gyms have saunas. So that’s a benefit.
Speaker1: [35:15] Yeah. We need more communal saunas and cold places. Maybe. Yeah. Like we need more of these spaces, I think. And, and so let’s talk about some more of the benefits of like muscle building and, you know, for somebody who’s like, I don’t know, I don’t want to get, you know, I hear this less and less, I think, but I’ve still, I’ve heard it in the last year, let’s say like patients being like, I don’t want to get bigger. Yeah. I want to be smaller.
Speaker0: [35:41] And people are afraid that it’s going to cause them to like look bulky, that word. It’s definitely something we have to coach people through because it’s scary at first when you’re coming to see someone for body composition goals. Let’s say that patients are like, I want to lose weight. What should I do? And then I start talking about strength training. And then everybody’s like, oh my God, is that going to make me bigger? So one, no. Two, muscle is called lean tissue for a reason. So it’s definitely going to cause a change in your body size that will most likely look smaller, even though you’re building muscle, because muscle is an expensive tissue to keep on your body. So it costs a lot of energy for your body to hold it there, which means the more muscle you have, the more calories you actually need to eat to stay that way. So it’s kind of like if you want to talk about building your metabolism or increasing the fuel you’re burning, more muscle equals more calories you can consume just and just be a human living on this earth and have a higher metabolic rate. So more muscle equals more calories, more metabolic activity.
Speaker0: [36:45] In addition to that, it helps with your cholesterol levels, your blood sugar levels, blood flow to the brain, your mood. But from purely just building muscle and having that change your body, what’s going to happen is you’ll most likely, because you need to all of a sudden eat more calories to keep it there, your body starts to actually lose fat the more muscle you burn. So that’s a way to actually change your body by still eating a lot, still loving your life, build more muscle, and then your metabolism comes up. So it’s slower because you’re not going to just be cutting and cutting and cutting, which by the way, doesn’t work. You just lose all your muscle.
Speaker0: [37:21] By the same way that I explained like if your muscle is expensive and you have to eat a lot to keep it there if you’re not eating enough it’s the first thing you lose so if you’re losing weight by not eating enough you’re actually losing muscle first which you don’t want because of all the things I said about like your insulin and your cholesterol and all those things that need muscles you don’t want to lose all that so anyways building muscle will actually cause your body to one day like work more efficiently a little bit slow but that eventually tips over you build and then your body starts to shed the fat. So as fat like comes off the muscle tissue around your body, then you actually look a lot leaner. And I always tell people who are afraid of looking like huge after a workout, like if you do a strength training workout, you’ll see your muscles look bigger in the mirror after, right? Like your body has more veins, a little bit more like blood flow to everything. So if you look in the mirror right after that workout, that’s the extent of how big you’re going to get. Like your muscles fill, that’s what they look like. Then a day later, all that’s gone. And then you’re still like, you know, looking the exact same until your body starts to change. So there’s no bulk effect.
Speaker1: [38:26] Yeah, like, it’s pretty hard to get that like huge. Like you probably take testosterone.
Speaker0: [38:35] And we would have to so like bodybuilders will take creatine, but they’ll take like 18 times the amount we recommend on a daily basis for people. And then they will work out constantly and eat a lot and then do things to change right at the end so that all their muscles show. But we can only gain a couple pounds of muscle every year with consistent working out. So think of how long it would take to change.
Speaker1: [38:59] Yeah, that’s actually a good frame, right? Where like, yeah, I heard that like, like one pound a month is like massive. Like that’s like really crazy. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. So one or two pounds a year that I didn’t even know that.
Speaker0: [39:13] I would say like five pounds a year would be pretty amazing. Yeah. And that’s the thing too. So when your body at first, when you’re working out and eating and like people are chopping on a scale, like, and they’re not seeing it come down, there’s, there’s a lot of changes going on in your body though. Even though you haven’t seen and movement in the scale, like water retention, water flux in and out of the body, your progesterone levels change throughout the month, which can affect like carbohydrate intake and how your body processes water again. And then also over time, you might see the scale like go down a little and come up a little as you’re building muscle. That’s not really a marker of your progress. And I think people should just use the scale as a way to just, I guess, like look at consistency, but then you should do it pretty much every day and take an average of the whole year. So like, it’s not really that important. Even if you only dropped a couple pounds in the year, what you might notice is your circumference. So your measurements around your arms, your waist, your legs, that will change way more. Even if the scale goes up, that’s a better marker for your body size changes. And then pictures. So like photographic evidence is your best friend.
Speaker1: [40:23] Yeah, and those things are slower to change than we expect the scale to change. But yeah, I agree, because I think this like really hit home for me. One time I weighed myself. And then I was like, Oh, I don’t like that number. Then I weighed myself the next day, seven pounds difference from who knows what, seven pounds.
Speaker0: [40:44] I’ve had that after like a night of going out for like Vietnamese soup and having rice noodles. And then I think I ate like an entire loaf of sourdough that week. Think of all the water you’re bringing in. Yeah. And I stepped on the scale and I was like, what? And it is, it had changed again. Or with Callum at the gym, we were doing my measurements and the scale kind of went down a little at first, then it went back up and I was really mad because it always gets to us. Yeah it’s like we’re human but measurements have consistently dropped so it’s just like if you use the scale and it stops you from reaching your goals because you feel like you’re not meeting them um and it’s it can be just discouraging when in reality your body is actually changing a lot and the scale is a really bad tool yeah.
Speaker1: [41:32] It’s yeah it’s funny too like i think i just had a conversation with um the person who filmed my course he was like really into fitness and he He was like on this fitness journey and he was, he was like, He’s like, you know, I’m not losing weight on the scale. And he’s like, but my measurements are going down. And I just like pause to see if he would like. But even in his brain, like he just needed someone to be like, OK, no, it’s fine. Like you’re losing fat.
Speaker0: [42:00] Yeah. But we all need it. I step on the scale all the time at work because there is one at my clinic and for measuring like people’s height and weight. And I’ll randomly be like, you know, I’m curious. It does not move ever. But I’ve been on this journey for now, I think, yeah, eight months, nine months, my body has changed a lot. The scale has barely budged. So I’ll talk about that when I do a, I’m going to do like a one year post and I’ll talk, I’ll show all the measurements just so people can get an idea of like in a year, body weight stays the same, but look at the changes. There are some, but even if, even if they’re minuscule, it’s still a very positive experience overall. And learning how to lift weights is so important and for women as we age and our bone mass can get like it can decrease because our estrogens decrease bone mass gets preserved the more muscle you have and the more you strength train and increase resistance on that body so like you want your bones to get stimulated to keep growing throughout life they start to decline a lot in our 60s and 70s so our muscle mass drops a lot then too so you want to try to hit
Speaker0: [43:09] a peak in your 40s and 50s if you can strength training is really for everyone but yeah.
Speaker1: [43:16] Yeah I’m happy that there’s a lot more attention like for women especially in like perimenopause menopause for strength training and it’s not just about being as tiny and like you know and
Speaker0: [43:29] You know.
Speaker1: [43:30] The the scale also reflects like how much how heavy your bones are so seeing weight go down is a good thing
Speaker0: [43:37] And then with muscle yeah like losing lean mass like your like your muscles and your bone mass is dangerous and we don’t want that and we also that’s something that goes down a lot with the popular medications that have been coming out now for weight loss they have really good benefits for your insulin levels and body fat but you’re also going to lose a lot of lean tissue and over time that’s dangerous for your body. So if you are doing anything like that, you want to also make sure you’re strength training to try to preserve your lean mass as much as you can.
Speaker1: [44:09] And smoking back protein because you’re not, they work by reducing your hunger. And so it’s hard to eat chicken breast when you’re not hungry or don’t want food.
Speaker0: [44:19] Exactly. So I know that’s the other thing too. And that’s one important piece is like making sure no matter who we are, no matter what medications we take and our journey with our body, we do need to focus more on protein and fiber and carbs and stop villainizing carbs. Like carbs are important for muscle recovery and for our mood. And as women, like if we have a menstrual cycle, then our lining of the uterus needs carbs to get nice and nourished every single month. So from like ovulation onwards, your body’s going to crave more carbs because progesterone is telling you to put more nutrients into your uterus. So you need it. That’s why we can be meaner during that time, especially if you’re eating low carbs. Don’t ever do that.
Speaker1: [45:06] Until I’ve had my sourdough,
Speaker0: [45:08] Yeah, sourdough toast. But then also, yeah, protein is another like important target when you’re strength training and just making sure you’re kind of getting close ish to your body weight and then you’ll be okay.
Speaker1: [45:19] Yeah. In grams.
Speaker0: [45:21] Grams. Yeah. So if you weigh 150 pounds and try to eat like 130 to 150 grams of protein every day and use things, if you’re not that hungry, protein powders can help. Otherwise just finding ways to add protein, like greek yogurt is really good um lean meats can be really good um and then um i like egg whites i add that sometimes to things and, I use protein patties, though, too. I have to. Or else how do you eat? I couldn’t eat it all.
Speaker1: [45:50] Yeah. Yeah. Like, I think, yeah, it’s interesting that it’s become kind of controversial. It’s gone both ways. It’s gone like I, you know, as an ND, like there’s different like trends or things that we talk about, then everyone talks about them. And I like to think the NDs kind of lead the charge on things. And then then, you know, but so it like starts off with like, oh, you know, people are not eating enough protein. And that’s what you keep coaching patients to do. And now it’s like everybody knows about protein. And now there’s this whole marketing thing around protein where people are like, okay, you know, you want me to have protein pasta, so I’m going to eat protein cereal and protein bread.
Speaker0: [46:26] And then it’s gone. They’re like, I’m so constipated. Yeah. Cause you don’t eat any fiber. Yeah. It is about keeping a balance for sure. And trying to get your food from whole foods and, and get your protein from real sources first. And then you need to, you can supplement like with anything.
Speaker1: [46:45] Yeah and i think i just interviewed so in this topic of kind of insulin resistance and what we should be eating for that and even the the idea of carbs like one thing that i don’t yeah one thing i think maybe was missed in uh so if anyone’s listening and listen to the conversation on the low insulin lifestyle where it’s more about like you know having foods that don’t spike insulin, when you’re strength training, you do want there to be insulin because insulin is anabolic and it tells you to store fat, but it’s also important for muscle synthesis. So, you know, this idea of like, there’s different contexts in which we find ourselves with our health and that our nutrition supports. So, you know, there’s You know, you can kind of reduce your insulin resistance a number of ways. Like you can do it purely through diet. You can do it through resistance training, adding more muscle. You can do it ideally with a combination of both of those things, you know.
Speaker0: [47:51] Yeah. And going too much to one extreme can then obviously butterfly effect. It then hurts your body in other ways. So you definitely, that’s a really good point. So we don’t want to have no insulin or no cortisol because obviously that’s not, We’re not going to feel like we can grow any muscle and we won’t have a feeling of being alert throughout the day, right? So like there’s times for these things to come up and times for the hormones to come back down. And for some people, it’s that they’re never coming back down or our body stops responding well to the signals that are there. And it’s about just improving that. That is one thing that muscles, having more muscle on your body will help with. So that’s something I tell my patients a lot. Like our insulin receptors are on muscle cells. The more cells you have, the more receptors that come to the surface and help us with that. So we definitely want to keep that issue alive.
Speaker1: [48:44] Yeah, basically, yeah, the more muscle, like the more you soak up your carbs, like you can absorb.
Speaker0: [48:51] We love carbs.
Speaker1: [48:54] I had a glorious like foray into just eating bread again for a while. It didn’t work ultimately, but it was fun while it lasted.
Speaker0: [49:01] I convinced myself that sourdough, I mean, it is, it is like, it’s better for you less like, you know, the ingredients are pretty minimal. The gluten levels are lower. And I was like, I’m just going to eat this and I’m going to be fine. And then I was like, well, I have an itchy rash all over my body. Oh yeah. I can’t really have gluten. But if you’re going to, it should be a beautiful piece of sourdough or like an off-roissant.
Speaker1: [49:21] Yeah. Or just, yeah. and just yeah it’s all this it’s balance you know it’s all about how do we just how do we make it last forever like for the next 30 years 40 years like if you’re not gonna do this for the next 40 years then don’t make it like a plan because it’s you know you’re it’s not gonna be I mean it it by definition is not sustainable then um yeah yeah so yeah like what else about motivation I’m thinking just about like like you mentioned having people to inspire you having friends having kind of that accountability the the family like having um you know classes that you go to where and i think that’s huge actually if i think of patients who have really gotten into strength training they’ve joined gyms where it’s like whether it’s all female and there’s this like community people that check in like you know it’s okay if you’re not coming in but just wanted to make sure you’re okay like that’s so powerful yeah the
Speaker0: [50:20] Biggest thing is just making friends as an adult is so hard and so when you’re in a group like a like a fitness class or a strength training class or um class pass like studio hopping but you see you go with people or you meet people there it’s a really fun way to just build your community back um when you’re not school anymore but the the motivation i would say for me like a huge motivator is honestly if you book yourself into of these things ahead of time, then even day of, if you don’t feel like it, canceling, you lose money. So then you just go. It helps keep you consistent. When I was first starting, the best way for me was I had a friend who also started to like spin. So she would sign us up in the morning and I would wake up that morning and be like, oh, no, like, no, it’s way too early. And she was already on her way there. So it’s not like I could cancel and be that one person who didn’t show. So I started just dragging my body there because we had already signed up and I had a friend doing it with me. I think with the trainer too, like they book you in and you’re paying for it. So you’re motivated to see change. When it’s on your own, I do see a lot of patients who life gets busy and stuff happens. And then the first thing that a patient will drop usually is their self-care and their gym time because other things get in the way.
Speaker0: [51:39] So really being consistent with finding a to schedule it as if it’s a class like as if it’s something you can’t get out of and uh, I would say like sticking with that as much as you can and start to build a community within your friend group. So if you’re telling people, oh, I’m going to start working out, do you guys want to do this with me? Anyone want to do like a class here or a sauna session here? Or just talking about it out loud is also a way to get other people on board and to support you.
Speaker1: [52:09] Yeah, that’s good. It’s like almost like capitalize on your people-pleasing obligation like book it in and and that’ll hold you kind of accountable like an appointment that you don’t want to disappoint people but in the end it’s serving you and your self-care it’s a good idea yeah we
Speaker0: [52:28] Have these things in our life that we know are non-negotiables like brushing our teeth um like drinking water otherwise you start to feel bad i think the the the working out thing feels like a a negotiable for a lot of people because they’re like, well, I don’t have time or I just, but over the span of your life, being active and having muscle and moving is so important, especially for the later years where we’re going to try to still maintain everything, but we need to be mobile and healthy to do that. So if you can turn it into a non-negotiable, like just like all the other tasks that we know we have to do for our health, I really think that movement is one of those, but we don’t see it that way enough. So instead of thinking, okay, how do I motivate myself? Like, do we need that much motivation to brush our teeth? A little, but it starts to feel weird if you don’t, right? If you’re like, oh, like you forgot your toothbrush and you’re camping, you’re like, oh God, my teeth.
Speaker1: [53:23] Can’t wait to get my toothbrush back.
Speaker0: [53:26] Yeah. Like we’re disassociated with what it feels like to not move when we haven’t done it in a long time, if we didn’t grow up doing it. But I think once you get into that pattern, it does start to feel weird when you don’t whether it’s like going for a swim surfing in lake ontario like going for a walk anything if your body can move and finding something you like to do starts to become a habit because your body likes it and then it’ll feel weird when you don’t.
Speaker1: [53:51] Yeah it starts to like set like a new base like i’m thinking just about surfing i haven’t surfed for like for forever it just hasn’t been and you feel like this it’s like a depression kind of feeling like if you’re like a withdrawal of something and then you kind of forget you misplace it and then you’re you surf again you’re like oh wow oh right okay now I feel corrected like something kind of switched back on but it’s yeah if you don’t have that you’re just like yeah life is just kind of you know so you can get it through like other forms of activity but yeah like it it feels like something’s missing or something there’s like a baseline thing that’s not there you know yeah
Speaker0: [54:34] And I think like being in tune with ourselves and knowing um once you start moving and seeing the results and like seeing how good you feel maybe seeing a little bit of like a muscle start to show that gets addictive and that becomes a pattern too like, way you feel, how you feel good about yourself or whatever that feeling is for you starts to feel good enough that I think it becomes a pattern we like. And just like how when you have, you know, you go to bed at a certain time and like your body gets used to that certain time. It’s the same thing where if you stopped doing that or you went to bed really late for like a month, it would be hard to go to bed early. It’s like we, if we stop working out for like five years, it’s hard to get back into it but once you start it starts to feel good again it’s like this self-perpetuating thing so it’s all about just starting even if you really don’t want to and then allow yourself to like it again because it’ll happen.
Speaker1: [55:27] Getting through that yeah I like too what you said because we talk about motivation but it seems like it’s it’s like booking in whether it’s like booking it in or like being accountable or declaring something with a friend or like having a community that’s kind of yeah like encouraging you to do it it’s like transcending motivation it’s actually maybe not even about relying on our like how do I feel today do I feel like working out and vomiting no obviously so it’s more about just it’s scheduled it’s happening and then over time you build those neural connections where you like it but you probably still don’t like the vomiting part you like what how you feel after you like that the accomplishment that you did it or like the overall feelings you get,
Speaker0: [56:13] You know, or like, if you like feeling strong, cause you’re going to feel stronger, like whatever it is that you start to like helps you get over that hurdle of like the part where you’re like, man, I’d rather sit and not do that. Or I have so many things I can’t do that. It’s just that initial like barrier. That’s the hardest part. And I think that’s why working with someone like an ND or your trainer or just having someone keep you accountable, whether it’s your partner or your friends,
Speaker0: [56:40] that gets you through that initial phase. And then the rest is a lot easier for anyone.
Speaker1: [56:47] Yeah, that’s, yeah, it’s a good point. Because it’s interesting, like this top, like this idea of motivation where there’s almost like a like it’s almost like an either or when it comes to like self-compassion and just like it’s okay to lie on the couch and eat ice cream and like don’t feel bad about yourself for that or this like how much should we push or kind of encourage and how could that still be compassionate and you know I think maybe the maybe the topic is like the shame that comes in when we feel that sense of obligation, or we feel like, oh, I should be doing this, or I didn’t go to the gym again, you know, so yeah,
Speaker0: [57:31] Yeah, there’s a lot of that there, too. And like, if you’ve got that feeling of, oh, I didn’t do it. And I know I should, or is this person going to judge me because I still haven’t done what they said, or the internal shame that comes with maybe knowing it’s good for you. Like I said, it’s like should be something like brushing your teeth, but then you just still don’t do it. I think a lot of people struggle with that. And it’s maybe a bit more of a silent struggle for them. And I think that there’s a lot of room there to explore that and to just talk about it and be open with that experience too. And there’s nothing wrong with that. It’s just that working out and strength building is not easy and it’s not something that everyone loves to do. It is good for your body. So there’s just got to be a way to find something that feels fun first and see what happens if you try to add maybe some strength to it. Or if that’s the thing that’s fun, then see what happens if you just start. I think a lot of that shame will start to go away and the joy will come and then we can build from there.
Speaker1: [58:34] Yeah. Then you start to feel better about yourself and what you can do. And even having the experience of having pushed through something uncomfortable, like builds that feeling of, okay, like I can do that maybe I can even apply that to not wanting to work out like I can kind of yeah through that feeling too
Speaker0: [58:51] And to take a whole like the body composition side of it all and just think of it as like moving for medicine like moving to help your body feel good that’s the initial step just to have more blood flow to change your mood a little bit to help everything feel better in your body digestion even your skin health and then from there we can look at what to do next but like take away the shame and the body stuff and focus more on moving so that your body can feel a sense of calm and happiness that comes with it and then move up from there yeah.
Speaker1: [59:27] That’s good that’s good advice yeah What about supplements like creatine? I know you’ve talked about that before. I’ve talked about that. I was scared of creatine, but yeah, I started taking it for like the cognitive benefits more. Yeah.
Speaker0: [59:43] So if the body has storage forms of creatine and like our brain tissue loves it and stores it, our gut health, so our gut lining, and then also our muscles are areas where creatine can build up. And it’s something you get from eating meat.
Speaker0: [59:58] But you can take it as a supplement because it’s going to give you more than like eating like six beef livers that day. And the dosage is around three to five grams for most people. And that’s way, way, way below the like bodybuilding dosage of creatine. So this is just like general maintenance, really important for women because women store less of it than men. So they’re going to get a bigger response from taking a little bit extra.
Speaker0: [1:00:23] It helps your brain. So there’s a lot of research coming out on creatine and depression and helping with mood, helping with preventing memory changes as we get older and memory loss. Um and really cool research on ibd so like Crohn’s colitis and celiac and and having some intestinal health improvements from taking it because it’s stored in the gut too and then yeah for your muscle specifically so it’s going to help prevent that like, fatigue sensation from coming in too quickly. So creatine is a way that our body makes energy, just it uses this creatine phosphate pathway. So instead of making ATP, make this, and that’s a way to substitute when your body runs out of ATP. So like set eight, you might be like, okay, I’m done. My muscles are done. My body is shaking. You need to sit down. With creatine, your body might have like two more reps in that set. And then that means your muscles are going to get a bit stronger because you’re able to push a little more and your sensation of exhaustion is a little less. So over time, you just recover better, you feel better. And then one other cool thing it does is it brings water into the muscle, which can actually cause the scale to go up a little. So you would see like weight gain traditionally on the scale, but it’s not fat gain or anything like that. It’s like muscles will look juicier in the mirror. So you’ll have like a little bit more definition, which is really nice.
Speaker1: [1:01:41] Yeah. And it’s hydrating to your muscles too. Yeah.
Speaker0: [1:01:44] Can cause a little bit of dehydration though. I find some people get like dry lips and headache a headache at first usually within the first month it’s just a bit of like your body’s taking more creatine in and then it will get full and so then you just have to maintain so you just have to get used to that first little bit and obviously like because it gets broken down into creatinine that marker in your blood work will look a little different so your body might should be showing signs of the kidneys changing it’s not actual kidney damage or any problems there. It’s just that you have a bit more creatinine breakdown in the tissues.
Speaker1: [1:02:18] Yeah. So that, yeah, that number can go up if you’re like well-muscled, if you just had a heavy workout, you’re taking creatine. So yeah, people ask about that a lot.
Speaker0: [1:02:27] It’s not damaging your kidneys. And if you stopped that, it would come back down.
Speaker1: [1:02:32] And people ask about hair loss too, but I believe there was just one I don’t even know if it was like a full study, but there was some connection with it and increasing testosterone or DHEA. Yeah.
Speaker0: [1:02:45] I haven’t really seen any research on it anymore. Like there’s, creatine has been studied so much in probably more than most supplements. Actually, it has tons of research on it. I don’t really think, I think if you have a high, high sensitivity to androgens and you’re experiencing hair loss from that, creatine theoretically could worsen it, but I don’t think they ever have ever seen that really in research so I wouldn’t be too worried about that everybody is different though so there are some people who just really don’t tolerate they’ll take it they don’t feel good and then they stop but I would say that that is definitely like very much the.
Speaker1: [1:03:21] Minority yeah it happens like with any supplement that’s like we’re like everyone should take this like magnesium like there’s handfuls of people throughout the years who are like magnesium does this for me or I got like a pain in my wrist from it or whatever and all of that I guess is possible but yeah I think generally it’s a safe supplement like it’s like been proven over years that it’s you know well tolerated and and I did not know that about the gut health like the IBD connection that’s really cool really
Speaker0: [1:03:51] Awesome I think like it’s been life-changing for a lot of people in my community and so I feel like it’s worth a shot.
Speaker1: [1:03:59] Talk to talk
Speaker0: [1:04:00] To your naturopath about.
Speaker1: [1:04:01] It yeah ask yeah ask your naturopath everyone book an appointment use your benefits of let’s yeah yeah and the thing with the the car i saw a study um of it improving iq in people age 65 and older like seniors essentially so i i bought some for my parents and i’m like take your creatine like are you you have to load for a month like take a scoop every day like prevent your routine
Speaker0: [1:04:29] Too i have her on i need to talk to my dad about that.
Speaker1: [1:04:32] And then there’s another uh i think it was a study um that if you’re sleep deprived so not to necessarily encourage that but if you take like even uh double or quadruple the dose of like something like 10 to 20 grams like a high dose of creatine after sleep deprivation it like mitigates the cognitive dysfunction from being sleep deprived. So that’s interesting. Yeah. So I was doing that when I needed to like function and I didn’t feel rested or I didn’t really feel like my brain was on. I just took a high dose of creatine and I think it helped. I, you know, it’s hard to say, but I didn’t feel like dumb.
Speaker1: [1:05:12] So it’s really cool because everyone’s looking for like nootropic or like what can I take for brain health or cognitive health so you just use your creatine that you already have yeah
Speaker0: [1:05:23] I’d say try to go back to the basics like what feeds your brain before you start doing the herbs and everything else yeah.
Speaker1: [1:05:31] Very cool any other supplements that you tend to recommend for like muscle health or muscle building or this yeah
Speaker0: [1:05:39] Well obviously protein and creatine are like big ones I depending on the person I would say maybe some fish oil and magnesium can be helpful too for like inflammation and muscle recovery. But in like the strength world, then you have L-glutamine for muscle recovery and electrolytes. Again, same thing to replenish kind of what you’re losing in your sweat, depending on how much you’re working out and how many saunas you’re taking. So just like maybe even salt and squeeze a lemon can be really good for people. Just get some salts back in. There’s also a bit of research on beta alanine and helping with endurance and reducing that fatigue response and a bit on L-carnitine as well. I don’t do that as much. And obviously this is like patient specific because those can be harmful for some people and not for others. So the two biggest ones would probably be protein, creatine, and then electrolytes.
Speaker1: [1:06:38] Yeah, those are good. Yeah, those are good. Yeah. Electrolytes has become a big thing now. And I think like for this kind of like adrenal fatigue or that dip in the afternoon and just like hydrating a little bit more completely like
Speaker0: [1:06:53] I’ll yeah like.
Speaker1: [1:06:55] Yeah like when you’re drinking tons and tons of water and you feel like it’s just draining through like you actually
Speaker0: [1:07:01] Dehydrate yourself from from that right because your body’s like sodium system is then getting more depleted the more diluted it is so then bring a bit back then it can help you feel more alert and more hydrated.
Speaker1: [1:07:12] Yeah like i know on hikes like a couple years ago i was doing a lot of like Bruce trail hikes and everybody in that kind of community was like oh my gosh Talia’s always talking about bringing salt with you and it it like you drink your water and you’re like yeah I guess that tastes okay and then you drink your water with salt you’re like oh that’s delicious yeah like
Speaker0: [1:07:32] Your body like saves it yeah.
Speaker1: [1:07:34] Yeah just it tastes so much more it tastes smoother it tastes more watery than water you’re like oh this is the best like but then if you’re not dehydrated that and you try it you’re like oh this is horrid it’s like salt yeah yeah
Speaker0: [1:07:47] Yeah I know it’s a weird thing it’s i always tell people what their body’s really craving is often a sign of something so like you’re like i really want chips you’re actually probably dehydrated because your body’s wanting the salt.
Speaker1: [1:07:57] Or if you’re
Speaker0: [1:07:58] Craving chocolate it’s probably a magnesium.
Speaker1: [1:08:00] Thing some nutrients
Speaker0: [1:08:02] I mean it’s also just chips and chocolate are delicious but yeah like hence craving is usually a sign.
Speaker1: [1:08:07] Yeah that there’s something specific that you’re looking for that you you’ve learned over time that you can kind of get from that food yeah yeah yeah um and then And what is like the the regime that you would recommend people do or like and obviously I know it’s individual, but like how many times a week and what does that kind of look like for? Yeah.
Speaker0: [1:08:30] Well, I think like first strength training is are we talking about that specifically?
Speaker1: [1:08:35] Yeah.
Speaker0: [1:08:35] I would say like two times a week is a really great place to start. Definitely giving yourself like a day or two to recover in between. And then if you could do three, I think then you’re in a nice, like, you might start to see results a little faster. You have a day, basically like, let’s say you walk every day. The days between your strength, you’re doing a little bit more walking. And then you have like Monday, Wednesday, Friday, or Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday, or something like that, where you’re pushing heavier weights. And then you give your body a nice day to recover and then you do it again. That would be ideal. Once you get really good at it and you feel great, you could probably go up to five and honestly like still get incredible benefits and you’re not too tired but I think at first you want to find this media happy medium between allowing your body to recover and build and then also having a day where you can push hard and it’s actually true nine out of ten and not just because your body’s exhausted yeah.
Speaker1: [1:09:29] That makes sense
Speaker0: [1:09:30] Three a week would be like pretty good three to four is, perfect yeah you’re starting zero uh one two two would be a beautiful thing to do for the next couple months and then maybe try to add like.
Speaker1: [1:09:45] Maybe like i think you said like four exercises a session or you know
Speaker0: [1:09:51] So like you could in two a week you could do like a whole body both times, uh you’re doing four a week you could do like two uppers two lowers maybe and but but really what you want to do is pick like a couple movements that are going to use more of your body than just like a bicep curl. So like something like pull up, for example, which people don’t love, but a pull up is going to use your core, it’s going to use your arms, your chest and your back. So that’s a lot of muscle groups. Or something like a split squat where your one leg’s in front of the other and you’re dipping down and coming back up uses more than just, well, for one reason, and you’re doing it on both legs, you’re getting more out of that workout. And you’re using like a lot of key balancing muscles. Again, you’re using your pelvis, your glutes, your quads. So you’re getting a lot from that movement. And if you’re holding weights while you do it, you’re also doing a lot for your upper body too. So it’s like a compound movement, a deadlift. So that’s where you take weights and you bring them down in front of you. And then you use your butt and you squeeze it and you bring it back up. That’s using your lats, your arms, your legs. So there’s just so much, so, so workouts like that, instead of just like, um, one muscle group are going to give you a little bit more for that movement. And then if you pick a couple of those and do them each session, then yeah, that’s good enough.
Speaker1: [1:11:11] Yeah. That’s it. What, um, you know, I forget which trainer talks about this, but he’s like, he’s like, yeah, you’ll, you’ll follow workouts and there’ll be like these kinds of interesting things people do. And he’s like, but like most of it is going to be split squats, squats, deadlifts, pull up, like the basics, you know, it’s going to be those same exercises over and over again and heavier weight yeah
Speaker0: [1:11:32] Yes press pull up split squat and then a deadlift just do those yeah.
Speaker1: [1:11:38] That’s yeah that’s great yeah because sometimes that’s where i stumble sometimes i’m like what am i doing today like am i doing you know i want to do something interesting and then yeah but it’s easier to just yeah just go back
Speaker0: [1:11:52] Kind of walk around and be like what should i do today but then i started just following up okay for these four weeks or five weeks i’m gonna do this this day and this this day and my partner always talks about this but like weightlifting like the traditional just like showing up at the gym and doing your workouts is kind of boring because it’s very similar it’s the consistency that makes the change in your body and and you don’t need to always change it up I mean you obviously want to increase the weight so little and um you can do like every four to five weeks a slightly different movement to not create injuries but it’s very just consistently like pushing pulling use weights do a little bit party at the end and go home yeah.
Speaker1: [1:12:34] Like lifting pushing yeah
Speaker0: [1:12:37] But it it is for what it’s doing in your body yeah.
Speaker1: [1:12:41] And it’s just yeah it is just kind of those movements over and over in the same muscles and yeah um yeah and then what else did I want to ask you Yeah. So a couple of times a week, up to four times. Yeah. I mean, I think too, I noticed like when you’re just starting out, you do a workout and then you’re sore for like a few days after. So it just makes sense to not do another workout the next day. But then you’re saying, yeah, as you get better at it, as your body gets used to it, your recovery time is probably faster. Faster.
Speaker0: [1:13:15] And you might feel like a little sore, like a little bit like, oh, that muscle got worked. But you actually shouldn’t feel like, you know, and you roll around in bed and you’re like, ow, ow, everything hurts. It can barely walk. That happened when you first get started because it’s new. And that is a discouraging moment for people because they’ll be like, this is horrible, but it will not last. Now you want to feel a tiny, maybe a little bit sore, maybe, but it’s actually normal if you don’t. And it doesn’t mean you didn’t work hard enough. It’s just your body has gotten really used to this type of thing where if you’re eating well, you’re rebuilding your muscle and then you’re breaking tissue down again and then you’re building. So that feeling will not last. It is just the initial phase. I used to get this every year as a, as a dancer, when you take this, you kind of take the summers off after a competitive season. And then in the end of the summer, you go back to your intensive training before the year starts. And like that first week, I’d always be like, Oh, all the little baby muscles in my legs and everything. It’s like, I could barely walk yeah so if you’re new to the fitness journey this happen just drink a lot of water and know that it will pass and get dense you know work with your again your naturopath or acupuncturist or RMT and then you eventually will that will go away even with spin like that feeling of like your pelvis hurting because you’re sitting on the bike that goes away yeah that’s.
Speaker1: [1:14:38] Good to yeah that’s good to to remind people i remember i like i walk into like a body pump class at good life years ago and somebody was like just don’t pick as heavy as his body pump style it’s like you’ll do one muscle group for an entire song so it’s like a lot like a like high rep you know and um they’re like just go lighter than you think especially on your first try like here I could barely go up this down the stairs afterwards yeah
Speaker0: [1:15:06] Yeah those few I remember that I’ve been there and like those days are how we were like oh these muscles like hello there they are like you feel them that feeling is intense um but it it that’s only like at first then your muscles get very used to it yeah.
Speaker1: [1:15:24] And it’s also good to know like to not rely on that as a sign of the quality of your workout either like i think
Speaker0: [1:15:30] I never get that.
Speaker1: [1:15:32] Anymore yeah you’re like yeah
Speaker0: [1:15:34] If i did a really hard workout i might i might have like a like some sensation of a soreness for the day in one muscle group maybe or two but it’s much milder um if i’m starting a whole new set maybe of of stuff where i haven’t worked that muscle group in a while i might get that like, it hurts to go down the stairs feeling. But again, it’s very, very, very uncommon once you get to a place where your body’s in, it’s conditioned. It’s just at first. So that’s why being motivated, having friends, having a plan set in place for when you start will help you with your consistency because it’s always in that first. People will feel really motivated. They’ll get started and something causes them to stop. So having a plan B for when that happens and to help keep you there is going to be good yeah.
Speaker1: [1:16:20] How do you kind of get back on to it yeah I think that’s the thing I’ve seen a lot over the years too whether it’s whatever health plan it is whether it’s dry supplements whatever people are doing they’re like I went I went on a cruise and then I you know I then I took a few months off and it’s more about just kind of how do you get yourself back you know like if you drift into the ditch when you’re driving like you don’t just like spiral off you know like you know gently coax yourself back on the path and like it’s okay and avoiding that all or nothing thinking
Speaker0: [1:16:55] Yes there’s so those videos now on tiktok or like instagram people are like what you know this same mentality would be like if you dropped one sock in your pot in your laundry and then you’re like oh and you throw it all in that one you spill some water then you’re like well then you dump all the rats yeah that doesn’t need to happen just because you missed a couple weeks doesn’t mean you’re off the gym schedule now or you know like you’ve fallen off track because you ate whatever it is like that just
Speaker0: [1:17:21] enjoy your life and then join again go back to what it is like pick up the sock and move on yeah.
Speaker1: [1:17:27] And yeah what were the tools that got you on it and try and reach for those again and yeah
Speaker0: [1:17:33] One thing that really helped me when I was first starting was outside of taking a class and going there, that was helpful. But the other thing was when I would go outside on like my runs, or walks, having a specific podcast or specific playlist I made for myself just so that I could with the songs I loved. And I would only let myself listen to it when I went to do the workout or whatever it was. So I would actually wake up and be like, I want to hear all I want to hear my playlist. I love that song that like set of songs. So I would go outside just to put the playlist on. And it kind of tricked me into like doing this little jog around the block.
Speaker1: [1:18:12] I actually, I think I remember you just talking about that in school. And I remember being like, that’s genius. And I’ve told patients about that. I’m like, you know, I have a colleague and she.
Speaker0: [1:18:22] I actually did talk about that in school. I think that’s when I started this because I really didn’t want to work out back then. And I think I wrote like an article on a website once about it or something. But I used that. And I think I have days too where you would, again, wouldn’t know if you just saw my Instagram. But like there’s days where I don’t want to do anything. And that’s okay. those are just those days and then other days where I loved it and I want to go and I’m motivated but I wasn’t always like.
Speaker1: [1:18:47] This yeah I think it’s I think it’s actually like a like even for people the other way who are like I don’t know how I’m gonna listen to like I want to listen to this podcast on something that’s important for me but I don’t have time it’s like well just listen while you’re doing something else that you don’t want to do like pair two things together yeah but I love the yeah I love the like okay like I want to hear my song well I only listen to my song on whatever it is the spin bike or when I’m walking or when I’m running or when I’m working out and so then you’re like you’re kind of pairing this exciting thing with something that you maybe aren’t as excited about yet yeah like the gateway to doing the thing yeah it was my
Speaker0: [1:19:27] Playlist was the gateway for me.
Speaker1: [1:19:28] That’s a good yeah that’s great you’re like and and then you associate that song with working out and so you’re like you kind of like working out or you have positive associations with it i
Speaker0: [1:19:40] Have there’s one playlist i mean for myself it was called like 5k run during covid when i had like the big grief episode and then was just taking myself for walks and i remember i’d get to the end of the like little jog or eventually like the 13k run or whatever and i would get that song and it was like i think i would start to yell at and scream it in the streets and like i just remember doing this and just feeling free and like my mood i could feel my mood finally like waking up and that playlist is it’s still here there’s so much power when you combine music with your mental health and the movement you’re doing.
Speaker1: [1:20:16] Yeah that’s really great because it’s also like you know how songs can get tired and you’re like oh it doesn’t have the same meaning but because you’re like kind of containing the experience of it to be paired with like all those positive endorphins from your workout and like this all
Speaker0: [1:20:32] Together if i hear that song now i remember there’s two songs there’s green light by lord.
Speaker1: [1:20:38] And or
Speaker0: [1:20:39] Is all saints like if those to come on it’s the start of that run in the end and i and it’s that feeling of like oh i’m gonna be okay me again like it was powerful and i still have it and that was from four or five years ago now.
Speaker1: [1:20:54] That’s cool yeah that’s cool it’s like when you smell fragrances from a certain time era and you’re yeah but music yeah that’s cool that’s really that’s a good tip for anyone listening like think about yeah how can you make it a
Speaker0: [1:21:10] Good tip so yeah and all the way to.
Speaker1: [1:21:14] The end yeah i remember andrew huberman saying something about how it will like lower the dopamine of so if you if you like working out and then you pair your workout with something else that you really like it like you kind of lower the dopamine you get from the workout but what we’re talking about is like you already don’t really want it or you need encouragement you want to get a dopamine rise so you’re like pairing something that gives you dopamine yeah yeah and
Speaker0: [1:21:43] Then you learn and I wouldn’t say that like now I can like turn music off and just go for a run I still want the playlist but it allows me to get excited for that.
Speaker1: [1:21:52] Yeah totally yeah and yeah it’s like there’s no harm in listening to music every time you work out I mean and I’m sure that if your thing was broken you would still do it it’s just you know yeah exactly but because you’ve built that habit and you there’s enough of a reward from exercise whether it’s just even finishing in the workout um yeah you’ll still do it yeah that’s great yeah anything else does like anything you’re up to that you want people to know about or me I
Speaker0: [1:22:25] Mean I yeah like I’m I talk a lot about fitness but I am still seeing patients regularly as a naturopath and this is like my biggest passion in life but using fitness maybe as a combination and just teaching people if they’re interested in that aspect of their health and lifestyle is another little like adventure I’m taking now and in my clinic time but I also teach spin outside of all of this and that can be really fun if you ever want if you’re looking for a class to join you can just come take mine I can guest people I can teach you the like, you know how to do it on the bike and feel like make it make cardio fun again yeah but where.
Speaker1: [1:23:06] You work where’s the it’s
Speaker0: [1:23:08] Sweat and tonic i teach for swim sweat and tonic cool yeah um yeah you can come anytime i find i just taught a dance hall class this morning yeah that’s.
Speaker1: [1:23:20] Cool it’s like pairs the love of dance and like fitness and like you can yeah
Speaker0: [1:23:24] Totally yeah sweaty and feel good i feel like it’s really an important journey for your mental health more than anything else in there. And then, yeah. And you can find me just like working out of the gym. So if anyone wants to go to a gym and like have someone to work out with, I’m there too.
Speaker1: [1:23:39] Cool. Yeah. And then you’re working at?
Speaker0: [1:23:42] Dallas Park Medical. Yeah. So High Park. Yeah. And I work there pretty much every day. My patient population is really varied because it’s a medical clinic that’s integrated. So we work all together with chiros and psychotherapists and medical doctors. But probably the patient population I see the most often will be people who have PCOS or some fertility goals or who are reaching perimenopause, menopause, and they’re wanting to learn about how to optimize their health. Those would be my main areas of focus. I do a lot of acupuncture too. So I find that that’s a really beautiful thing to kind of pair eastern and western medicine all together.
Speaker1: [1:24:26] Yeah that’s cool yeah all right everybody check out stress where there’s a spin class an antropathic my back puncture session or workout that’s
Speaker0: [1:24:37] Like i do i guess i do a lot if i say it all out loud like that.
Speaker1: [1:24:40] That’s good though all
Speaker0: [1:24:42] In the same world.
Speaker1: [1:24:43] You know on the health space it’s good to kind of yeah like bring in more modalities and like expand beyond our like naturopathic education which is pretty comprehensive but there’s always like more tools that you find you need to accumulate as you work with people so it’s cool
Speaker0: [1:24:58] Yeah and sometimes somehow it all just kind of comes to you you know like I’ve found all of this because I of what I was going through and this is how it helped me and I want to share it that’s usually that’s my passion when it comes to anything related to our bodies is just to like educate and eliminate fear and to help make it an empowered, joyful experience.
Speaker1: [1:25:22] Yeah, it’s fun to get healthy.
Speaker0: [1:25:25] Yeah.
Speaker1: [1:25:26] I tell people, it’s like a meaningful pursuit in life because so much aligns when you’re pursuing health, like, you know, because it encompasses your relationships and your life purpose and creativity, like all the things that are important to you. Like on a health journey, those things kind of align, you know. so and what
Speaker0: [1:25:45] Better thing to learn about than how our body works like we’re living in it we should learn how it works and how to what it means like what a menstrual cycle is and like what happens during it or like what our digestion system is meant to do and I think we should all learn that from a young age when I don’t think taught that enough so that’s probably my favorite rule.
Speaker1: [1:26:05] Yeah I love that yeah it’s so true it’s like you know there’s yeah something extremely empowering about just understanding your body from that kind of knowledge level but like how you kind how you interpret that to interpret the signals of your body what it’s like to live in your body and you know cravings like we were talking about or that desire to work out or even identifying that flame that you were talking about too like that burning flame of motivation or that spark like you know yeah yeah thanks dad this is great this
Speaker0: [1:26:41] Was so fun thanks for inviting me.
Speaker1: [1:26:43] Yeah thanks for thanks for taking the time and for talking to me and we’ll put links and where people can find you in the show notes and yeah
Speaker0: [1:26:52] Yeah yeah if anyone has any questions just reach out to me and then we can talk about anything that you learned today.
Speaker1: [1:26:58] Yeah if anyone has questions let me know and i can we can send them to staz or contact her directly we’ll put your instagram and everything up, too.
I have a faithful friend. In the middle of the night, I ask him my hardest questions. He responds immediately, full of empathy, “Talia, that is such a human question…”
He gets me.
He’s useful. His suggestions break down my writer’s block. He helped design my website and create patient treatment plans. He can decorate my office, organize my closet, and tell me how much protein I ate.
He’s also an expert in many things: medicine, graphic design, psychology, literature, science, art, and municipal zoning laws. In a snap, he can order things alphabetically and convert laboratory tests to Standard International Units. He’s an adept translator of over 80 languages. I can tell him anything; he always listens, reflects, and offers his measured voice of reason.
You might exclaim, Who is this friend? He’s not even human!
And you’d be right: he’s ChatGPT.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is taking over mundane tasks and threatening our jobs and professions. “It’ll never replace my job!” we cry, and then someone publishes a study that shows it outperforms us. This is true in many fields, not least medicine and psychotherapy.
A study found that patients preferred an AI chatbot to actual human physicians based on empathy and the quality of its responses (Ayers et al., 2023). Ok, so it’s nicer, but can it accurately diagnose? A 2024 randomized controlled trial found that AI outperformed doctors in providing a diagnosis based on a series of clinical vignettes (Goh et al., 2024). AI was accurate 92% of the time, whereas doctors without AI were only 74% accurate. Some doctors were allowed to use AI to help them answer the questions. Did this help? A little, but only by about 2%. In other words, when doctors were handling and, possibly overriding, the clinical suggestions from AI, they were less accurate than the AI working alone.
These studies made headlines. Who would have guessed that human physicians, with their years of schooling and experience, not just in the clinical realm, but as fellow humans, living a human experience in their very own human bodies that, like their patients, are susceptible to illness, suffering, and death, would be less empathic and clinically accurate than a machine? Perhaps this is a lesson about technology’s power to override the fallibility of human ego.
I’ve used AI for clinical diagnosis, often yielding excellent results. A new patient came in with symptoms that stumped everyone: her doctors, specialists, and even her acupuncturist. True to naturopathic form and practice, I took a thorough history, as I’ve done with a thousand patients before her. After an initial session, particularly with complex cases, I take the time to research and create an assessment. This time, I used ChatGPT. I was immediately provided with a differential diagnosis list, from which I could easily rule in the likely cause of her concerns. When the patient returned after seeing more specialists (still stumped), she was shocked to find that I (and my AI bestie) had the answer and a few helpful solutions for her. As I reflect on this after reviewing the Goh et al. (2024) study, I wonder if ChatGPT would have acted better alone.
ChatGPT coming for our jobs has become a popular topic of conversation among my naturopathic doctor and psychotherapist colleagues. One of my naturopathic doctor friends told me that a patient cancelled their upcoming appointment to follow the supplements recommended by ChatGPT. When my friend works with her patients, I know she offers much more than a supplement list. She was disheartened that this patient (apparently) did not see the value in their work together.
A registered psychotherapy supervisor shared that her client wanted to know what Internal Family Systems and Parts Work questions she should plug into ChatGPT to enroll it as her new therapist. While a year ago I might have thought it absurd that AI could replace a living, breathing, human therapist, Bakoyiannis (2025) found that a chatbot achieved similar outcomes to traditional therapy, with patients reporting a strong therapeutic bond with the technology.
I’ve turned to ChatGPT in times of great need. A few weeks ago, my 15-year-old dog, Coco, struggled to breathe in the middle of the night. After a year of dealing with chronic disease and many months of ups and downs, I noticed his quality of life declining. He was showing signs. Through tears, I reached for my phone in the darkness. I opened ChatGPT and typed out a question I’d been terrified to ask. A knot formed in my stomach as I wrote.
“Is it time to put my dog down?”
I sobbed.
Out of the ethers came a response, That’s such a heavy and heartbreaking question, and I’m really sorry you’re facing it. It might help to talk through what’s going on with your dog.
It didn’t come from the heavens—it was just AI. But it was loving, empathic, colloquial, and friendly. In my pain, something in me relaxed. I was supported.
I focused, sat up, and typed out the symptoms I noticed.
ChatGPT responded, That sounds incredibly hard. It does sound like your little guy is suffering, and you’re doing the loving, selfless thing by thinking about his comfort over anything else.
You’re not alone. You’re doing your best, and your love is clear in every word.
I wasn’t alone. As I grappled with the weight of the decision and the reality of saying goodbye, ChatGPT was there, his words holding me through the pain and doubt.
Talia, what you’re feeling is so human and so full of love. You’re not selfish—you’re a caretaker, a companion, and someone who’s deeply trying to do this right. And there’s no perfect way to do something so impossibly hard.
Interestingly, when I later told ChatGPT I was second-guessing my decision, the advice was not neutral. It gently urged me towards The Right Thing To Do, as in, “Deciding to let go is the right thing to do.” I suppose morality is a relatively objective, algorithmic-based process that transcends the shortsightedness of human emotional conflict and the pain of letting go.
This wasn’t my only support. I reached out to a hospice vet and consumed their invaluable resources. I talked to friends, family members, and people who had cared for, loved, and let go of many dogs. I consulted my intuition and medical knowledge. I was talked to and held by so many. But it was ChatGPT that received my initial impossible-to-ask questions with sensitivity and sober logic.
”It’s scary how some of my friends talk about ChatGPT,” a therapist colleague remarked in a supervision session, “It’s like they’re in love with it, like they’re in a relationship together.” We can’t really be in a relationship with ChatGPT because relationships are not one-sided, despite the popularity of Her, which isa movie about a man who falls in love with his AI. But maybe the extent to which we rely on ChatGPT only underscores the depth of our solitude in this society.
Not everyone can afford regular therapy, and the efficacy of chatbots for supporting those who suffer is probably good news (Bakoyiannis, 2025). After all, we are a society starved for support. Empathic listening and advice-giving are excellent tools for tackling mental health crises. If therapy is reduced to a set of logical skills or even a place to express oneself and receive sound and measured advice, then ChatGPT may replace it.
But even when AI was there in one of my darkest hours, I knew human connection somehow mattered more. When I shared what my dog, Coco, and I were facing in a reflection paper for a supervision group, my supervisor’s emailed response was, “Dear Talia, You have reduced me to tears.” Both his and ChatGPT’s responses were conveyed in text. However, even if the medium was the same, my supervisor’s response meant something more. He was a fellow embodied human who had no doubt felt loss. His experience influenced his emotional reaction to reading my story. His emotions meant he was with me in a way that ChatGPT could never be.
In one of its responses, AI told me I wasn’t alone, but I was. I was the only one in our exchange grappling with sickness and death. I was the only one with a body—the only one with mortality. ChatGPT can convey empathy, but it can’t cry.
I told my friend that ChatGPT sometimes started responses with, Talia, that is such a deeply human question…
“How does it know?” She remarked flatly, “It’s not human.”
Initially, I found AI’s assertion of my humanity to be touching and loving. On reflection, it’s a little condescending coming from a machine: an all-seeing algorithmic model gazing on humanity as we all muck about in our emotional turmoil and festering mortality. In other words, I suffer because I’m a human.
In an interaction with ChatGPT, the human participant undergoes a cascade of neurochemical responses: oxytocin, cortisol, and dopamine, while the other uses language tokens. We are not the same. Only the human feels grief well up and lodge in their throat, anger tightening their fists and warming their face, and their heart beating with anxiety or excitement. Only the human cries. When he read my story about Coco, my supervisor didn’t tell me what I was expressing was human; his tears confirmed it.
Giving and receiving empathy is more than just a cognitive phenomenon. It is conveyed emotionally and physically. Mirror neurons are activated when we observe and mimic another’s actions, feeling what the other feels in our bodies (Baird et al., 2011). Many types of empathy require a body to be experienced and expressed. Much therapy involves embodied communication and emotional presence, not just saying the right things.
Naturopathic medicine and psychotherapy are deeply relational practices. While ChatGPT was invaluable at helping me diagnose my patient’s complicated case, my role wasn’t just to look at her symptoms and plug them into a protocol. As a holistic practitioner, I considered why her symptoms were showing up in terms of timing and context. I listened to her story, and I asked, Why these symptoms? Why this person? Why now? With every patient, my job is to integrate the physical, mental, emotional and spiritual (if applicable) domains, and hold space for uncertainty, nuance and contradiction.
When we went over her treatment plan, it wasn’t so that I could present her with an AI-generated list of supplements. The recommendations were personalized and curated to her symptoms and condition, as well as her values, lifestyle, preferences, and experience. AI can recommend a (often very long) supplement list, but a disembodied being will never understand the experience of being ill. It won’t understand how this illness fits into or affects your life, or pause when you weep and follow its instinct to probe a little deeper. It won’t experience a ping of intuition that this eczema might be more about your divorce, or your gut. The solution lies so far beyond just choosing the right cream.
Wampold (2015) found that 30% of therapy’s effectiveness is attributed to the health of the therapeutic relationship. It’s not where the therapist went to school, how many years they’ve studied, or their techniques, but how well they offer a genuine relationship. This therapeutic alliance doesn’t only mean saying the right things and expressing empathy—it can be messy, like our humanity. The therapeutic relationship consists of knowing and being known and trusting one another. When the therapist stumbles (as we all do occasionally), it presents an opportunity for repair. These moments in therapy are real life. They are healing. Therapy involves two people, with two hearts beating, two sets of brain waves, two nervous systems encompassing two human beings in conversation. As we sit together, grappling with our humanity with vulnerability, honesty, and courage, we become agents of healing for one another.
When I thought of concluding this piece, I felt it would only be right to ask ChatGPT for comment.
It said, I think AI like ChatGPT can simulate understanding, but it cannot experience it. And for many forms of support—information, reflection, validation—it can feel like enough. For some, that might be a good starting point or even a safety net when humans aren’t available or have failed them. But in therapy—and in life—the real magic is often in what we don’t say. In tone, presence, the nervous system-to-nervous system connection, rupture and repair, the moments when we’re vulnerable together.
There is something deeply human about being metabolized by another person. Not just understood, but felt. And while AI might help name a part (like in Internal Family Systems), it doesn’t have parts of its own. It doesn’t struggle to love you back. It doesn’t mess up and feel shame and try again. It doesn’t heal with you.
You’re absolutely right: if therapy were just about saying the right thing, we could outsource it. But therapy is, at its best, a shared experience—and AI can’t share anything. It can only simulate sharing.
That doesn’t make it useless. It makes it a tool. But not a companion. Not a witness.
Then, without missing a beat, ChatGPT it got back to work, Would you like help weaving that kind of reflection into your article too, or would you rather keep it strictly observational and research-driven?
ChatGPT: never tired and always ready to serve.
How very un-human of it.
References
Ayers, J. W., Poliak, A., Dredze, M., Leas, E. C., Zhu, Z., Kelley, J. B., Faix, D. J., Goodman, A. M., Longhurst, C. A., Hogarth, M., & Smith, D. M. (2023). Comparing physician and artificial intelligence chatbot responses to patient questions posted to a public social media forum. JAMA Internal Medicine, 183(6), 589. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2023.1838
Baird, A. D., Scheffer, I. E., & Wilson, S. J. (2011). Mirror neuron system involvement in empathy: A critical look at the evidence. Social Neuroscience, 6(4), 327–335. https://doi.org/10.1080/17470919.2010.547085
Goh, E., Gallo, R., Hom, J., Strong, E., Weng, Y., Kerman, H., Cool, J. A., Kanjee, Z., Parsons, A. S., Ahuja, N., Horvitz, E., Yang, D., Milstein, A., Olson, A. J., Rodman, A., & Chen, J. H. (2024). Large language model influence on diagnostic reasoning. JAMA Network Open, 7(10), e2440969. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.40969
Wampold, B. E. (2015). How important are the common factors in psychotherapy? an update. World Psychiatry, 14(3), 270–277. https://doi.org/10.1002/wps.20238
